Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement

 
 
Thursday, 4th December 2008

Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the The Scotsman site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

Sarah Palin - Wonder who she reminds you of?



Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 04 September 2008
Sarah Palin is the image of a certain superheroine, but don't expect John McCain's running mate to fight for female rights
ALL week she's been reminding me of someone; and now, suddenly, I know who it is. There's the firm but pretty jaw-line, the lean, fit-looking figure, the sense of tremendous power and potency all pent up behind the Moneypenny spectacles and neat suits of a super-efficient secretary. Yup, Sarah Palin, the new Republican candidate for Vice-President of the United States, is a dead ringer for Wonder Woman, that 1970s icon of unleashed female power who would step aside from her role as tightly buttoned assistant to some bloke, do a quick twirl and emerge in an explosion of energy as a fabulous female freedom fighter in a drop-dead sexy costume – "in your satin tights, fighting for your rights, and the old red, white and blue", as the theme song put it.

Over the next few months there will be endless attempts by the Republican camp to portray Palin as a typical all-American Mom, wrestling with the everyday problems of family life, including the unplanned pregnancy of her 17-year-old daughter, Bristol. But let's be clear that, like Margaret Thatcher before her, this woman is no ordinary wife and mother.

At a time of crushing family responsibilities, when she has five children under 20 – including a four-month-old Down's Syndrome baby and a teenage daughter expecting a child within weeks of the presidential election – Palin has done what few family men, never mind women, would do and decided to accept one of the most demanding, all-consuming job offers on earth. It will take her 3,000 miles from home if the election is won and subject her family to relentless public scrutiny throughout. So, we can take it that we're dealing with an exceptional level of ambition here, real gold-star-headband stuff.

The only problem, though, is that – just six days on from her own explosion from relative obscurity to global fame – the new Vice-Presidential Candidate appears to be a Wonder Woman without the twirl. Palin obviously has the driving ambition and quite possibly the ability; but to judge by her fixed, Stepford Wives-like smile and 1950s retro hairdo, she is a woman determined never to know that exhilarating moment of freedom, when the power and sexuality become unchained from the rules of a world shaped by men.

From her early days as a gun-toting Alaskan beauty queen, through her adult life as a Pentecostal Christian and passionate campaigner against abortion, Palin has been one of those women smiled upon by traditional male power-brokers – or at least, those who have escaped her admirable anti-corruption drives – because she is prepared to trash feminism, along with most other socially and environmentally progressive ideas. And now, in an apotheosis of that male-sponsored career-pattern, she has been propelled in a single day from the outer edges of American politics to its dead centre, by the favour of an elderly male politician who famously likes to surround himself with good-looking former beauty queens.

What a fool Hillary Clinton must feel, for imagining that she could best reach the centre of American power by forging an independent career as a Senator, then fighting her own way through one of the most exhausting primary campaigns in US history.

Well, enough. For whatever public line Palin chooses to take on women's rights, at least she will never be able to join convincingly in the growing right-wing mantra that women cannot "have it all"; Palin evidently does have it all and may soon be just a heartbeat away from the biggest job on earth. Of course, those of us who retain some real attachment to the idea of freedom may ask ourselves just how free Bristol Palin is feeling today, in her hugely public decision to marry the boyfriend who got her pregnant. There was a time, a generation ago, when women would fight – in or out of satin tights – against that kind of crude biological determinism in girls' lives; I dare say Hillary Clinton can remember some of those battles.

But this is not the age of Clinton, as Barack Obama's dismal choice of running-mate has made clear. It is the age of Sarah Palin, the Wonder Woman who believes that twirling is wrong and who, instead, puts her formidable power at the disposal of the male leader, to use as he sees fit.

The full article contains 764 words and appears in The Scotsman newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 03 September 2008 7:46 PM
  • Source: The Scotsman
  • Location: Edinburgh
  • Related Topics: US elections
 
1

AmyEm,

UK 04/09/2008 01:16:54
Interesting that you would have been reminded of Wonder Woman. Myself, I was at first strongly reminded of Marcia Gay Harden's portrayal of the character Mrs Carmody in the recent King adaption "The Mist". But then I remembered the movie "Drop Dead Gorgeous", and Kirstie Alley's turn as Gladys Leeman... that's Palin!

http://uk.youtube.com/watch?v=9LZRI9bibWg
2

Wally,

By The Rivers Of Babylon (USA) 04/09/2008 01:57:14
perhaps we Americans can enjoy some alcoholic beverages and forget (for a while). I really like this song about RedNecks, WhiteSox and BlueRibbonBeer.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nb7g34aqUg0

Like other peoples we will be loyal to our nation no matter what happens to it.

