DCSIMG

Glasgow 2014 athlete on trial for sexual assault

The case is ongoing at Glasgow Sheriff court. Picture: John Devlin

The case is ongoing at Glasgow Sheriff court. Picture: John Devlin

A Commonwealth Games weightlifter has gone on trial for allegedly sexually assaulting another man in a supermarket toilet after a sheriff dismissed concerns that he would be unable to understand the proceedings.

Toua Udia, 22, denies intentionally or recklessly touching the man’s testicles in a coffee shop toilet in Tesco on Dalmarnock Road in Rutherglen, South Lanarkshire, on July 21.

The trial was delayed at Glasgow Sheriff Court this morning while Sheriff Martin Jones decided whether Udia, from Papua New Guinea, was competent enough to understand the proceedings.

About 800 languages and dialects are spoken in Papua New Guinea and concerns were raised that Udia’s interpreter did not speak the required dialect of pidgin English.

Sheriff Jones decided that a verbatim translation was not required and the trial could proceed with reference to photographs and anatomical diagrams if required.

Udia’s accuser began his evidence in the early afternoon, insisting the athlete touched his testicles while he was helping him to strap an ice pack to his leg.

“I came out of the cubicle and saw him strapping a bandage to his left calf,” he told the court.

“I asked him: ‘Are you okay?’. He asked me if I could help him tie the bandage.

“I went to his right side and he said: ‘No, the other side’.

“I took both ends of the bandage and he said: ‘Pull it tight’.

“I held it as tight as I could and he put his left hand between my legs and touched my testicle with two fingers.

“There was a bit of pressure. It wasn’t a scuff and it wasn’t a total grab, but it was definitely as if someone was poking.

“I said: ‘Hey!’ to tell him to back off. He looked at me and just smiled as though it was normal, with a wee smirk, as if everything was fine.”

The accuser said he did not consent to the contact or wish it to happen, and that he left the toilet and alerted staff and the police.

Procurator Fiscal Depute Adele MacDonald said: “It might be suggested that you are not telling the truth today and that you are looking for media attention given that Mr Udia is in the Commonwealth Games.”

The accuser insisted he is not looking for media attention.

Ian Moir, defending, said: “This case is one which has had a huge impact on (Udia), particularly because his career hangs in the balance.

“His family contacted me over the weekend to indicate how terribly difficult they were finding it, including the problems that a case of this type has brought to Mr Udia and his family.”

He outlined the communication difficulties his client has had with the interpreter, who has been trained and approved by the Home Office but admitted that he did not speak Udia’s stated dialect.

Mr Moir said: “The delegation to the Games have done their best to assist and have advised that there are 800 languages and dialects in Papua New Guinea alone, so these have been simply to do the best possible without the correct resources.

“The secretary to the High Commission of Papua New Guinea in London Nasser Tamei has also raised concerns to me about about this issue.”

He added: “An experienced interpreter has submitted that that he doesn’t speak this language and he has never interpreted in it before, but that he will try to explain in a language that he is not sure about. My submission is that is not good enough.”

Sheriff Jones dismissed these concerns and the trial continues this afternoon.

The court later heard from the accuser’s partner, who saw him just after the alleged assault and said “he looked ready to explode with anger” as he related the details to her.

Pc Jamie Carr told the court that Udia spoke to him while he was waiting “voluntarily” in the back of a police van.

“He (Udia) said that a male came out of the cubicle and that he had asked this male for assistance to help him strap the ice pack to his leg with a shirt,” Pc Carr said.

“He then said that both him and the other male were tying the shirt and at this point the accused said his hand slipped and accidentally hit the other male.

“He then pointed to his groin area to suggest that is where he hit him. He then stated: ‘I didn’t touch his d***.”

The court then heard from Tesco shop assistant John Wilson and security guard Alexander Steven, who both said they were sceptical about the alleged victim’s accusations when he initially approached them.

The accuser earlier told the court that Mr Wilson’s initial response when he was told about the alleged incident was: “Aye, right!”

Addressing Mr Wilson, Mr Moir said: “Is it fair to say that you were a bit sceptical?”

Mr Wilson said: “Yes, probably a bit sceptical.”

Mr Steven said: “His (the accuser’s) behaviour just didn’t ring true. It just didn’t add up. What he said had happened I didn’t think had happened.”

Ms MacDonald said: “You said that you didn’t believe it happened, that the complainant’s behaviour didn’t ring true. I put it to you that you didn’t see what happened in the toilet so you have got no reason to say that, do you?”

Mr Steven replied that he did not.

The case will continue tomorrow.

 

Comments

 
 

Back to the top of the page