Greens tell council not to ‘jump gun’ over Castlebrae

Published on 09/10/2012 12:00

THERE have been further calls to shelve plans to close Castlebrae Community High School, with the city’s Green councillors insisting it “would be irresponsible to close and bulldoze [the school] while the future of Portobello hangs in the air”.

Education chiefs are set to approve plans today to consult formally on closing the Craigmillar school by the end of academic year, a move which has already been challenged by Labour politicians Sheila Gilmore MP and Kezia Dugdale MSP.

Now, city councillors from the Scottish Greens have tabled amendments calling on the closure plans 
to be halted. Councillor Melanie Mains said once the “trigger” has been pulled it “becomes very difficult to turn back the tide”.

She said: “It seems that the council has jumped the gun. Since Portobello is one of the main alternatives to Castlebrae, it would be irresponsible to close and bulldoze Castlebrae while the future of Portobello hangs in the air

“And closing Castlebrae leaves a serious question over longstanding and ambitious plans to regenerate Craigmillar. The council says that it wants to build a new school for Craigmillar in the future but not when and nor has it earmarked funds. Without a high school it will be so much harder to attract families into the area. We need greater certainty.

“But most important of all are the young people. Would they fare better elsewhere or will they just be scattered to the four winds and get lost in much larger schools? Although Castlebrae is a struggling school I think the community and young people need more from the council than just throwing in the towel.”

Related Articles

• Portobello High School ruling: Council ponder next move as park plan is overturned on appeal

  PARENTS have reacted with shock and anger after plans to build a new Portobello High School on a community park were thrown out by the courts.

  52 Comments

• Renewed calls for new Portobello High School after storms rip off part of roof

  A SENIOR government minister today said Portobello High School was “collapsing” around its pupils after part of the assembly hall roof was blown off in strong gales which forced the campus to close.

  15 Comments

• Battle lines are drawn in school closure challenge

  CONTROVERSIAL plans to close a city school have been challenged by two senior politicians who have drawn up “eight red lines” which they say cannot be crossed.

  0 Comments

• 100 voices

  The Primus of the Scottish Episcopal Church, The Most Rev Dr Idris Jones

• Catch those trams before it's too late

  Is this cycle path a danger to its users?