I thought from the beginning that she was similar to Wonder Woman.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=M_blOQEu9ws

http://ap.google.com/article/ALeqM5jQD-Ub1QQZgszKZ4ddpQBmVCevOQD92VI7OG0
3

XPAT,

Fife, UK 04/09/2008 04:33:28
Ooooh, nicely done Joyce!

Yes, let's hope American women who long for justice and equality will not put their hopes in this molded plastic doll!
4

American girl,

Liberal East Coast 04/09/2008 05:41:03
Ms. Palin reminds me of every American woman who sees through Obama's vapid, feel good speeches. She is a strong woman who will be a strong advocate for the American way of life. Although this may not appeal to you at The Scotsman, we Americans love her and she will be our next Vice President! It's a shame that Europeans have turned against the people that stood with you during your most difficult days. Next time you're in trouble, go to Mr. Putin. I'm certain that he'll be glad to assist you... for a very dear price, your freedom.
5

r1niceboy,

Nebraska 04/09/2008 05:56:57
#4 Ms. Palin reminds me of every American who voted for Bush twice and thinks it's Ok for Bin laden to still be free, pay more than we can afford at the pump, not be able to afford healthcare, and happily watch our kids dumbed down by PTA members who believe in social control more than their own cildren's future, who think that abstinence only education is fine while their teen kids pop out babies, and that anyone who doesn't do what the Republicans tell them is a terrorist.

That's what she reminds me of.
6

American girl,

liberal east coast 04/09/2008 06:11:44
Nebraska is one of our "angry young men" who we've had just about enough of. Brainwashed by David Axelrod's puppet, Barack, his rhetoric is memorized and repeated, parrot-like, at every given opportunity. Sara Palin will be the wake up call that many of these zombie-like followers need to snap them out of their reverie.
7

Let's have the truth,

Queensland 04/09/2008 06:31:13
"Sarah Palin - Wonder who she reminds you of?"

....Paris Hilton with spectacles.
8

Wally,

By The Rivers Of Babylon (USA) 04/09/2008 06:47:21
Follow-up on #7:

it saddens me that you say that as I know that the view of someone outside perceives things that a person inside does not see.

Sarah Palin stood before the nation on national tv and told everyone that she told congress 'no' on the bridge to nowhere. But when she was running for governor she campaigned publicly that she supported the bridge to nowhere. That was when the US Congress was scheduled to provide about $390 million in funding. When the US Congress cut the funding back to something like $80 million and told Alaska to cover the rest, that is when Sarah Palin decided 'no' on the bridge to nowhere. Palin lied blatantly on national tv.

Deception is a tool of the enemy.
9

11+failed,

the pans 04/09/2008 08:11:31
Another article by a disappointed sycophantic Hillary supporter unable to recognise real talent. Quite amusing to read the mostly factually wrong tittle tattle from democrats who idolise the disgusting Bill Clinton who managed to make America a laughing stock worldwide. Even the cattle market in Fort William had a bull and fat cow with Bill and Monica around their necks.
10

Teofilio Cubillas,

04/09/2008 09:08:26
#4 "It's a shame that Europeans have turned against the people that stood with you during your most difficult days."

No disrespect to the brave Americans who died on European soil (I've paid my respects on Omaha beach - have you?) but spare us the bilge about how the USA came to our rescue. The US was quite content to stand on the sidelines making a fortune from Britain via lend lease and then only entered the war because Germany declared war on her after Pearl Harbour. And as regards your rather snide comment about Mr Putin, in the final analysis, Germany was not beaten by either the US or the UK but by the Soviet Union. Read some history instead of Fox news.
11

AmyEm,

04/09/2008 09:29:39
"Another article by a disappointed sycophantic Hillary supporter unable to recognise real talent."

See where the URL says "The Scotsman"? I doubt very strongly that Joyce McMillan is a disappointed sycophantic Hillary supporter, because McMillan is no more likely to vote in this election than any other Scottish journalist. To be honest, I shouldn't think she cares all that much about the outcome of the election either; I don't, but do enjoy reading about the soap opera that is American election. Hence, the 'You just say that because you're a disappointed Democrat' reflex would seem out of place here. As for turning against the people who stood by you etc, what has discussion of individual American politicians to do with WWII? Election rhetoric - laughably silly.
12

Let's have the truth,

Queensland 04/09/2008 09:42:11
This says it all:

http://www.mirror.co.uk/news/top-stories/2008/09/04/is-sarah-palin-the-worst-running-mate-in-history-115875-20723110/
13

Malc.F,

france 04/09/2008 09:43:16
No 10 Dead right
14

Let's have the truth,

Queensland 04/09/2008 10:02:15
#4

"She is a strong woman who will be a strong advocate for the American way of life".

