Allan Massie: Follow the Welsh lead and put faith in talented youth

Published on Tuesday 7 February 2012 02:57

“This match will surely mark the end of Dan Parks’ international career. I would throw Stuart Hogg in at the deep end in Cardiff and expect him to swim”

MIRROR image. In 2006 Scotland beat England at Murrayfield in a desperately close match thanks to a superb defensive display and the numerous mistakes made by an England team that was on top most of the time. On Saturday England beat Scotland at Murrayfield in a desperately close match thanks to a superb defensive display and the numerous mistakes made by a Scotland team that was on top most of the time.

The worst of these mistakes was Ross Rennie’s delaying of his pass which , if properly timed and delivered, would have put Mike Blair in under the posts. This was as uncharacteristic as it was sad, for Rennie, who otherwise had an outstanding game, is perhaps the best off-loader and passer of the ball out of the tackle in Scotland today. Still, before we dwell on our errors and deficiencies, we should acknowledge the high quality of the English defence, well-organized, brave and utterly determined.

What was most evidently lacking in the Scottish performance was anticipation.

On half-a-dozen occasions, from the first minutes of the game when Jim Hamilton went careering into the England 22, a player would make a break, or at least half-break, and find himself isolated, with the support too far behind. That, for instance, was why Richie Gray had to attempt a very risky off-load to Alastair Strokosch who was at least a yard behind him instead of being on his shoulder. If Gray had been playing in an All Black strip he would have had a player on either side ready to receive the ball. You can’t coach the sort of awareness that intelligent support play demands; you can only encourage it .What must be especially frustrating for Andy Robinson and Gregor Townsend, both of whom in their playing days were adept at reading the game, is that Edinburgh in their Heineken Cup run have excelled in support play and off-loading. So, why can’t Scotland do as well? On Saturday better anticipation and a greater awareness shown by ball-carriers and support runners would have resulted in a comfortable Scottish victory, perhaps by as much as 20 points. To make matters worse England’s three scores were all made possible by Scottish mistakes. A mix-up between the Lamont brothers led to Owen Farrell’s first penalty, Alastair Kellock’s ill-judged run across field to his second, while the charge-down of Dan Parks’s clearance kick needs little comment beyond the observation that there can be scarcely any international fly-half who hasn’t suffered a charge-down. Ask, for instance, Ronan O’Gara, or even Dan Carter. Nevertheless this match will surely mark the end of Parks’ international career. Though some of his distribution in the second quarter of the match was good, his kicking from hand in the first 20 minutes was dreadfully poor, and made it impossible for Scotland to put a raw English side under pressure early on. So it is surely time to say “thank you and goodbye”.

One assumes that the Edinburgh pairing of Mike Blair and Greig Laidlaw will start at half-back against Wales. Chris Cusiter did some very good things on Saturday – his snaffling of Chris Ashton which led to our second penalty goal was Cusiter at his terrier-like best and he made three or four sniping runs. But if Laidlaw is to be at fly-half, then his club partner should be with him. Duncan Weir, who had a very fine second half, after an indifferent first 40 against the Saxons on Friday, is waiting in the wings, but Laidlaw is surely ready to take centre-stage. His alertness brought him closer to scoring than any of his team-mates. I wasn’t sure that he beat Ben Youngs to that touchdown, but one has seen flakier tries awarded.

The two Six Nations debutants, David Denton and Lee Jones, did well, Denton being outstanding. If they have television in Heaven, Scotland’s greatest back-row forward Douglas Elliott must surely have lifted a glass of whatever they drink there in approval, for Denton rampaged all over the field just as Elliott himself used to. Jones was lively, adventurous and sound. England put their most prolific try-scorer, Chris Ashton, on the left wing to test the newcomer, and he got no change from the Edinburgh winger.

Experience is invaluable, as we know, but other countries, notably Wales, have shown themselves more willing than Scotland to trust in youth, and perhaps we should now be ready to do the same.

Nineteen-year-old Stuart Hogg scored a marvellous try against the Saxons, perhaps because it didn’t occur to him that he couldn’t. It was the kind of try that Andy Irvine or the young Chris Paterson used to score. I would throw him in at the deep end in Cardiff and expect him to swim. There are other youngsters pushing hard for a place: Matt Scott, Stuart McInally and Rob Harley, for instance. Any one of them might come in, if not this week, then before the end of the tournament. That said, it would be no surprise if the only change to the starting XV in Cardiff was at half-back. The Millennium Stadium is a tough place to make your international bow, and Wales are in rampant form. They were magnificent in Dublin, both adventurous and efficient; they scarcely dropped a ball all afternoon. It will take a tremendous effort from the Scottish forwards to subdue them, and even if they manage to do that, this Welsh three-quarter line looks sure to score two or three tries a game against anybody. So I would expect Andy Robinson to give the bulk of the team another chance, and hope that this time – at last – the good leading-up work and line-breaks will be rewarded with tries. After the first weekend the championship already seems to be between Wales and France. Ireland haven’t won in Paris since Brian O’Driscoll’s first match there. It will be an astonishing turn-up if we win in Cardiff, and England will have to play a lot better than they did at Murrayfield if they are to beat Italy in Rome.

