Tories were right over 80s South Africa - Tebbit

A portrait of a young Nelson Mandela lays alongside a floral tribute in Cape Town, South Africa. Picture: AP
A portrait of a young Nelson Mandela lays alongside a floral tribute in Cape Town, South Africa. Picture: AP
Share this article
Have your say

Nelson Mandela was the leader of a movement that resorted to terrorism and the Tories were right to shun sanctions against South Africa at the height of the anti-apartheid struggle, former Tory chairman Lord Tebbit has said.

Margaret Thatcher refused to impose economic blocks despite intense diplomatic pressure and branded Mr Mandela’s African National Congress (ANC) “terrorists”.

Less than a year after becoming Conservative leader, David Cameron publicly denounced the approach the Conservatives had taken in the 1980s.

Lord Tebbit told BBC Radio 4’s World At One: “I’m not sure that it was thought that it was our business to instruct South Africa how to manage its internal affairs but we did not think that seeking to damage the South African economy would contribute to the search for a perfect settlement and we were proved right.

“It might have ended it (apartheid) earlier but it would probably have ended it in violence and bitterness and history shows that that was not the way it ended.”

Asked how much credit he gave Mr Mandela for that, he replied: “At the end I gave him enormous credit for it. He was able to come out of prison after 27 years not bitter, not angry and able to look at the world and change his mind on a number of major issues and I think that is a tribute to him.”

The former Conservative Party chairman, who was widely condemned in the 1980s when he claimed there was a “stinking hypocrisy poured out daily” about South Africa, was asked if he regretted comments he made at the time.

“We all sometimes say things rather heatedly that possibly, in retrospect, might have been said more calmly.”

Lord Tebbit dismissed suggestions that he should have regrets about the way the Tory government dealt with South Africa in the 1980s.

“You have to act within the constraints of the time and I get very irritated by people who judge the past by the present. It is not very sensible,” he said.

“After all, if you do that you might finish up declaring that Cromwell was a terrorist and that wouldn’t be a very sensible view to take, would it?”

Reminded that many Conservatives had called Mr Mandela a terrorist in the 1980s, he replied: “He was the leader of a political movement which had begun to resort to terrorism.”

Mr Cameron admitted that Baroness Thatcher had been wrong to brand the ANC “terrorists”.

He flew to South Africa in 2006 and told Mr Mandela: “The mistakes my party made in the past with respect to relations with the ANC and sanctions on South Africa make it all the more important to listen now. The fact that there is so much to celebrate in the new South Africa is not in spite of Mandela and the ANC, it is because of them - and we Conservatives should say so clearly today.”

Mr Cameron wrote an article for The Observer one week later outlining how his impression was “not how violent the armed struggle or Soweto uprisings were, but how restrained”.

• Live blog: reaction to Nelson Mandela’s death

Scotland’s politicians pay tribute to Nelson Mandela

Obituary: Nelson Mandela, former South African president

Jim Murphy on Nelson Mandela’s global influence

Text to display

Glasgow at Mandela’s side on road to freedom