Robert Morris Morgenthau, former district attorney. Born: 31 July 1919 in New York, United States. Died: 21 July 2019 in New York, United States, aged 99.
He seemed almost like he was out of Central Casting – tall and patrician, with a cultivated above-the-fray presence. In fact, former Manhattan District Attorney Robert M Morgenthau inspired some television casting of his own, as the model for the avuncular prosecutor Adam Schiff, played by actor Steven Hill on the long-running television series Law and Order.
Law & Order creator Dick Wolf called Morgenthau “the greatest district attorney in the history of New York”.
Morgenthau spent nearly half of his life jailing criminals from mob kingpins and drug-dealing killers to a tax-dodging Harvard dean.
He served as US Attorney for New York’s southern district during the Kennedy and Johnson administrations, returned to law enforcement as Manhattan’s top state prosecutor in 1974 and didn’t leave for 35 years, with his office handling around 100,000 criminal cases yearly.
In 2005, at 86, Morgenthau was elected for the eighth and last time, turning back a challenge from Leslie Snyder, a popular former state judge who tried without success to turn his age and lengthy tenure into campaign issues.
He was 90 when he stepped down from office in 2009. “I looked at my birth certificate, and I said, ‘It’s about time,”’ he told The Associated Press.
In his position at the forefront of Manhattan’s legal and political scene, Morgenthau was widely acknowledged by allies and foes alike as effective, non-partisan and incorruptible.
Under Morgenthau’s watch, New York County prosecutors took on many high-profile cases: political payoffs by mob boss Anthony “Tony Ducks” Corallo, the shooting of four black youths by white subway gunman Bernhard Goetz, the weapons-possession arrest of hip-hop mogul Sean ‘Diddy’ Combs.
Over the years, Morgenthau’s office also prosecuted mob boss John Gotti, acquitted on state charges of ordering a hit on a union official, and former Tyco CEO L. Dennis Kozlowski, convicted of fraud and larceny in a case seen as an emblem of corporate excess. The office also produced guilty pleas from ‘Preppie Killer’ Robert Chambers Jr. and John Lennon’s killer, Mark David Chapman.
Morgenthau, who had claimed a 97 per cent conviction rate while US attorney, lost the Combs case, but in the late 1990s, his state DA’s office was winning guilty verdicts in three of four cases.
However, Morgenthau insisted that convictions weren’t everything.
“The prosecutor’s job is to protect the public and to administer the laws,” Morgenthau once said, deriding district attorneys who collected convictions like “notches on a gun”.
That premise was put to the test in the Central Park jogger case, one of the most sensational prosecutions handled by his office. Thirteen years after a female jogger was attacked in the infamous gang “wilding” spree, Morgenthau asked a judge in 2002 to throw out the convictions of five men because DNA evidence and another man’s confession put them into question.
Morgenthau was born into a wealthy, prominent New York family. His grandfather, Henry Morgenthau Sr., was US ambassador to the Ottoman Empire during the First World War, and his father, Henry Morgenthau Jr., was secretary of the treasury under President Franklin D. Roosevelt, a family friend.
His childhood reflected his lineage. Morgenthau had a lifelong friendship with members of the Kennedy clan; he once cooked hot dogs with Eleanor Roosevelt for King George VI; on another occasion he prepared a mint julep for Winston Churchill.
He joined the US Navy one day after graduating from Amherst College in 1941 and spent four years in the service during the Second World War, earning the rank of lieutenant commander while seeing action aboard destroyers in the Mediterranean and the Pacific.
After the war, Morgenthau earned a law degree from Yale and joined a New York law firm headed by former US secretary of war Robert P. Patterson.
In 1960, Morgenthau campaigned in New York for his friend and fellow Democrat, John F. Kennedy. The next year, the new president named him to the prestigious post of US attorney for the Southern District of New York, the nation’s busiest such office.
Morgenthau resigned after 17 months to run for governor against incumbent Republican Nelson Rockefeller. After his defeat in a disastrous campaign in 1962, Morgenthau was reappointed federal prosecutor by Kennedy.
Morgenthau developed a reputation for targeting white-collar criminals. In 1963, his office successfully prosecuted former Harvard law school dean James M. Landis for tax evasion. More than 40 years later, as state district attorney, he convicted Kozlowski and a subordinate of looting Tyco of $600 million.
Morgenthau was forced out as federal prosecutor in 1970 by President Richard M. Nixon. He briefly joined Mayor John Lindsay’s administration as a deputy mayor, then waged another losing gubernatorial race before leaving the public eye for the next four years for private law practice.
In 1974, Manhattan District Attorney Frank Hogan resigned due to health problems after 32 years. Morgenthau then launched his first successful run for public office.
Over the next quarter-century, Morgenthau was elected another seven times as head of one of the nation’s largest law offices, with 550 prosecutors and 700 other staffers. Among prominent figures who served in the office was the late John F. Kennedy Jr. and Snyder, who ran against him in 2005.
Snyder mounted a vigorous campaign in which she pointed out that Law & Order had three district attorneys in 17 years on the air whereas Morgenthau had served alone for 30. The New York Times agreed that “three decades is more than enough time for any executive to accomplish his or her mission,” but that endorsement did not help Snyder overcome his advantage at the polls.
In addition to jailing Goetz in the 1984 wounding of four black youths who tried to rob him on a subway train, Morgenthau’s notable convictions included a crack dealer who killed the son of AOL Time-Warner head Gerald Levin; the murderous mother-and-son grifter team, Sante and Kenneth Kimes Jr.; and seven youths who killed a Utah tourist in a subway mugging in 1990.
His civic work included a relationship with the Police Athletic League that dates to 1962, and his position as chairman of the Museum of Jewish Heritage, which opened in 1997.
Morgenthau was survived by his wife, Pulitzer Prize-winning reporter Lucinda Franks, and seven children. His first wife, the former Martha Pattridge, died of cancer in 1972.