Rugby brain injuries study sparks call to cut games and end full-contact training sessions

Ex-Scotland rugby players had more than twice the risk of a neurodegenerative disease and a 15-times higher risk of a motor neurone disease diagnosis, a study has found

The results have led to rugby authorities being urged to eliminate contact training and reduce rather than expand the global calendar.

Consultant neuropathologist Prof Willie Stewart, who led the research, said it raised immediate questions for rugby authorities to mitigate the risks.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

“I am genuinely concerned about what is happening in the modern game, and that if, in 20 years’ time, we repeat this study we would see something even more concerning” Stewart said.

Doddie Weir: ex-lock forward is fighting against MND, raising tens of thousands for researchDoddie Weir: ex-lock forward is fighting against MND, raising tens of thousands for research
Doddie Weir: ex-lock forward is fighting against MND, raising tens of thousands for research

Rugby has talked a lot and done a lot about head injury management and whether it can reduce head injury during (training). Those conversations have gone on a while and the pace of progress is pretty slow.

“This should be a stimulus to them to pick up their heels to make some pretty dramatic changes as quickly as possible to try and reduce risk.

“Instead of talking about extending seasons and introducing new competitions and global seasons they should be talking about restricting it as much as possible, cutting back on the amount of rugby we’re seeing and getting rid of as much training as possible.

“Things like that have to be addressed pretty rapidly.”

The study, published in the Journal of Neurology Neurosurgery & Psychiatry, compared health outcomes among 412 male, Scottish, former international rugby players and over 1,200 matched individuals from the general population.

Ex-Scotland and British Lions star Doddie Weir is currently battling MND, which may be linked to head clashes on the rugby pitch.

The study was part-funded by the Football Association and Professional Footballers’ Association, building on the landmark 2019 study which found former professional footballers, such as Celtic legend Billy McNeill, had an approximately three and a half times higher rate of death from neurodegenerative disease than expected.

Stewart said the numbers found had come as a “big surprise” and more work – including a broader study – was now needed to fully understand their meaning, although the immediate message for the game was clear.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

“The hypothesis we’re working on is that head injury exposure in sport increases the risk of neurodegenerative diseases and we’re finding that over and again,” he said. “The story we’re getting from all evidence is that exposure to head injuries is a risk we need to do something about.

“The modern game from 1995 onwards has seen that that head injury exposure go up and up and up as far as I’m concerned.”

He added: “Contact training during the week should be viewed as virtually a thing of the past, getting rid of as much as possible.

“Look at the number of matches being played and ask, ‘Is this credible that young men and women can be playing week-in, week-out, for the majority of the year just for entertainment?’…

“I know it’s tough to think about there being less rugby rather than more but maybe less is more if you see better quality rugby, the players are less damaged and fitter.

“You can’t continue to put young men and women through what they’re being put through now we know even from the amateur era there’s this risk of brain disease.”



Want to join the conversation? Please or to comment on this article.