Sarwar attacks Brown's anti-terror plans

Published on Saturday 29 March 2008 19:29

PREVIOUSLY loyal backbench MPs, including Muslim MP Mohammed Sarwar, are turning against Gordon Brown's counter-terrorism plans and are preparing to deliver the first parliamentary defeat of his premiership.

Tensions in Muslim communities are also rising as a result of the plans, Sarwar warned. Opponents said last night they were "reasonably optimistic" they would be able to throw out plans to extend the time terror suspects can be held without charge from 28 to 42 days.

Their case has been strengthened by around a dozen MPs who voted in favour of similar laws in 2005, including Sarwar, who have changed their minds. Speaking about his decision for the first time, Sarwar told Scotland on Sunday he now regretted supporting a 90-day limit and was concerned the legislation would unfairly target the Muslim community.

The Glasgow Central MP said: "Last time I voted out of loyalty with the Government.

But since then there has not been a single case where prosecutors or the police have asked for an extension beyond 28 days. Only six people have been held for 28 days – three of whom were released without charge. The Government should think twice about doing this."

Asked about the possible impact on the Muslim community, he replied: "They will be upset. Most people are very reasonable but they just do not see a need for this legislation."

Ayrshire North and Arran Labour MP Katy Clark added: "Whether it's intended or not, the legislation will be seen as an attack on the Muslim community which is not good for community relations in the current climate."

Osama Saeed of the Scottish Islamic Federation said: "A detention period of 42 days is posturing in order to look tough but in reality it will not achieve anything and at worst it will be counterproductive and cause tension between communities."

The counter terrorism bill receives its second reading on Tuesday, with the key votes expected in April or May.

A Home Office source said "positive conversations" were taking place with Labour MPs opposed to the bill.

The Conservatives, Liberal Democrats and SNP are all opposed to the bill.