Parent anger at end to same-sex running races at Highlands school

Same-sex running races have been ended on sports days at a Highlands primary school
Same-sex running races have been ended on sports days at a Highlands primary school
Share this article
Have your say

Parents have hit out at a decision to end boys and girls only races at a primary school sports day in the Scottish Highlands.

The move, by Merkinch Primary School in Inverness, means all the children recently competed together at a sports day.

The decision comes weeks after Highland Council emailed out new guidelines to improve inclusion for pupils who are lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender or intersex.

READ MORE: Remains of Edinburgh Uni man found four years after disappearance

Mother-of-two Melissa Watson said: “It was a big talking point for me and my mates. There was a race between five girls and one boy and he came last and all the boys were like ‘ha, ha ... you got beaten by a girl’.

“In my eyes this opens the kids up to being bullied.

“Why doesn’t the school just let the LGBTI children race with the sex that they feel they belong to, instead of making all the kids run mixed races?”

Another mum, who did not wish to be named, said: “The world has gone mad. I feel for the children in ten to 15 years. I dread to think what it’s going to be like.”

Del McClurg is chairwoman of Merkinch Community Council and her grandchildren attend Merkinch Primary. She said she had “mixed feelings” about the move.

“I think the school needs to explain this to the parents,” she said. “The Olympics don’t do mixed-gender competition sports.”

Head teacher Judith Kean was unavailable for interview, but in a written response she confirmed races were mixed at the sports day held this week and that feedback from parents and children had been positive.

Hugh Torrance, director of Leadership, Equality and Active Participation (LEAP) in Sports Scotland, which published the guidelines emailed by Highland Council to all schools, said: “The guidance has come about as a result of LGBTI pupils working together with schools to try and address some particularly difficult issues that pupils have experienced within physical education in particular.

“We have suggested that pupils should not be segregated according to sex unless it’s necessary.

“The evidence points to there being no differences between the genders when it comes to sport pre-puberty, but the manifesto is not saying that we need to do away with gender segregation completely in sport. That’s not how the world is set up at the moment.”

Morgan Cowley, former chairman of the Highland LGBTI forum that campaigns for the fair treatment of all LGBTI people, said: “I think introducing non-gender specific sports days into schools is rather a clumsy way of trying to address the crux of the matter within our schools, which is promoting respect for one another and celebrating difference.

“There are undoubtedly more astute ways of doing this and what Merkinch Primary is doing seems to be increasing conflict rather than reducing it.

“Trying to promote nongender specific sports into schools at this point in our society’s development, when the whole world celebrates and enjoys gender-specific sport at the highest levels, seems a hard sell.”