Bonnie Prince Charlie and the perils of propaganda – leader comment

The characterisation of Bonnie Prince Charlie in Outlander as an "effete weakling"  has been described as a "travesty". PIC: Starz.
The characterisation of Bonnie Prince Charlie in Outlander as an "effete weakling" has been described as a "travesty". PIC: Starz.
0
Have your say

Historian Lucy Worsley has made two BBC series about “history’s biggest fibs” in an attempt to demonstrate that far from being a collection of firmly established facts, our image of the past is often based on stories that the people in power want us to believe.

According to one story, Prince Charles Edward Stuart – aka Bonnie Prince Charlie, aka the Young Pretender – was actually an “effeminate weakling”.

READ MORE: Outlander’s depiction of Bonnie Prince Charlie ‘a travesty’

The 1745 Association, which says it was set up partly to “preserve the memory of those who actively participated in or who had connections with the ‘45”, claims this is how he is portrayed in the popular TV series Outlander in what they describe as a “travesty”.

Outlander had simply swallowed Hanovarian propaganda, as there was “no way that such a man could have mobilised the support he did”, said its chairman Michael Nevin.

Putting aside the debate about the motivational skills of a theoretical “effeminate weakling”, it seems wise to remember that not all of history’s fibs stem from winning side.

Just as Charles may not have been weak, he was perhaps not quite as “Bonnie” either.

READ MORE: 10 surprising facts about Bonnie Prince Charlie