Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement

Drink Driving, Don't Risk It!

'Don't lie about Russia's war history'

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 20 May 2009
RUSSIAN president Dmitry Medvedev has formed a commission to protect Moscow's version of Second World War history from "falsifications", amid growing concern over attempts to downplay or criticise the country's war record.
A presidential decree posted on the Kremlin's website said "the commission will engage in the compilation and analysis of information on the falsification of historical facts and events, directed at lowering the international prestige of the Russian
Federation".

It comes days after the president warned against anybody questioning Russian history and its wartime sacrifice – millions of Soviet civilians and soldiers died in years of bloody fighting and German occupation .

"We will not allow anybody to cast doubt on the achievement of our nation," he said. "We should not close our eyes to the terrible truth of war. History teaches you nothing, only punishes you for ignorance of its lessons."

The new commission, which will be headed by Sergei Naryshkin, the president's chief of staff, and made up of 28 government officials, will also "counter efforts of historical falsifications against the interests of Russia".

That welding of an official interpretation of history to Russian national interests serves as an indication of Moscow's determination to quell what Mr Medvedev described on his internet blog as "more and more harsh, depraved and aggressive" attempts to rewrite history.

In particular, Russia has been angered by the growing confidence of former Soviet republics and satellite states in challenging or rejecting Moscow's version of the war, which paints it very much in terms of good versus evil, and of defence and liberation.

The three Baltic states, which were invaded and annexed by Stalin in 1940, have sparked Russian ire by regarding the Red Army as occupiers rather than liberators after its soldiers drove German forces out in the latter years of the war.

Latvians who served in the infamous SS still parade together, and earlier this year the tiny Baltic state said it would bill Russia for £130 billion in compensation for damages caused by the "occupation". In 2007, Estonia caused outrage in Russia after it decided to relocate a contentious Soviet war memorial – a move described at the time by Sergie Lavorv, Russia's foreign minister, as "blasphemous".

Russia was further angered last month when posters praising a Ukrainian SS division appeared in the western Ukrainian town of Lviv, while Kiev's government is pushing for recognition of the nationalist Ukrainian Insurgents Army, which, after fighting German forces, maintained armed resistance to Soviet control up to the mid-1950s.

However, such steps could soon risk not only the wrath of the Kremlin also that of the Russian legal system.

Vladimir Putin, the Russian prime minister, has started work on legislation aiming to make it a crime to belittle or deny the key role Russian forces played in defeating Nazi Germany.

The bill envisages a three-year prison sentence for anybody who "rehabilitates Nazism" by sullying the achievements of Soviet forces.

Commenting on the legislation, parliamentary speaker Boris Gryzlov said: "We are seeing what is happening in some of the ex-Soviet states. You cannot stay indifferent when politicians and parties try to justify Nazism."

Liberal Kremlin critics said, however, that Mr Medvedev's commission amounted to an effort to airbrush Soviet history. Author Yulia Latynina said it played into the hands of "mastodons in epaulets" – ultraconservatives among Russia's historians and politicians.

"The whole idea was copied from Orwell's 1984 and from the famous phrase about Russia as a country with an unpredictable past," she said. "This commission will finally turn Medvedev into a laughing stock."





Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 19 May 2009 10:14 PM
  • Source: The Scotsman
  • Location: Edinburgh
  • Related Topics: Russia , World War II
 
1

2dogs in D.C.,

20/05/2009 01:01:48
Let it go.It's done,let it, go move on.The Allies won,thank what be.
2

Kenny A,

20/05/2009 01:12:37
Russia was both great and evil in WW2, cannot change history.
3

Tom in Belmont,

Belmont 20/05/2009 02:16:26
Russia cannot alter the fact that it suffered as a jilted partner rather than as a true victim. Stalin was happy to conspire with Hitler to divide Poland and seize the Baltic states, invade Finland (which nearly suffered the same fate), and after the war to treat every Soviet minority that hated Russian oppression as a "fascist". The suffering and courage of the average Soviet citizen of the day cannot blanket the devious scheming (and often utter stupidity) of the Communist leadership.
4

,

20/05/2009 02:20:53
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
5

greenhill,

20/05/2009 09:44:34
If the Nazis did not attack Russia then they would still have been allies.

Bulldog Ha! more like Bulls**t
6

Arminius,

Bei Uelzen 20/05/2009 11:39:37
"millions of Soviet civilians and soldiers died in years of bloody fighting and German occupation" - The Soviet Union lost a lot of people during WW2 but not all of these casualties were sustained "liberating" the Soviet Union. The Soviet Union attacked Poland in 1939 and Finland in 1940 as well as annexing the Baltic States. It sustained casualties because of the incompetance and recklessness of its own commanders (the Winter War being a prime example) and also to the execution squads of the NKVD if they tried to withdraw. Soviet citizens died fighting in the uniform of the Germans because they so opposed to Communist oppression. They also died fighting partisans in the Baltic States and Ukraine until long after the Germans had surrendered. Even Soviet prisoners of war, who survived the hell of German POW camps, suffered and died in the Gulags of Siberia because they were regarded as traitors for choosing capture over death for the motherland.
Also the "liberation" of Eastern Europe and the East of Germany by the Red Army was marred by a catalogue of rape, looting and murder.
Now Putin is working hard to criminalise anyone who points out these rather inconvenient facts.
7

,

20/05/2009 14:43:05
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
8

Selgovae,

20/05/2009 19:31:28
#2 Kenny A

"cannot change history."

Course you can.

Anyway, I'm just glad Word War II was won by Wing Commander Buffy Morrison and his gang.
9

Dave Crassman,

17/07/2009 13:49:36
If it wasn't for the Russians the Germans would have won the war and that's a fact.
10

Phil the Flooter,

24/07/2009 10:52:15
Unfortunately some young Germans are rewriting history to show their forefathers were the 'goodies' and we (particularly the RAF) were the Baddies. This is because all the old soldiers from both sides are dying out and are not around to give these whipper snappers a good slap.
Then we get the young American Punks whose sole knowledge of history is gained from Hollywood films.. 'If it wasnt for us you Limeys would be speaking German/eating sausage etc etc..' with not a clue about the involvement of Soviet troops in WW2.

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
 

Today's Vote

Is the government right to continue with its policy of cutting down quangos?
No, I think their independence means we get a better job
Yes, they are unaccountable and expensive
Only if their work is duplicated or plainly redundant

Web Links:



Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.