Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement

 
 
Wednesday, 20th August 2008

Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the Edinburgh Evening News site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

Anger over primary class with seven teachers in six months



Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 24 June 2008
PUPILS at an Edinburgh primary have had seven different teachers in six months, it emerged today.
Parents of pupils in the primary three class at Granton Primary today accused education chiefs of "failing" their children by not properly covering for the long-term illness of the class teacher.

The situation means the pupils were not given report cards like the rest of the school in March but instead received a smaller "progress report" yesterday.

The parents also believe the youngsters have suffered as a result of having so many temporary teachers, claiming their behaviour and education have been affected. They say the school has been hit over the past year because it has not had a permanent headteacher.

Education bosses insisted "every effort" was made to ensure pupils' class work was not disrupted when a teacher was off sick, but some Granton parents say the situation has become so bad they are thinking of moving their children from the school.

Caroline Conway, whose seven-year-old daughter Cara is in the class, was among parents who met director of education Gillian Tee to outline their concerns.

She said: "It's the inconsistency that's the problem, not knowing if the children are going to school and having the same teacher as they had the week before.

"There is no forward planning and the children have to start from scratch every week.

"There's not been a teacher with them long enough to prepare a report card, and this progress report is signed by a teacher that had them for a week." Another parent, Susan Wilson, whose daughter Samantha is in the class, added: "I feel totally let down by the education board.

"I'm swithering about taking them out of the school because of this situation."

Jennifer Crooks, 27, whose seven-year-old son Kyle is in a separate P2/3 composite class, said: "Fair enough people are ill, but he struggles as it is and there's been a few times when he didn't want to go into school because he's scared.

"I want to move him to a different school but I don't want to knock him back any further."

A council spokeswoman said the education department "appreciates" parents' concerns.

She said: "We have reassured parents that we are currently in the process of appointing a permanent headteacher to the school and all P3 pupils have now received their report cards.

"When a teacher is absent from a school, depending on the length of absence and circumstances involved, either a teacher from the same school provides cover or a supply teacher is employed. Every effort is always made to ensure that pupils continue with their classwork as normal."

Labour Forth ward councillor Elizabeth Maginnis also attended the meeting with parents.

She added: "The parents had prepared their case well and spoke with conviction, making a strong case for recognition of the high levels of behavioural problems and the need for more help.

"The problem is, of course, not helped by the absence of a permanent headteacher."


The full article contains 513 words and appears in Edinburgh Evening News newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 24 June 2008 10:22 AM
  • Source: Edinburgh Evening News
  • Location: Edinburgh
  • Related Topics: Schools in Edinburgh
 
1

alex paterson,

edinburgh 24/06/2008 12:13:44
Failing the children, very much so,seven teachers in six months is crazy,excuse=the absence of a head teacher,answer=appoint one.
2

allknowing,

24/06/2008 12:16:12
"today accused education chiefs of "failing" their children by "

I would argue the parents are failing THEIR children.

They are the ones who wanted the brats, up to them to have them educated. Dont like state school, go private, or home school.

Chancers!!!
3

Gastric Antral Vascular Ectasia,

24/06/2008 12:18:01
"Fair enough people are ill, but he struggles as it is and there's been a few times when he didn't want to go into school because he's scared."

He's scared because people are ill? I don't understand.
4

Scotish Exile,

24/06/2008 12:42:55
moaning minnies, one kid appears to be thick in any case and the other is getting used to seeing a range of teachers, which will be good experience when they get to go to the "big school"
5

Bored,

24/06/2008 12:44:14
my memory fails me, but wasn't there an article last week about a couple of thousand newly qualified teachers still looking for a job?
Why can't they get one of those?
6

ger,

24/06/2008 12:46:23
think it is shocking that any pupil should have that amount of different teachers in such a short period of time, must be very unsettling for the pupils, there must be gaps in their learning.
7

Xena - Warrior Princess,

24/06/2008 12:59:14
#2 I don't know about the parents failing their children but most certainly your parents failed to bring you up with any sympathy or empathy with anyone. As for calling children "brats" how old are you? Either very young or ancient? the latter I suspect.
8

anneleen,

24/06/2008 13:12:22
in response to the humbly named 'allknowing' - some people can't afford to go to private school, children are not brats, and what gives you the right to comment on the parenting skills of people you don't know? some of the people who have commented on this article appear to have not even read it (comment 3).
i volunteer at kids clubs in granton and know some of the children affected by this disgraceful mismanagement of the school. i was shocked to hear about this, but even more shocked to read some of the callous remarks of readers. try saying something constructive.
of course it affects a child's emotional, behavioural, and all round educational development when there is a lack of continuity in their schooling. a variety of teachers is one thing - a lack of any effective education programme is another. would this happen in a richer area of edinburgh like morningside or marchmont? i doubt it.
9

allknowing,

24/06/2008 13:16:38
I dotn see what was wrong with my post at all.

If parents dont like the school system, either go private, or home school.

If a wee bit of thought went into it before they had their brats, they wouldnt be moaning now.

I certainly wouldnt raise kids up expecting someone else to pick up the tab!!