That's what clear thinking people are worried about. America has made it a "Way of life" to impose its militaristic will on any tinpot state that has the temerity to voice a contrary opinion.

She would do the world a service by returning to the obscurity of the Arctic.
15

Let's have the truth,

Queensland 04/09/2008 10:08:24
#4

"It's a shame that Europeans have turned against the people that stood with you"

What an idiotic statement. Do you also have the same opinion about the majority of your countrypeople who believe McCain and this Palin woman is a total disaster not only for America but for the rest of the world too?
16

Puzzler,

Edinburgh 04/09/2008 10:14:17
Sarah Palin is the middle class left's worst nightmare -a successful woman with a mind of her own, who doesn't belong to their club.

If Hilary Clinton had been subjected to any of this there would have been howls of protest.

She has disabled baby - the nasty undertone is that he should have had a temination, and that by not doing so, she is exposed as a religious crank. Now commentators are implying that she should stay home and look after him. What cheek.

Her daughter is pregnant - its quite surreal to see so-called liberals taking cheap shots at a 17 year old who has made a mistake - once again counselling abortion and advising Palin to stay home.

She has a gun and goes hunting - she lives in Alaska for God's sake! Slagging her as a gun nut makes about as much sense as criticising a Scottish politician for owning a pair of hiking boots and a fishing rod.

She eats moose meat - and? your point being? Moose are indigenous to the state. It makes a lot more environmental sense to hunt and eat them than bring in alien species like cows and clear miles of forest to provide grazing.

So basically Palin is supposedly a thick docile breeding machine with a slapper of a daughter, who is a gun nut and knows nothing. Compared with Obama, the preferred liberal candidate who is mixed race but in every other way just another member of the Ivy league elite.

The upshot of most of the criticism of this woman is that she is not a member of a very small, self selecting crowd of influential people, mainly based at Washington, mainly very rich and mainly lawyers.

Somone once said, never underestimate your enemy. They are treating this woman as a fool because she is not one of them. They are wrong. I think we are going to see the public humiliation of the democratic party in this election.
17

American girl,

04/09/2008 12:40:45
To # 10 If you think that I believe for one minute that you fought on Omaha beach, you're daft. But then, you never did say that you fought, did you? If you are offended by my Putin comment, then your political bent is evident. Good luck. As for # 15, I live in the United States and know the truth about what goes on here, not simply by reading "The Scotsman". If the McCain/Palin ticket frightens you and your brethren, be afraid, be very afraid, because they will be the next president and vice president of our beautiful, powerful, unapologetic country!
18

Palermo,

04/09/2008 12:47:01
#16 well said

good on this high-achieving woman. many of her critics will not be parents themselves, I should imagine, and possibly less able to appreciate the greatness of achieving a balance of happy home life and success in the toughest of glass-ceilinged careers.

#11 - AmyEm
Have to say I disagree with you...I very much suspect that Joyce McMillan and others like her have a very clear opinion of who they want to win this election, whether they can vote in it or not.

Just like the last 2 times, people like the BBC and the Scotsman (Sunday Times too I have to say) have been rattling on about how great the Democrats are, how sinister the Republicans are, and having a quite distasteful superiority complex as they laugh up their sleeves at just how crazy these dumb Americans would be if they vote for someone who ticks any of the following boxes (each of which are appraently anathema to the liberal establishment in the UK):
a living faith, pride in their roots, family, a non-metropolitan background, and worst of all, wait-for-it, an occasional slip-up in terminology when speech-making.

Now, I'm down with you syntax stormtroopers on the last point, but really, the rest is surely none of anyone's business but those who have a vote??

I'm already looking forward to a THIRD re-rerunning of Huw Edwards, the day after the election, looking shellshocked and gloomy outside the white house, sporting the kind of look that says "I didn't see THAT coming"

19

AmyEm,

04/09/2008 19:19:14
#18

Other than your inexplicable reference to family, yes, one could merge the extremes of viewpoint in current discourse to build some more of those irregular verbs made famous by Yes Minister (if you're familiar with those; an example is "I give confidential security briefings/You leak/He has been charged under section 2a of the Official Secrets Act")

* I have a living faith/you worship/she is a religious fundamentalist.
* I have pride in my roots/you respect your origins/she is a gun-toting separatist nationalist.
* I have a non-metropolitan background/you're not from round here/she is an underqualified redneck.

