Your Reviews: Battle of the Bands

Published on Monday 8 December 2008 08:42

Bob Wallace, 58, musician, Leith Walk: "The Sober Tongues are the most exciting band I've heard in a long, long time. Their material really shone and I'm sure they'll go places. Awesome stuff."

Vicky Wilson, 39 college manager, Port Seton: "I thought all the groups had something to recommend them but the Sober Tongues really made the night for me. They were brilliant, really enthusiastic and exciting and I wish I could have taken my son along to hear them: they're an inspiration to the younger generation."

Will Medvei, 28, oil and gas Analyst: "They (Sober Tongues] were like a wall of noise, normally I'd run away from something like that. I really liked The 48, though the sound levels were a bit off."

Alison Ross, 21, student, The Gyle: "I mainly came to see Rieser, they played at my college a while back and I've been a fan since then. Superb songs and some great guitar."

Davey Duncan, 48 rig manager, Corstorphine: " I really enjoyed the Sober Tongues, thought they were fantastic. I hadn't heard of them before tonight."