Chess

IT'S a timeless debate that willcontinue through the ages:

comparing today's champions

with the great champions of the

past. But earlier this year the

most detailed computer study

ever conducted hailed Bobby

Fischer as the best player ever.

On truechess.com, researcher

Charles Sullivan explained how

he ran 12 computing threads

24 hours a day for 15 months

to analyse 18,785 games of

the champions since the first,

Wilhelm Steinitz in 1886. Based

on Rybka and Crafty programs,

he compared the moves chosen

in more than 600,000 positions

with a norm called "average

grandmaster move".

Sullivan found that in his best

year, 1968, Fischer's choices

were better than the average

GM move more than 40 per

cent of the time. Current world

champion Vishy Anand, in his

best year, 2006, was second

with 31 per cent. Vladimir

Kramnik and Vasily Smyslov

interesting battle for second

place." His remark was not

hubris, but that of someone

who knew he was nearing his

peak of chess perfection - and

he only allowed four draws in

his commanding victory.

R Fischer - A Matanovic

Vinkovci, 1968

Ruy Lopez, Chigorin variation

1 e4 e5 2 Nf3 Nc6 3 Bb5 a6

4 Ba4 Nf6 5 0–0 Be7 6 Re1

b5 7 Bb3 d6 8 c3 0–0 9 h3

Nd7 10 d4 Bf6 11 a4 Na5 12

Bc2 Nb6 13 b4 Nac4 14 a5

Nd7 15 Bb3 exd4 16 cxd4 c5

17 Bf4 cxb4 18 Nbd2 d5 19

exd5 Nxa5 20 Bd6 Nxb3 21

Qxb3 Re8 22 Bc7 Rxe1+ 23

Rxe1 Qxc7 24 Re8+ Nf8 25

Qxb4 Be7 26 Rxe7 Qd8 27

Ne5 Ng6 28 Nc6 Qf8 29 Qc5

a5 30 Rc7 Qe8 31 d6 Bd7 32

Ne7+ Kh8 33 d5 a4 34 Nb1

Nf8 35 Na3 f6 36 Rb7 Qh5

37 Nxb5 a3 38 Nxa3 Qd1+ 39

Kh2 Qd2 40 Qe3! Qa5 41 Nc4

Qa6 42 Qb3 Ba4 43 Qb4 Nd7

44 Nb2 1–0

- who sadly passed away this

year, aged 85 - were tied for

third at better than 21 per cent.

Anand is also a distant

second to Fischer when the

research is expanded to cover

the best two-year periods of

the champions. Fischer also

holds a dominating lead over

second-placed Garry Kasparov

in his best five-year spread.

In 1968 at Vinkovci, Croatia,

Fischer commented before the

start that "There will be an