Anyway, they are from Granton anyway, already destined for the dole office!
10

The Honest Lad,

Musselburgh 24/06/2008 13:18:31
allknowing is probably one of these SNP posters. Teachers getting cut in East Lothian under new administration with kids getting put into composite classes all over the shot to save on budget.
11

ger,

24/06/2008 13:20:35
allknowing......knows nowt!
12

allknowing,

24/06/2008 13:26:28
#10&11

Tell me why not! Whats wrong with home school or private?
13

ger,

24/06/2008 13:30:27
nothing if you have the money or the time. My kids go private, I am fortunate to be able to provide them that experience, many are not. Every kid deserves the right to a proper, well balanced education, its not a gripe its a right!
14

Sarcasm,

24/06/2008 13:30:44
Allknowing is fishing and you're taking the bait.

Leave her alone.

Anyway I heard the kids were OK with all but one of the 7, grumpy.
All part of smaller class sizes apparently.
15

Foo,

ejinbara 24/06/2008 13:32:16
#9 - Stop trolling.

'If parents don’t like the school system, either go private, or home school.'

That comment is a brilliant example of your total asshattery. Go private = huge unnecessary expense. Home school = Quitting job and going on benefits.

People pay their taxes and expect results from the public system.
16

Sarcasm,

24/06/2008 13:38:28
#15

#9 - Stop trolling.
A good start

"If parents don’t like the school system, either go private, or home school..."

Downhill I'm afraid, that's her fed for another while.
17

Xena - Warrior Princess,

24/06/2008 13:40:52
Aw Sarcasm I must take issue with you, there is no way that "allknowing" is female - No Way.
18

Foo,

ejinbara 24/06/2008 13:41:24
#16 - her?
19

allknowing,

24/06/2008 13:51:28
poo, my identity has been found out. I am in fact one of the dole scroungers in the photo, who wanted kids to get more benefits, park nearer the shop door, and pretend at being a happy family.
20

Sarcasm,

24/06/2008 13:56:30
17

Surely a male can't be allknowing.
Maybe only a male is arrogant to claim to be.

I'm too confused with this and there is a nice man on the telephone about my lottery win.

At least I think its a man, they can't fool me you know.
21

Sarcasm,

24/06/2008 13:59:17
#19

I think your trolling has been well outed on this thread.

Mind you, you look better than I'd imagined.
22

Xena - Warrior Princess,

24/06/2008 14:04:42
#21 Definitely MALE - you hit it on the head with the remark "only a male is arrogant to claim to be", his arrogance and ignorance just shines through in all his comments. He obviously has ESP as well as he knows the women in the photo are dole scroungers.
23

Gorgie_Tony,

Edinburgh 24/06/2008 14:05:37
This SNP/libdem administration are certainly showing their true colours. They couldn't careless about the wee kiddies education. Hands up those that voted for these muppets. Didn't you see this coming? I certainly did and put my cross elsewhere on the ballot paper. Roll on the next election so we can get these clowns out!
24

Mr Henderson,

24/06/2008 14:18:47
How come it is always the ignorant who manage to get their comments in first? I guess they haven't got a job or are wasting time at work.

This situation is the same at many schools, although I must admit not as bad as 7 teachers in 6 months. The Council have to accept some responsibility here. Why is there no head teacher? The council is saving money and not educating our children properly.

As for children feeling scared, they are young and being sent into an uncertain situation.

I now feel I must apologise to the first few posters. They may have suffered a similarly bad educational experience and therefore ended up ignorant through no fault of their own.
25

subrosa,

24/06/2008 14:44:04
# 7 I'd like to comment on your "young or ancient" remark. Obviously you're young because most older people in Scotland don't refer to others or themselves as 'ancient'. That's derogatory.

As for your 'ancients' calling children 'brats' may I inform you that the word 'brat' was never given to children in my day and also the word 'kid' was seldom used either. It's only in the last 30 years or so people started to refer to children as such.

Personally I prefer the work children for children and pupils for children who attend a school. Student is a word for anyone in further education.

Now my 'ancientness' is showing - then again so is my respect for my fellow man.
26

subrosa,

24/06/2008 14:44:41
work should be word ooops
27

deirdre catt,

edinburgh 24/06/2008 15:10:19
#23 - If you put a cross on your ballot paper then the vote would have been invalid.At the last local elections,you had to rank the candidates in order of preference 1,2,3 & so on.
28

Scotish Exile,

24/06/2008 15:32:06
bingo wings
29

Broughton Resident,

Edinburgh 24/06/2008 15:49:25
The Council HQ has many teachers on 'secondment' to the centre for one reason or another. Could one of those teachers not be used to teach here. There are also 'surplus' teachers. If they're surplus why isn't one put into this school. It doesn't surprise me that the Council's Education service is overspent and having to cut budgets when it wastes resources in this way.
30

davydee,

24/06/2008 23:49:22
#9 Allknowing
Dont you understand fool that continuity of education is important and that to have your childs education disrupted in having a supply teacher constantly can be disruptive to the learning curve added to the fact that there is no Head teacher which is also a drawback to any school you dont have any kids do you thank god for that
31

Shurley,

Edinburgh 25/06/2008 11:34:18
#28

House
32

Shurley,

Edinburgh 25/06/2008 11:38:57
#23

just hold on a minute [or at least another few months] those lovely SNP MSP's haven't given us all a free gift yet, so at least give them the chance to squander all our council tax before we boot them out. After all, I've writen to our saviour {Alex] asking if he can cancel my road tax obligations to ensure that my annual savings are the same as those who now cross the bridge free of charge and are adding to this lovely city's pollution problem.

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.