The Sixth sense
I am surprised that Professor Hugh McLachlan (Perspective, 19 December) should draw a distinction between “the ethics of the matter” and “the practical questions of whether euthanasia and assisted suicide should be permitted and, if so, in what specific circumstances”.
They cannot be so readily separated. He assumes, without rigorous supporting arguments, that euthanasia and assisted suicide can be ethically justified and then leaves the “practical questions” open for debate. Are ethical standards not to be applied to them?
Prof McLachlan seems to have an idiosyncratic version of Christianity, which has nothing to say about ethics or politics. He misinterprets the New Testament to support his views. However, both Jesus and Paul reaffirm the Ten Commandments, including the sixth, and give them a much deeper application than to merely the outward actions.
So reverence for human life, as made in God’s image, must be our starting point. Love for one’s neighbours demands that we do all we can to preserve life and reduce suffering by holistic care until death supervenes. His allusions to pacifism and vegetarianism are red herrings and have nothing to do with the issue.
Prof McLachlan is wrong to claim that “the debate does not revolve around the points alluded to” by Rev Sally Foster-Fulton, namely personal autonomy and human dignity.
These are two of the most common arguments used by proponents of euthanasia and assisted suicide.
For example: “It’s my life and I have a right to end it when I want and to have help to do so if I am unable to,” and: “When I have lost my independence and dignity, I want to have my life ended on my terms in a dignified way.”
It is impossible in a short letter to answer all of Prof McLachlan’s points, but I hope I have said enough to stimulate further reflection on this serious issue. I believe there is a strong ethical case against assisted suicide and that it should not be legalised.
(Rev Dr) Donald M MacDonald
How can Hugh McLachlan support his argument that questions of “assisted dying” are practical not ethical?
In the same sentence in which this is asserted he goes on to ask whether euthanasia and assisted suicide should be permitted.
Old Chapel Walk
Search for a job
Search for a car
Search for a house
Weather for Edinburgh
Saturday 18 May 2013
Temperature: 8 C to 12 C
Wind Speed: 25 mph
Wind direction: East
Temperature: 9 C to 17 C
Wind Speed: 7 mph
Wind direction: North east