Comments

There are 14 comments to this article

Order by:

• Newest first
• |
• Oldest first

Page 1 of 1

• 1
• Show all

14

Aubrey Wilson

Thursday, February 9, 2012 at 10:25 PM

Scottish camp is quietly optimistic, although the occasional non-Italy win is hardly enough, but one has to start somewhere. The unavailability of the three best second-rows for Wales might also be telling. This is such an important match for Scotland.

• Report Unsuitable

13

RAIDERJAMBO

Thursday, February 9, 2012 at 12:22 AM

Sorry Allan, but back in the 70's whilst playing HS rugby in Scotland we were coached (rather successfully) the All Black awareness and intelligent support play by a rugby coach who demanded it, rather than encourage it!

• Report Unsuitable

12

Paulista

Tuesday, February 7, 2012 at 11:13 PM

What a man this Massie is. He turns up everywhere - columnist in the Daily Torygraph, waving the union flag, denigrating Scots who believe in their country but trying to force Scots Tories like Walter Scott on innocent children, writing novels in the first person about Roman emperors (shades of megalomania anyone?) and now he is a rugby expert! What a pity he doesn´t believe in Scottish independence because he could be our first President if we decide to go the whole way and have a republic or a Senator like W.B. Yeats in Ireland. It´s no too late tae think again Alan or are you dreaming of the day when you become Laid Massie of Murrayfield?

• Report Unsuitable

11

midlothianboy

Tuesday, February 7, 2012 at 09:28 PM

#10 Braveheart - I sympathise ,but if you want to see the moderator working overtime just try occasionally pointing out some of the flaws in Allan Massies journalism.

• Report Unsuitable

10

braveheart64

Tuesday, February 7, 2012 at 08:54 PM

Hi there i was the first person to post a comment on this blog and I see that it has been removed by the moderator.can't remember using any nasty swear words - can only think that the moderator is related to the lamonts or NDL as i was advocating that they should be dropped in favour of some of our A team players.

• Report Unsuitable

9

A Jambo come rain or shine

Tuesday, February 7, 2012 at 06:07 PM

#7 decision made!!

• Report Unsuitable

8

brigandaca

Tuesday, February 7, 2012 at 05:34 PM

Rejoice. He has retired! http:www.bbc.co.uksport0rugby-union16931078

• Report Unsuitable

7

Gordieboy78

Tuesday, February 7, 2012 at 04:17 PM

#6 those are decent, balanced comments. Parks DOES deserve our respect because, let's face it, he was willing to step forward and take the responsibility during an era in which very often there wasn't another recognised stand-off (we'll ignore the whole Paterson debate for now...) Now that we have options there though, and the wee man isn't getting any younger, we should definitely be trying out other options. I thought the entire Scotland team got a lift from the way Laidlaw played when he came on and he should definitely start in Cardiff. Other than in extremis, I think we should accept that Parks's time has been and gone and we should now build for the future.

• Report Unsuitable

6

A Jambo come rain or shine

Tuesday, February 7, 2012 at 02:32 PM

#5 No chance. The national clamour for LaidlawWeir to start must mean AR will change things. I'm not blaming Parks for our loss but we aren't going to win by kicking penaltiesdrop-goals and DP can't get us scoring tries so AR has to go with a form fly half. I'd love him to play Hogg at full back as well but not sure i can see it happening. Big thank you to Dan Parks for his contributiions over the years but it's time to move over.

• Report Unsuitable

5

buzzer

Tuesday, February 7, 2012 at 02:09 PM

I would stick with Dan Parks as on his day his distribution is superb. If playing rubbish then take him off and give Laidlaw the berth. But I do feel Dan Parks will play out of his skin to make ammends after all he is not a bad player and if Ross Rennie had pased the ball we would not be taking it our wrath on Dan Parks

• Report Unsuitable

4

brazzo

Tuesday, February 7, 2012 at 01:25 PM

Agree with Allan Massie's summation entirely and will live in hope that AR goes all the way by bringing Hogg and Scott into the frame , including the obvious half back change, as both Lamonts were pretty ineffective.

• Report Unsuitable

3

1956

Tuesday, February 7, 2012 at 09:02 AM

Excluding injuries i would change the half back bringing Blair and Laidlaw on.

• Report Unsuitable

2

O. Kontrayr

Tuesday, February 7, 2012 at 07:16 AM

Comment removed by moderator

1

braveheart64

Tuesday, February 7, 2012 at 04:31 AM

Comment removed by moderator

Order by:

• Newest first
• |
• Oldest first

Page 1 of 1

• 1
• Show all

Logged in as:

Comment here. Start typing your comment here:

Post comment

Please adhere to our Community guidelines

Your view

Please sign in to be able to comment on this story.