Wherever you stand on the spectrum, it's great fun to watch the fireworks. And if it doesn't seem that way, then it may be a sign that one is taking the rhetoric too personally. The discourse is all the more hilarious to those with no particular axe to grind, simply because it is ridiculous. So yes, I will laugh at the craziness, the sectarian PC language, the stereotypes, the apple pie goodness and the carefully-engineered appearance of mediocrity. When Gordon Brown finally lets us have an election in the UK, I fully expect to spend a good deal of time poking fun at British politics, too. Feel free to do the same!
20

daveserviceman,

edinburgh 04/09/2008 22:50:31
sarah Palin reminds me of the female president in Commander in Chief has the same manorisms and family
similarities
21

jamurai,

05/09/2008 02:51:06
no.17 Most of us reading the Scotsman aren't particularly interested in what goes on "inside" the United States, rather in what they do outside. The McCain/Palin ticket with their bullish "patriotic" rhetoric is a danger to this world. It seems to be contagious too- I couldn't beleive that CNN paused their coverage of the convention yesterday so the pundits could stand up for the Star Spangled Banner.
I don't exactly know what you are doing reading the Scotsman anyway. As someone above mentioned, Fox News is where you'll find what you want.
22

Wally,

By The Rivers of babylon (USA) 05/09/2008 04:28:05
Jamurai in 21: there's a web-site that monitors traffic on web-sites all over the world, forgot the name of it. Some time ago I checked it for traffic on Scotsman.com. About 57% of the people that read Scotsman on-line are in the UK. About 25% are in the US. amazing. If you go to the english language version of AlJazeera you'll find that a lot of the comments there are made by Americans also. In our own country controversial comments on many web-sites are not allowed.
23

Dragonhead,

Dalian,China 05/09/2008 05:01:53
American Girl. Save your breath dear lady.You are wasting it on the leftie cabal in UK, particularly in Scotland. So out of touch with reality, that they should be more pitied than scorned. I have not stood on Omaha Beach. Instead I stood with my comrades on the beach at Iron Bottom Sound in the Solomon Islands at Dawn on ANZAC DAY 25th of April 1991. One of the most moving dawns of my life. To know that 50 major warships lie on the bottom within actual eyesight range,was a sobering moment.It showed me the commitment of the Americans in defending 'FREEDOM' was not some propoganda,but real heroism. To the lefties, come and speak to the people of north east China about your friends the Russians who 'liberated them' from the Japanese and stayed for over a decade!I have seen both sides of the coin up close and personal.Even the French Secret service said:"We don't trust them because they are communists, but because they are Russians",says it all. Georgia sound familiar? They 'liberated' South Ossetia and Abkhasia,how long will they stay there?
Watched Sarah Palin live on CNN here in China. Impossible I hear the dross exclaim.Believe your own B*llsh*t, we know it to be such.
For the detractors of this woman,male or female,she has more balls than the lot of you. Obama is a hollow vessel. Who really, really pulls his strings? There are none as blind as those who WILL not see. Awa back tae yer cloth caps and marxist principles!
24

jamurai,

05/09/2008 05:17:04
I assume no23 your mission is to reform those capitalist Chinese from within then? What a lot of irrelevant dross.
25

,

05/09/2008 05:32:47
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
26

Dekester,

Canada's westcoast 05/09/2008 17:15:39
Brilliant #16..thank you for that.

Palin is an incrdible lady..

C'mon drones. Get at it.
27

r1niceboy,

Nebraska 06/09/2008 00:03:18
She reminds me of an amalgam of all the southern GOP congressman, but with a womb and a hatred of moose.
28

Macbeth 1616,

Fife 06/09/2008 09:35:58
McCain is older than any previous candidate. Unfortunately, statistically he has to be more likely to be hit by illness/death than any of his predecessors. His choice of VP may therefore be more relevant than in any other previous election.

The majority of the criticism of Obama has been about his inexperience, both domestically and on foreign affairs. It is impossible for the Democrats to say that he has foreign experience because demonstrably he has not.

The same HAS to be said of Palin. She has no experience outside of Alaska, and has two years as governor of a state with under 700,000 residents. So about the size of Glasgow.

Palin and Obama are clearly good at oratory, they both wowed their own supporters.

The issue for me, and others in Scotland, seems to be how the US will act in the world, rather than how it acts within its own borders. We see reports of Republicans views on abortion, rounding-up immigrants and creationism and generally shake our heads in disbelief.

What does matter though is where the US will invade next, in which country will the US empire deploy its huge military strength. Where will it whip up a storm to justify more conflict, where will it next go and torture people it doesn't like the look of, or bomb the hell out of villages that may have some suspects in.

If war has to be around, then I want the world to be led by someone who understands that the bigger battle is global warming. I want someone to take the lead and say "STOP" before it's too late. Obama seems to understand this, although I'm not 100% convinced. Palin absolutely does not.

