Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


Ten changes in new-look Scotland side to face Fiji

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 10 November 2009
SCOTLAND coach Andy Robinson has wasted no time in laying down a marker as to his style for the team by making ten changes to the side that last took the field in a full international and stressing the focus on a powerful start to the autumn against Fiji.
The selection of one new cap in Alex Grove owes much to injuries to Ben Cairns and Max Evans, but it underlines the value of performing well under Robinson's nose on the Scotland 'A' tour to Romania in June. He has been picked ahead of Edinburgh's more experienced centre Nick De Luca and Robinson pointed yesterday to a greater ability in the debutant to pass and ignite the threat of strong runners Rory and Sean Lamont, and Simon Danielli, on the flanks.

Similarly, Robinson's 'A' team skipper, Chris Cusiter, has stolen ahead of Mike Blair and will make his first Test start since facing New Zealand at Murrayfield in the 2007 Rugby World Cup over two years ago. It is the latest chapter in an enduring story, Cusiter having usurped Blair when Matt Williams took over as Scotland coach in 2003 and Blair having taken over on Hadden's appointment in 2005, while Cusiter was in New Zealand on Lions duty.

Blair was the Lion this summer and he has lost his place on return. Cusiter has only played two games in the past five weeks, but did enough in those, and his early season displays, to edge ahead of Blair. The difference this time is that Robinson has told Blair he is joint-captain in an effort to harness both players' talents and drive, but there was no indication yesterday that Blair may be handed the starting berth against either Australia or Argentina.

Instead, there is a sense that this is Robinson's strongest available side, one he wants to build around, with injured players Euan Murray, Max Evans, Ben Cairns, Jim Hamilton, Ruaridh Jackson and Alasdair Dickinson all to come into the mix for the RBS Six Nations Championship.

Robinson said: "I'm very pleased with the squad we have – it's a very competitive squad. There were a number of 50-50 calls that we had to make, but it's getting the balance right and a picture in my mind of the team that's going to perform at the weekend.

"What I've been really pleased with is the attitude of the players not selected. Training has been intense and each player has come and spoken to me, disappointed at not being involved, which is as it should be. What we have here is a side that has a degree of physicality about it."

He went on to discuss the various merits of the front, second and back rows of the pack, where he has opted against the veteran duo of Nathan Hines and Jason White for the recognised lineout skills of Al Kellock alongside Hines. Robinson has also been pleased by Johnnie Beattie's "consistency" and the "athleticism and pace" of Richie Vernon ahead of Kelly Brown on the bench. He spoke of consistency improving, in the likes of Moray Low's scrummaging and Beattie's all-round play, of dynamism and an ability to be "evasive", particularly in the back three.

"The two Lamonts (Rory and Sean] are dynamic, strong, evasive runners, and very powerful," he said. "I like the fact that both players have had to go to new clubs and have worked their way into the teams and delivered."

On handing Grove his Test debut, the coach said: "I was pleased with the way he performed in the IRB Nations Cup, he's got his spot at Worcester this year and he has very good catching and passing skills, and it's about him, along with Phil Godman, bringing into the game the likes of Simon Danielli, Sean and Rory, a touch wider, and that's why he's been selected."

Scots with a reasonable memory will recall the days when every team selection started with a choice of goal-kicker, so few were the reliable options, so Robinson was inevitably questioned about his confidence in leaving out Paterson, the player who has transformed that aspect of Scotland's game, particularly when so many of the team's wins have been claimed by Paterson's kicks.

Robinson responded: "I believe in Phil Godman as a goal-kicker and it's about him taking the opportunities when it comes to match-day. When Chris comes on he will take over the goal-kicking duties, but I have no issue with Phil because he's a very good goalkicker. He had 81 per cent (success] in the Magners League last year and 71 per cent in the Six Nations.

"I also look at how we're going to perform over the whole 80 minutes. Rory Lamont's strength in the air and the way he's been performing for Toulon, with his evasive skills, has earned him the chance to start in this game."

He shrugged aside the return of former Scotland coach Mike Brewer, now as Fiji's forwards coach, and his inside knowledge of Scots, but expects a very physical, dynamic test. The key, as ever with Robinson, lies with taking control of Saturday's game and delivering victory, and little else. "This is what international coaching is all about – it's about the delivery on the pitch," he said.


Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 09 November 2009 9:45 PM
  • Source: The Scotsman
  • Location: Edinburgh
 
1

monto,

Edinburgh 10/11/2009 08:38:08

Good luck to Andy and the team What a change to see a team picked on merit and not favouritism Without,Dickenson Murray,Jackson,Cairns and Max Evans this is the strongest ohysical line up and why Thom Evans wasn`t picked sadly. Hope this is the end of us giving away trade mark soft tries, that Morrison stands up defensively and that Sean Lamont`s hands are working
2

Stoobing,

London 10/11/2009 09:37:28
Thom Evans form is definitely down on last season's just now, so no bad thing that he's not in this squad. Sure he'll figure against the Aussies or Argentina.

Agree re S Lamont's hands too! He's apparently reborn at the Scarlets - will wait and see. Danielli is on the bench for Ulster now so bit to prove for him too.

All in all, pretty happy with that team but, as per usual, everything will hinge on Godman. Jackson will be fit for the 6N after all.
3

AF1,

10/11/2009 09:46:46
Thom Evans form may be 'down on last seasons' (for him) but he still has 3 tries in his last 4 league games. Is there another Scottish winger performing like that?

Not Danielli, he has been on the bench. Not SLamont, he has been playing centre.

I am hoping this isn't the 'strongest available' team rather just the one to play Fiji only as it would surely struggle against Australia.

England physical players got nowhere at Twickenham and were beaten for pace and guile as the game wore on.
4

Dr Cloth,

Edinburgh 10/11/2009 11:15:21
#3 - I agree with all you say here.

I do have a slight concern about Grove. I have seen him play once and he seemed a good player, however he is not huge. Given that we have picked Behemoths in the other positions in the backline he may be an obvious target for the Fijians, so maybe De Luca (for all his other failings) may have been the better defensive option here.

I am also disappointed that Thom Evans did not get into the 22 as even if he is not on top form, his pace can be extremely useful both in attack and defense and it looks like he has worked on his strength this summer.

That being said it looks a pretty decent side and I am anticipating this match much more positively than any international in the last 3 years.
5

D Man,

10/11/2009 11:54:32
I have not seen much of Thom Evans this year but what I have seen he has looked pretty bloody electric. Against Connacht and Cardiff he looked seriously sharp. I hope Robinson does not continue to ignore him as he is a genuine match-winner with that searing pace. I also think he is a better all round player than both S Lamont and Danielli (who are very similar players).

I also have concerns about White, especially as the second row cover. He's nowhere near the player he was. I also rate Macleod more than Kellock. Hope Richie Gray gets a go soon as well. Glad to see Vernon in the 22 though. From what I have seen of him he looks really dynamic and like a potentially top class back rower

All in all a pretty good selection, especially the pack. Hope to see less bulk and more pace in the backs for the Australia and Argentina games though
6

Arbroath1320,

10/11/2009 15:15:31
Best of luck to the team.
Don't agree with what has been said about Danielli. He has had a number of good outings for Ulster this season scoring a couple of tries. I think Thom Evans plays a lot better when his brother is on the park, look at the difference in him against Connaght and the games before his brother returned. That said, I prefer Evans over S.Lamont, given that we have the size of Danielli.
I only wish Jackson was fit because Godman always looks like a rabbit in the headlights although Jackson kicked poorly in Romania. Looking forward to seeing Hines alongside Kellock and hope that pairing make it through to the game against Argentina.
Fiji will be a hard game and the Scotland team will have to play at their best to get a result. I think it will be close.
7

GAR,

Dublin 10/11/2009 15:46:01
Got to say also, Rory Lamont has looked like the real deal at 15 for toulon and will have gained considerable experience from playing in some of the big games against the likes of toulouse etc.

Still a bit gutted that big B Douglas down in Montpellier; 45 odd caps for Scotland; playing in a really tough league against some big units on a weekly basis.
8

SRU PRESIDENT, COMMITTEE & ASSORTED BUFTIES,

Hunkered in the Murrayfield Bunker 10/11/2009 21:17:43
Jim Stevenson intimates he wants a run-out with the team. At prop.
9

Saturday,

Edinburgh 10/11/2009 22:17:34
#5 not sure you've been following Scottish rugby this season. Robinson isn't ignoring Thom Evans. Jason White has been having a belter of a season for Clermont Auvergne and Kellock is a leader for the forward pack.

Looks like a decent selction for Fiji, but not the strongest available to Robinson.
10

Dorfl,

South 10/11/2009 22:37:57
Let's see how Robinson's first game goes. Will he put subs on when required or stick to the Hadden 60mins? Will we change our tactics (through on field leadership) or stick with it until it's too late?
I'm optimistic as I think Robinson's abrasive attitude suits Scotland and at least he's actually played first class rugby.

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.