Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement

 
 
Saturday, 22nd November 2008

Claim a Free Glayva Miniature

Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the Edinburgh Evening News site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

Guides fight for sculpture as Lion proves a roaring success



Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 05 September 2008
TOUR guides are campaigning to keep the Lion of Scotland sculpture at Holyrood, saying it has become one of the city's most popular landmarks.
City guide, Ros Newlands, who is president of the World Federation of Tourist Guide Associations, has won the support of 300 colleagues who are keen for the statue to stay.

They will be meeting MSPs at the Scottish Parliament's Public Petitions Co
mmittee next week to discuss its future.

The 20-tonne granite carving by Cramond sculptor Ronald Rae has proved a big hit with tourists and local people alike since going on show as part of an exhibition in Holyrood Park nearly two years ago.

It has remained in the park opposite the Parliament building after Mr Rae offered it on a free, extended loan earlier this year.

The parliament's arts advisory group initially rejected his offer, but later agreed to allow it to stay till 2010.

Now, Ms Newlands said they were keen to secure the long-term future of the lion.

Ms Newlands said: "As tourist guides, we regularly take visitors on tour round Edinburgh, and we had noticed the amount of admiration it attracted.

"This iconic sculpture attracted comment not just from adults but from all ages. Children in particular are attracted to it in numbers.

"The Lion of Scotland sculpture is a great symbol for Scotland, now with its parliament once more established. How appropriate therefore that the statue be allowed to remain in such a wonderful location and continue to attract attention and admiration from visitors and locals alike."

Her campaign follows a previous petition by Bob Watt, who died earlier this year, which attracted more than 2000 signatures.

But Robin Harper MSP, chairman of the arts advisory group, has written to the committee saying it does not meet their criteria for public art.

Edinburgh tour guide Margaret McLeod, the vice-chairwoman of the Scottish Tourist Guides Association, said the criticism of the statue was "elitist", and the public had very much taken it to heart.

She said: "Our point is that public art should be different from the art in galleries. We're constantly taking visitors round and we see what people like and how they react to it.

"I think the art committee's attitude is snobbish, to be honest. We believe people do engage with this statue. We want to see it here for the future."

Mr Harper said they did not encourage unsolicited loans and gifts.

He wrote: "Our recommendation regarding the Ronald Rae sculpture was that it did not meet with our overall criteria and that we would not be recommending purchase or display within the Parliament grounds, but that we were content for the sculpture to remain in position in the grounds of Historic Scotland for the duration of the current loan to the SPCB which expires in April 2010 and which is not subject to any further extension period."

A spokeswoman at Historic Scotland said: "The future of the sculpture remains a matter for the Scottish Parliament and is not a discussion we are involved in."





The full article contains 520 words and appears in Edinburgh Evening News newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

 
1

alex paterson,

edinburgh 05/09/2008 12:19:41
Keep the Lion of Scotland,but get rid of half the tour guides,they are well past it,or have no interest.
2

JayDeeTee,

05/09/2008 12:34:56
Keep the lion and get rid of Robin Harper.
3

The Judge,

05/09/2008 12:38:15
TOUR guides are campaigning to keep the Lion of Scotland sculpture at Holyrood, saying it has become one of the city's most popular landmarks.

What a load of tosh. If he thinks a lump of badly sculptured sandstone that looks like a primary school project is a "landmark" he's not doing his job properly.
4

Jams,

Edinburgh 05/09/2008 12:50:44
Ironic how the "People's Parliament" doesn't really care what the people think isn't it.

Perhaps the committee would prefer Damien Hirst's half a cow or Tracey Emin's bed - after all they are "high art".

So if you want to see something that looks like a primary school project, I would suggest that The Judge review the last 5 years' Turner prize entrants.
5

Howard Moon,

05/09/2008 13:15:26
I'd like to see a Kapoor piece somewhere near this spot. The lion just seems poor.

Still, I suppose its nicely balanced by the CouncilMan outside their HQ.
6

Starkravingsane,

Edinburgh 05/09/2008 14:22:03
But it's lion down. I thought we were rampant? And where's the unicorn?
7

tracy griffen,

leith 05/09/2008 16:15:42
I work as a personal trainer and often take clients to Holyrood park. The wonderful stone lion has a place in my heart... and it's very useful for doing standing up press ups against!
8

JayDeeTee,

05/09/2008 18:14:00
#4. Excellent post. Hit the nail on the head there.
9

John Knox furr First Meenister,

High St, Embra 05/09/2008 18:40:39
Its so so so bad and I don't care what the plebs think of it.
10

The Geniune Mario Antionette,

05/09/2008 21:03:04
this lion is a mane attraction for tourists
11

JayDeeTee,

05/09/2008 22:40:01
#10. And if they sold soveniers, would they do a 'roaring' trade?
12

CentreLine,

Edinburgh 06/09/2008 10:19:15
#3 I guess it is intresting that you have an opinion yet have never got sufficiently close to the scupture to see that is is made of granite. All of the works displayed in the park by Ronald Rae were granite and made an already interesting landscape just that little bit more fun. Of course most of them have moved on with the exception of the lion. On a daily basis visitirs to the city are seen clambering to have their picture taken beside this piece of art in the same way that many want to be pictured beside men in kilts. It does not really matter if you agree with it or not there is no getting away from the fact that these are the little things that make our wonderful country unique in the eye of the visitor. It does no harm and a great number of people like it. Leave it alone is my view.
13

The Geniune Mario Antionette,

06/09/2008 11:25:35
#11 - I'm not going to take this lion down
14

Broughton Resident,

Edinburgh 08/09/2008 12:35:59
Mr Harper said, "they did not encourage unsolicited loans and gifts" and also wrote: "Our recommendation regarding the Ronald Rae sculpture was that it did not meet with our overall criteria and that we would not be recommending purchase or display within the Parliament grounds.

I thought the sculpture was in the grounds of the Queen's Park, not the Parliament, and exactly what are the criteria for purchase or display - whether Mr Harper likes it or not?

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 

Features

Featured Advertising



Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.