Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


Hines headache for Hadden

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 22 May 2008
EDINBURGH'S New Zealand forward Matt Mustchin could win a first Scotland cap in Argentina next month as coach Frank Hadden tries to solve a severe second row shortage.
The 31-year-old was born in Christchurch and played for New Zealand at under-19 level, but after securing just one game with the Crusaders he headed north in 2003, first to Ulster and then, two years later, to Edinburgh. The 6ft 4in lock-cum-flanker
has become one of the most popular and consistent performers in the capital and been credited with helping the young squad mature.

His three years in Edinburgh now qualifies him to play international rugby for Scotland under the IRB's residency rules and, with Jim Hamilton injured and Nathan Hines and Scott Murray involved in the French championship, he yesterday joined team-mate Simon Webster in being called up to the tour squad.

Webster underwent fitness tests on his hamstring injury and passed "with flying colours", according to Dr James Robson, the team medic, which alleviates some concern on the wing berths. With Nikki Walker and Rory Lamont ruled out, Hadden was keen for the 33-times capped Edinburgh player to make it and join Simon Danielli, and uncapped brothers Thom and Max Evans in the squad.

However, the second row remains a headache for Hadden, who had only Scott MacLeod in the position until yesterday. Nathan Hines confirmed that he, and the Argentine caps at Perpignan, will not be released for the tour as they face three games in ten days during May/June, and may need to win them all to secure a Top 14 semi-final spot.

Hadden is leaving the door open for Murray, Scotland's most-capped player, as he remains hopeful that were his side Montauban to win over the next two weekends and secure a top-seven finish and prized Heineken Cup place – but not qualify for the play-offs – he may be released.

There was no mention yesterday of Mark Rennie, the lock at Bourgoin, who may be available, but Alastair Kellock, the Glasgow Warriors captain, and Edinburgh lock Craig Hamilton are to join training at Murrayfield next week.

Hines, 31, admitted that it was a difficult time for exiles, stating: "The coach has said I won't be going to Argentina unfortunately, and it's tough – you really are torn between club and country.

"I'm passionate about playing for Scotland, as everyone knows, and I don't want to miss any Scotland game. And, being selfish, you always worry when you aren't available for a Scotland game because you're not assured of a spot; whoever comes in could play really well and you can't get back in – especially when you're my age.

"I am also an experienced player and you want to play your part in making sure we get a decent draw for the World Cup. But I'm also passionate about my club and I'm a senior player here. I want to help bring success to Perpignan.

"There are quite a few Argentine players at Toulouse, Clermont Auvergne and Stade Francais who won't be involved in the Tests either. I was confident we could beat them out there anyway, but the guys will have a good chance now."



Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 21 May 2008 11:15 PM
  • Source: The Scotsman
  • Location: Edinburgh
 
1

pound,

fife 22/05/2008 06:57:28
Fancy organising a tour when you know that players will be involved in games with their clubs.

It is not only this tour between Scotland and Argentina but also the Lions tour next year.

It only puts pressure on all the players involved and clubs having to tell players they won't be released. Also the playing public who pay top money to see the best players from each country.

When they realised these games would clash you would think they would change the dates. Or is that to easy.

I would like to hear the reasoning behind these decisions,maybe this paper can find this out for it's readers.

2

Mitch,

Edinburgh 22/05/2008 07:35:33
Fantastic news for Matt Mustchin. A well deserved call up.

As far as the fixtures are concerned, given that the French and English seasons last longer than ours, if we had to wait for all the non-Scottish based players being available, there would be no time for tours at all. This is an excellent way to bring on extrememly good younger players, and so provide ourselves with far more strength in depth for the future. And who knows, they may even be much better than the old familiar faces - just look at how well Edinburgh has done this season without the better known players.
3

Sun City,

22/05/2008 08:23:36
How can it be that the French clubs can withhold players from international duty ?

IRB Article 9 clearly prohibits this. All the SRU has to do is have disciplinary action taken against the clubs who refuse to release players as they did against Edinburgh Rugby prior to the RWC.

C'mon Gordon, lift the phone.
4

AlastairS,

22/05/2008 16:38:53
I would like to add my congratulations to Matt Muschins. He has been outstranding for Edinburgh for the last 3 seasons and I am sure will do an excellent job for Scotland.
5

leemagee,

Perth 23/05/2008 03:39:50
I am looking forward to a backline with the likes of Thom Evans, Ben Cairns and Nik DeLuca in it...especially if Godman can get in at 10. Add to that, Johnnie Beattie, Johnnie Barclay, Ally Hogg and Ally Strokosch, and our back row will start to look quite imposing.
The unfortunate things is that the Scotland team is in a catch 22: we win in Argentina and we climb the ranking for the world cup, but then Hadden is given the reigns for at least another year...or...we lose in Argentina and plummet further down the rankings, but Hadden is rightly disposed of.
When you look at the Scotland A demolition of Ireland A earlier this year, it is plainly obviouly who should be coaching and playing for Scotland...unfortunately we will do what we've done since 1999 and play people on reputation rather than form...unless fate has a hand as it did this year with the Jason White, Ally Strokosch fiasco, and the Chris Paterson, Dan Parks fiasco.
For the sake of the players who really deserve a win, I hope we beat Argentina...but I also hope that the SRU has the eye to recognise that this will have little to do with Hadden, and more to do with player determination and the tactical knowledge of Robinson and Lineen.

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.