The US (Bush) argument against doing anything about global warming is that it may be detrimental to the US economy. Palin, in her small town way, takes this even further down and recognises it may have a detrimental effect on Alasks. I don't want a world leader who is concerned only about themselves, or their 700,000-resident state, I want them to be a WORLD leader.

With powe
29

Let's have the truth,

In a bomb shelter 07/09/2008 03:56:16
"Sarah Palin - Wonder who she reminds you of?"

Come to think of it she does look like one of those Abu Ghraib guards.
30

Hollycrud,

London, England 07/09/2008 14:32:31
I was wondering who Joyce McMillan reminded me of. Then it hit me. Blunder Woman.

"What a fool Hillary Clinton must feel, for imagining that she could best reach the centre of American power by forging an independent career as a Senator, then fighting her own way through one of the most exhausting primary campaigns in US history."

Mrs Clinton is nothing except an addendum to her husband's career. She got her Senatorial seat because of her husband. She built her whole career on the coat-tails of a philandering man, while trashing all the women he abused.

Without him she would be some obscure lobbyist/corporate lawyer hack in the boondocks. Yes, she only got a partnership in a law firm after her husband became Governor of Arkansas

And you dare call her "indpendent" and slam the woman who came from nothing and did it all herself. Laughable. Stick to writing about stuff you know something about Blunder Woman.

Oh... and I memo to all those deluded Brits posting here slamming Palin. Ordinary Americans don't give a flying Scotsman about your ignorant opinions, and think you should concentrate on establishing decent dentistry before lecturing them.

Seriously.. this from a country where a recent survey showed that 25% of British kids couldn't find their own country on an atlas. What a bunch of doofus hicks.
31

AmyEm,

08/09/2008 13:32:06
Politics is an endless source of amusement, it really is :-D

"Ordinary Americans don't give a flying Scotsman about your ignorant opinions, and think you should concentrate on establishing decent dentistry before lecturing them."

If this is so, why are you, presumably an ordinary American (your declared location aside), apparently wasting your time lecturing the Scottish about ignorant opinions? Does that count as more or less effort than giving a flying Scotsman? But perhaps you are an exceptional American who, by contrast to the ordinary common and garden variety, tends to care deeply about ignorant opinions held by Brits, and is excused the usual national pastime of morbidly contemplating the state of the nation's teeth. Or does one find time to obsess about both? Since you brought it up, as an exceptional American, how do you feel about the fascination the oral holds for your kinsfolk? Is it healthy, do you think?

"a recent survey showed that 25% of British kids couldn't find their own country on an atlas"

Incidentally, did you know that 99% of all statistics are made up on the spot? As Wikipedians tend to put it: [citation needed]. Let me provide that reference for you: you are incorrectly quoting National Geographic Kids, who surveyed around a thousand 6 to 14 year old children in a publicity stunt survey around the time of their UK launch. To mock the British correctly, the widely reported statistic you are looking for is 'one in five', or 20%. However, you would be ill-advised to do so. Let us examine National Geographic's body of data. Anybody who reads the full-scale 2002 comparative National Geographic survey (summarised at http://news.nationalgeographic.com/news/2002/11/1126_021120_TVGeoRoperSurvey.html) will note that on geographical knowledge, "Sweden scored highest; Mexico, lowest. The U.S. was next to last." Fun factoids abound - for example, almost a third of young adult Americans think that the US has a population of between one and two
32

AmyEm,

08/09/2008 13:33:17
billion, half of young adult Americans (not aged six, but 18-24) can't find New York on a map, etc.

The study concludes that English-speaking countries in general have a major problem with geography and to some extent geopolitics. If you want to take the British down a peg, the data supports you in saying that (whilst the USA is pretty badly off) English-speaking young adults in general, be they British, American or Canadian, are all pretty ignorant of local and global geography. Incidentally, it also supports the hypothesis that those who read widely, travel widely and pay critical attention to several media sources are more likely to know something about the world (incidentally, Palin first got a passport in 2007).

You brought up ignorance as an issue; National Geographic have reminded us all that there are a wealth of information sources around, and that we should all be making use of them. We would then be in a position to make informed decisions. You remind us that in your opinion, ordinary Americans do not care to hear the conflicting opinions of others. That would be a sad reflection indeed, if I believed it, but I don't.

In my experience, whilst blind patriotism and personality politics tend to cause people to react first and think later, most Americans I've met have been intelligent, able, thoughtful individuals who are able to handle (and give!) useful criticism. Frankly, I think your characterisation of your nation is both inaccurate and unfair.

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.