Musicians quicker at correcting mistakes - study

Musicians such as violinist Nicola Benedetti are better able to correct mistakes than those who do not play instruments, according to a new study. Picture: TSPL
Musicians such as violinist Nicola Benedetti are better able to correct mistakes than those who do not play instruments, according to a new study. Picture: TSPL
Share this article
Have your say

SIMPLY playing a musical instrument could sharpen up your brain and help delay the onset of a decline in a person’s mental abilities, according to new research at a leading Scottish university.

Researchers at St Andrews University have uncovered evidence that musicians have sharper minds and are able to pick up mistakes and fix them quicker than the rest of the population.

And they believe their findings suggest that learning to play a musical instrument could protect against the decline in mental abilities through age or illness.

The study, published in the latest edition of the journal Neuropsychologia, states that the findings demonstrate the potential for “far-reaching benefits” of musical activity on mental and physical well-being.

The study was led by St Andrews psychologist Dr Ines Jentzsch, who compared the cognitive ability of amateur musicians versus non-musicians in performing simple mental tasks.

She explained that the most striking difference she found lay in the ability of musicians to recognise and correct mistakes.

They also responded faster than those with little or no musical training, with no loss in accuracy.

Dr Jentzsch, a Reader in the university’s School of Psychology and Neuroscience, said that this was perhaps not surprising since musicians learn to be constantly aware of their performance, but to not be overly affected by mistakes.

She said: “Our study shows that even moderate levels of musical activity can benefit brain functioning. Our findings could have important implications as the processes involved are amongst the first to be affected by aging, as well as a number of mental illnesses such as depression.

“The research suggests that musical activity could be used as an effective intervention to slow, stop or even reverse age- or illness-related decline in mental functioning.”

The study compared groups of amateur musicians with varying levels of time they had spent in practicing their instrument to a non-musician control group.

They then measured each group’s behavioural and brain responses to simple mental tests. The results showed that playing a musical instrument, even at moderate levels, improves the ability to monitor our behaviour for errors and adjust subsequent responses more effectively when needed.

Dr Jentzsch - a keen pianist - continued, “Musical activity cannot only immensely enrich our lives but the associated benefits for our physical and mental functioning could be even more far-reaching than proposed in our and previous research.

“Music plays an important role in virtually all societies.

“Nevertheless, in times of economic hardship, funds for music education are often amongst the first to be cut.”

She added: “We strongly encourage political decision makers to reconsider funding cuts for arts education and to increase public spending for music tuition. In addition, adults who have never played an instrument or felt too old to learn should be encouraged to take up music - it’s never too late.”

The study was partially funded by the Wellcome Trust.


Let the Children Play music lesson campaign success

Key of life: music gives children academic edge and social skills