Sam McBride: Northern Irish result was far closer than expected

Sinn Fein leader Gerry Adams with Northern Irelands Deputy First Minister Martin McGuinness. Picture: Getty

Sinn Fein leader Gerry Adams with Northern Irelands Deputy First Minister Martin McGuinness. Picture: Getty

Share this article
5
Have your say

WARNINGS about the return of a hard border did not resonate, writes Sam McBride

More than three decades ago, the late Ian Paisley was in no doubt as to the utter depravity of the common market, even before it became the far more significant European Union.

In a sermon to his Martyrs’ Memorial church, the DUP founder asked his congregation: “What holds the Common Market together?” He immediately answered his own question: “Satanic 
power.”

Although many in today’s DUP couch their opposition to the EU in purely secular terms, it was striking that at the Belfast count the jubilant DUP supporters were those with links to Dr Paisley, such as Sammy Wilson, Nigel Dodds and Edwin Poots, rather than former Ulster Unionists such as Simon Hamilton or Peter Weir who represent the “new DUP”.

When Dr Paisley was first elected to the European Parliament in 1979 where he viewed himself as being “among a lot of frog-eaters and snail-mongers”, Dr Paisley famously pledged to “milk the EEC cow dry before slitting its throat”.

And yet while a large part of the DUP is overjoyed at the outcome of that throat-slitting, as delivered by British voters, a consequence has been to destabilise the UK to an extent which will alarm many unionists.

In many ways, two of the founding principles of what is now Northern Ireland’s dominant unionist party – staunch unionism and vehement euroscepticism – came into conflict in this plebiscite.

Even if the new DUP leader Arlene Foster was far less committed to leaving the EU than the party’s founder, she had limited room for manoeuvre in setting the policy of a party for which this was not a policy, but a founding principle.

By contrast, Sinn Fein – which in the 1975 referendum was campaigning on the same side as Dr Paisley against the European project this time with ease put itself on the Remain side, but found some of its supporters difficult to convince.

Having won the EU argument in Northern Ireland but lost it across the UK, Gerry Adams yesterday lost no time in demanding a referendum on Northern Ireland’s position within the UK. But the extraordinarily low turnout in nationalist areas across the Province has blunted that republican demand.

The spectre of affluent unionist North Down having a higher turnout than the border constituencies of Foyle and West Tyrone indicated that the fearful warnings about the return of a hard border simply did not resonate with sufficient numbers of nationalist voters most directly affected. Even more starkly, turnout actually fell from last month’s Assembly election in Sinn Fein’s West Belfast citadel, where not even half of eligible voters came to polling stations. Although Northern Ireland voted Remain, the result was far closer than either side expected.

By contrast, the situation in Scotland looks more immediately threatening to the Union.

At Stormont, after indications in recent weeks that the DUP and Sinn Fein were preparing to work closer together than ever before and the prospect of three stable years without an election, the Executive now finds itself dramatically unprepared for what has happened.

The Executive has seemingly conducted little contingency planning, such was its expectation of a Remain victory.

The economist Richard Ramsey yesterday said that it was “game over” for the Executive’s key policy of slashing corporation tax in 2018.

In one day, all is changed, changed utterly.

• Sam McBride is political correspondent at the Belfast Newsletter

Back to the top of the page