Time to get real

While I agree with Stefan Slater’s view of the BBC Election Leaders’ Special and Scotland’s Election Special (Letters, 2 May), the campaign highlights the overwhelming need for all aspiring MPs and ministers to have several years of prior “real-world” experience, not necessarily limited to, but preferably including, the private sector. A limited company would not get away with issuing a prospectus (manifesto) followed by further titbits, enticements and bribes in daily dribs and drabs to its actual and potential shareholders.

Nor by rewriting history – Ed Miliband was not forced to concede that public expenditure doubled in real terms from 1998-2008 without equivalent improvements to services; or that much of the “investment” he praised was via PPP/PFI contracts, saddling us with long-term expensive maintenance liabilities and – since he was denying Labour’s responsibility for the increased national debt – which are not even included in our recognised debt figure under our odd public accounting conventions (also unacceptable in company accounts).

Sign up to our Opinion newsletter

John Birkett

Horseleys Park, St Andrews