J K Rowling says she may sue MP Natalie McGarry

JK Rowling says she is considering legal action against Natalie McGarry
JK Rowling says she is considering legal action against Natalie McGarry
Share this article
Have your say

THE Glasgow East MP Natalie McGarry got more than she bargained for when she made disparaging remarks about the world’s most famous children’s author on Twitter.

A furious row erupted that resulted in JK Rowling suggesting she might sue Ms McGarry after the former SNP representative accused the Harry Potter creator of “defending abusive misogynist trolls” .

Ms Rowling revealed she was considering taking a ­defamation case after Ms McGarry claimed the author had “tweeted support” of a Twitter user, who uses the nom de plume of Brian Spanner QC to attack Scottish Nationalism.

A series of tweets were posted by Ms McGarry, whose political career has been marred by her suspension from the SNP after financial irregularities were discovered in a pro-independence group that campaigned during the referendum.

In a tweet addressed to Ms Rowling, McGarry said: “It is quite simple flee with craws...You tweet supportive tweets of a misogynist Twitter troll.”

The MP then added: “Do you or don’t you tweet supportive tweets of a misogynist and abusive Twitter troll like Brian Spanner. Answer is Yes. Simple.”

Picture: Twitter:

Picture: Twitter:

Ms Rowling replied: “So you need some evidence for that or I’m going to need an apology.”

The author added: “You are a politician making a public accusation. Show me where I have defended abusive, misogynist trolling.”

During the online spat that spanned six hours and involved many participants, Ms McGarry also said she “regretted” queuing to buy Ms Rowling’s books.

Ms McGarry later apologised for “any misguided inference” that Ms Rowling supports misogyny or abuse.

But the row escalated when Ms McGarry subsequently tweeted an image that had been altered to wrongly suggest Ms Rowling had responded “you’re a good man” to an abusive tweet sent by Brian Spanner.

According to the author, Ms McGarry had taken the “good man” tweet out of context. Rather than a response to an abusive tweet, it had actually been posted when Brian Spanner helped to raise money for Ms Rowling’s Lumos children’s charity.

Ms Rowling countered saying: “I assume the apology’s retracted, given the cut and paste screenshot you sent misrepresenting my interaction with BSpanner?” She added: “It is your view that if person A interacts with person B on Twitter, they must be “supportive” of B’s every tweet?”

The threat of legal action surfaced when Ms Rowling tweeted: “You don’t appear to understand how Twitter or defamation works.

“I’m going to help you out with the latter.”

She later suggested that money won from a court case would go towards her Lumos charity. “I’m thinking all damages to @lumos!” she tweeted.

Last night Ms McGarry had made her twitter account private.

The MP, who was elected in May last year at the expense of Labour’s shadow Scottish Secretary Margaret Curran, withdrew from the SNP whip last November.

She quit following allegations that tens of thousands of pounds in donations may be missing from Women for Independence, the campaign group she helped found and which played a prominent role in the 2014 referendum.

Scottish heritage: for stories on Scotland’s people, places and history >>