Q and A: Jim Lowrie

Published on Thursday 13 November 2008 21:05

Convener of planning, the City of Edinburgh Council, on the investigation by Unesco into whether the capital's World Heritage status should be retained.

Is the council satisfied that recent planning decisions on major developments have been thoroughly examined and have been subject to enough public consultation?

All of these projects have gone through extensive consultation and been carefully considered by the council's planning committee.

What is the council's view on whether a Unesco investigation, or "mission", is necessary at this time?

A Unesco investigation is welcome at this stage because of the high level of concern expressed by certain groups to recent large planning applications.

Is the council confident that Unesco's investigation, once completed, will not criticise the handling of recent large-scale applications in and around the World Heritage site?

We are confident that we have used robust and fair procedures leading up to the final determination of recent large scale developments.

Does the council believe that Edinburgh currently genuinely benefits from or is hindered by having World Heritage status?

The heritage of Edinburgh is a large attraction for tourists and visitors and having World Heritage status enhances our reputation as a heritage destination.

What does the council's planning service plan to do to address the apparent divisions between the local authority and the heritage groups in the city?

There are no major divisions between ourselves and heritage groups.

We have differences of opinion, but on the whole work together to preserve what is worthwhile in the city but also allow Edinburgh to develop and change.

What changes have been brought in, or are planned, by the council's planning service to improve the way the public are consulted on major developments?

There are extensive public consultations in the form of exhibitions, models and public meeting before a planning application is received by the council.

This has been happening in Edinburgh for some time now, but it will be a requirement of the Scottish Parliament's new Planning Act, which comes into force in spring next year.

The council's planning sub-committee deals with major applications using a hearing procedure where objectors and the developer are able to address members of the committee.