MEMBERS ONLY. THE LIFE AND TIMES OF PAUL RAYMOND
by Paul Willetts
Serpent's Tail, 320pp, £14.99
ONE thing about Christopher Hitchens – you can always rely on him to say the unsayable. And as our panel discovers there's plenty to argue about in his new memoir.
IN his new book, the BBC's World Affairs Editor casts a critical eye over how the 20th century was reported. Newsnight Scotland's presenter and two former Scotsman editors join our panel to discuss it.
SARAH Bakewell's lively account of the great 16th-century French nobleman-philosopher spins off from his homely discourses on human nature. Does the strategy work?
Marina Lewycka's award-winning debut novel, A Short History of Tractors in Ukrainian, was witty and inventive – so why do our panellists think her latest comes unstuck?
A NOVEL about obsessive love in a Canadian boarding school struggles to scrape a pass grade from our panel.
A bleak portrayal of China in the wake of the Cultural Revolution offers The Scotsman Book Club insight into a period of history that's hard for the West to grasp
HERE at The Scotsman's Book Club, we like to ring the changes, so following on from John le Carré's tales of dirty deals among the Hamburg spooks, what better than a series of children's stories?
John le Carré's new novel updates his classic themes of betrayal for the 'war on terror'. But was our panel convinced?
Andrew O'Hagan's writings on Britain and the US earn praise from our panel for their incisive thinking – and a flattering comparison with one of our greatest essayists
Jane Gardam's latest short story collection takes a wry and generally genteel look at old age - but will these tales be meaty enough to please our panel?
DR: IN THE PREFACE, RICHARD Mabey, one of our greatest nature writers, says the book will be a meditation on the ways in which we think about trees and how that's changed over the last thousand years; about how artists, foresters and landscape designers have used them, paying particular attention to the beech because it's his favourite tree. How does everyone feel the book measured up to that?