The Scotsman cartoon: Independence bonus v Union dividend

Competing estimates of the costs and savings of Scottish independence were set out yesterday as the Scottish and UK governments outlined their visions.
Illustration: Iain GreenIllustration: Iain Green
Illustration: Iain Green

The UK Treasury spoke of the “Union dividend”, suggesting every person in Scotland would be £1,400 better off each year by staying in the Union.

The Scottish Government spoke of an ‘independence bonus’ that would make each person £1,000 wealthier.