Scotsman Nationhood Debate

Scotsman Nationhood Debate

The good, the bad and the wobbly

WHAT does Scotland mean to you in 2007? That was the first question posed to panellists at all eight nationhood debates in our Scotland 300 series. The answers were extremely varied, although the phrases "my home", "a country that has punched above its weight" and "great scientific discoveries" were mentioned often.

Strong views... but it's what the people believe

WE HAVE been to 21 towns and cities, from Dumfries to Thurso and Ullapool to Peebles, clocking up thousands of miles.

More top stories

Scotland's big guns battle it out in final 300 debate

AFTER two months, eight debates and 21 road trips in the Scotsman van, our Scotland 300 nationhood tour finally came to an end in Edinburgh on Thursday night.

Independent thinking in cultured debate

OUR seventh and penultimate nationhood debate saw a lively crowd at the Volunteer Hall in Galashiels getting to grips with the thorny issues of cultural identity, independence, Trident and economics.

A warm welcome - for all but the chickens

EVEN before The Scotsman stall had been assembled in front of the Burgh Hall in Peebles, passers-by stopped to welcome us to the town. The natives, known as "gutterbluids", possess a strong sense of their own identity and history - but also a marked willingness to welcome strangers, or "stooriefits", into their midst.

Town uncertain about the Biggar picture

"QUITE honestly, there are no major problems in Biggar, it's a small town with all the usual small town issues."

Final stages of nation tour

THE Scotsman nationhood road tour makes its penultimate stop in Biggar, South Lanarkshire, today. Our reporters will set up shop in front of the Corn Exchange between 11:30am and 2:30pm to ask townsfolk what they think of Scotland in 2007.

Don't you dare to knock our town - we do that ourselves

"IT SHOULD be Scotland's third town," says one Cumbernauld resident - "but it isn't."

Nationhood tour arrives in Cumbernauld

THE Scotsman's nationhood tour continues today as our reporters arrive in Cumbernauld. The controversial new town in North Lanarkshire has won numerous awards - most often for being the ugliest town centre in Scotland - but what do its residents think about living there?

Village swallowed up in commuterland

ON A quiet Monday morning in John Street, Penicuik, 72-year-old Marion Brown is talking about how this Midlothian town of 25,000 people has changed. "It used to be that people worked in Penicuik and lived here too," she says. "Now they just sleep here."

Exactly what is so great about Britain?

SO MANY words have been written around the 300th anniversary of the Act of Union; so few have focused on the principal consequence of this momentous event: the creation of the British state. It is salutary to examine the performance of this new state, particularly in the early years. For the most part, that performance was inglorious and dire.

Debating Scottish identity - and a burning issue closer to home

THE sixth in our series of nationhood debates saw some feisty exchanges at North Berwick High School in East Lothian. Former Labour minister Iain Gray, bidding to return to Holyrood in the East Lothian seat, clashed on a range of issues with the SNP MSP Kenny MacAskill, independent MSP Margo MacDonald, Judy Hayman, the East Lothian candidate for the Lib Dems, and Bill Stevenson, the Tory candidate. This is a flavour of the debate:

Independence? Let's get basics right

DUNFERMLINE, birthplace of kings and captains of industry and once the royal seat of Scotland, today finds itself dealing with more common Scottish issues - joblessness, traffic and the dwindling prosperity of the town centre.

'Scotland is a belief - it's a feeling'

A WELL-INFORMED audience of almost 150 played a big part in another successful nationhood debate in Cupar, Fife. In a wide-ranging discussion, chaired in feisty fashion by Lesley Riddoch, Scotland's former first minister Henry McLeish outlined a vision of an evolving Union, as an alternative to the status quo or independence.

Fear and despair in a once-thriving town

LEANNE Chidwick walked out of the Boots shop in Alloa's almost deserted High Street yesterday and summed up the town's woes eloquently.

Nationalist heartland where debate shows little sign of flagging

IN HIS Saltire sweatshirt, it is not difficult to tell the allegiance of Douglas Allan. The 36-year-old labourer makes sure to wear his national flag everyday, whether Saltire socks or cufflinks (or even boxer shorts, according to his wife). His children, aged five and nine, wear Scotland baseball caps with pride and his wife has thistle-themed jewellery.

Hunting for opinion from Angus to Alloa

THE Scotsman 300 Nationhood Debate continues its high-mileage tour around Scotland this week, with stop-offs in Angus, Clackmannanshire and Fife.

Vote for the success story, not out of fear

ON FRIDAY I met businesspeople in Glasgow.

New technologies take over from jute and jam

ONCE renowned throughout the world for jute, jam and journalism, Dundee is in the throes of a major transformation.

Still a boom town of tough optimists

EVER since oil began pumping out of the North Sea in 1969, Aberdeen has been regarded as the engine room of the Scottish economy, if not the UK's.

Page 1 of 3

Back to the top of the page