Despite his failings, Burley at least displayed bravery in taking on high-risk friendly games

Published on Sunday 22 November 2009 23:17

CREDIT to George Burley who crucified himself on the altar of so-called friendly matches, and was much criticised by fans and football clubs alike for undertaking these matches. Maybe he should have been more circumspect in taking on Japan and Wales, because national team coaches are high risk exposure material.

The same reality adorns the job for whoever deems the challenge worth the career risk. Burley had to cope with truculent clubs and reluctant players. I don't doubt his handling on the field has to be questionable, perhaps his tactics dubious – but at least he didn't quake from the challenge and went into these friendlies likely aware they could prove his undoing.

How many hindsight-wise folk, however, would have anticipated downturns against Japan and Wales? No super bonuses for Burley. Maybe he should have tried banking instead.

IAN JOHNSTONE

Forman Drive

Peterhead

If you want further confirmation as to the problem within Scottish football, just look at the utterances of the chief executive Gordon Smith last week where he opened the door to the Rangers exiles. This is leadership at its absolute worst. The expulsion of these players is now laid at the door of George Burley.

But their combined actions were a total insult to all true Scots football fans. For players to turn their backs on Scotland or disrespect the flag, for me, is a lifelong ban that should come from those leading Scottish football and not be the decision of the manager at the time.

The most productive thing that Smith and the rest of the executive team could do for the game is resign. Real leadership is about making hard choices, and allowing the Rangers exiles back into the frame would show a weakness that is truly breathtaking.

What example does this show when a player can pick and choose whether he plays for his country? Or if he does, he can stick his two fingers up to the rest of the nation? A complete shambles and a total embarrassment to all true Scottish football fans.

ALAN DAY

Edinburgh