Scottish independence: Coalition banks on ‘No’ vote and Trident staying

By SCOTT MACNAB
Published on 19/06/2012 01:14

THE Coalition government is not making any contingency plans for the withdrawal of the Trident nuclear-armed submarines from the Clyde, despite the possibility of Scottish independence.

A Nationalist government taking office after a ‘yes’ vote in the 2014 referendum, would almost certainly spell the end of the Trident submarines at the Faslane naval base.

But senior Liberal Democrat Sir Menzies Campbell said the Coalition is not preparing to move them south. “The assumption in government is that there won’t be a ‘yes’ vote, so no there’s no planning being done,” the former Lib Dem leader said.

“There’s a wrinkle here that the SNP position is that Trident submarines – the nuclear deterrent – must be taken out of Scotland. But I understand that what they want to do is maintain the existing Astute-class nuclear powered ‘workhorse’ submarines to continue to be based there. We also understand there was a vote to be taken this month about whether the SNP should join Nato and this has been postponed until the autumn. I think there’s some inconsistency there.”

Under the Trident programme, the Royal Navy operates 58 nuclear-armed submarine-launched ballistic missiles and 200 nuclear warheads on four Vanguard-class submarines from Faslane.

The Scottish Government is committed to the “earliest possible withdrawal” of the nuclear deterrent.

Replacing it has proved a flashpoint for the coalition, with Liberal Democrats opposed to “like-for-like” replacement and Conservatives committed to a full renewal. “The two parties came into the last general election with a slightly different position,” Mr Campbell added.

“The Liberal Democrat position was that all options had to be investigated.”

Related Articles

• SNP anger over ‘obscenity’ of new £1bn nuclear submarine order

  ORDERING new nuclear-armed submarines would be an “obscenity”, the SNP said yesterday on the eve of the UK Defence Secretary laying the groundwork with a £1 billion order.

  336 Comments

• Submarine deal ‘will put new WMDs on the Clyde’ says SNP

  Plans to spend £1.1 billion on the UK’s submarine fleet which would see a new generation of Trident nuclear weapons based on the Clyde were condemned as an “obscene waste of money” by Nationalist MPs yesterday.

  65 Comments

• Navy needs four nuclear subs or defence will be at risk, warns Fox

  REDUCING Britain’s fleet of nuclear submarines would “risk” the effectiveness of the UK’s military deterrent, Defence Secretary Liam Fox has claimed.

  0 Comments