Concerns raised over 'cooling effect' of Scottish Government complaints being passed to police in wake of Alex Salmond inquiry

Complaints about the behaviour of Scottish Government ministers could be referred to the police even if that is against the wishes of alleged victims, sparking fears of a “cooling effect”.

Deputy First Minister John Swinney said the Government may have an "ethical duty" to alert Police Scotland.

SNP MSP Michelle Thomson raised concerns this could put some complainers off.

Read More
Downing Street parties: Dame Cressida Dick confirms Met Police criminal investig...
The Scottish Government overhauled its complaints procedures following the Alex Salmond case. Picture: Andrew Milligan/PA Wire
Hide Ad
Hide Ad

New rules will see complaints about current and former ministers handled by external and independent investigators following the unlawful investigation into claims of sexual harassment by Alex Salmond.

The botched investigation into the former first minister was ruled to be unlawful by the Court of Session, prompting three inquiries into the Government’s handling of the affair and its complaints procedure.

Where a crime may have been committed, the new procedure says the Government "will, wherever possible, respect the wishes of the complainer".

However, it adds there may be circumstances where the Government has "an obligation to bring the matter directly to the attention of the police".

During its handling of the Salmond case, the Scottish Government reported allegations to the police despite the reluctance of complainers.

Speaking at Holyrood's finance and public administration committee on Tuesday, Ms Thomson asked: "What active consideration have you given that that could actually have a cooling effect on complainants – completely the opposite intention?"

Mr Swinney said it was a "very difficult question", but argued there had to be “an acceptance of the particular obligations that apply to Government”.

He said this would be considered on a "case-by-case basis".

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

Earlier, Mr Swinney told the committee: "As an employer, the Scottish Government is not under an absolute duty in all circumstances to report matters that it believes may be a crime to the police. It's not under a statutory duty, as an employer.

"But I would consider that the Scottish Government, for the purposes of ethics, if it considered it had knowledge of a crime having potentially been committed, would have to give very serious consideration to referring that to the police, even if an individual who was a member of staff who was perhaps a victim of that alleged crime did not want that to be the case.”

Responding to Ms Thomson, Mr Swinney said the Government would consider whether it has “got the balance of that thinking correct”.



Want to join the conversation? Please or to comment on this article.