Carnival atmosphere mixes with sense of anger and grievance

This protestor typified the carnival atmosphere, but beneath seethed a bitter sense of betrayal. Picture: Jeff J Mitchell/Getty

By Craig Brown and Jennifer O’Mahony
Published on Thursday 1 December 2011 00:00

ACROSS Scotland, thousands of public sector workers took to the streets in protest at the government’s changes to their pension and working conditions.

Though the spirit in which the marches took place was peaceful, and in some cases almost festive, their placards and banners expressed the marchers’ anger and sense of injustice at having to pay for a crisis they feel was not of their making.

Beyond the protest, however, a recurring theme raised by individual strikers and the unions was that this was just the beginning of a prolonged struggle – and that if the government did not back down then yesterday’s scenes would be repeated.

EDINBURGH

THE mood in Edinburgh was carnival-like, as representatives of nine unions joined for a day of action, and with 99 per cent of Scottish schools shut, many children waved flags and placards from the unions of their striking parents.

Yesterday’s march, which began at Johnston Terrace and ended outside Holyrood, attracted about 10,000 people.

A blue bus with “Chaplin’s Disco” emblazoned on the side blared out pop music as crowds gathered at noon, and the vehicle later served as a sound system for the delivery of speeches.

As she waited for the march to begin, Sheila Adamson, a member of the support staff at Queen Margaret University, said she felt betrayed by the government.

“Agreements were made and the government has gone back on its promises,” she said.

“We don’t want more for our pensions, we just don’t want them to be cut.”

However, Graham Hall, principal officer for the housing service at East Renfrewshire Council, was less taken with the popular discontent on the streets, despite being a public sector employee.

“I’m embarrassed and thoroughly ashamed to see this,” he said.

“They all have well-paid jobs with excellent positions and benefits, but they are very misguided and have fundamentally misunderstood the government’s position.

“I’m not sure what it’s going to achieve, and I am going to terminate my membership of the GMB if they carry on like this.”

GLASGOW

OUTSIDE the famed Barrowlands Ballroom, a group of STUC stewards stood by the entrance awaiting the arrival of 5,000 public sector workers and their supporters.

Former miner Tommy Canavan said: “I think it’s the right thing to do. They should have done it earlier. Cameron is just Thatcher mark two – he’s going to take the unions on, and this is just the start.”

Arriving in the city’s east end, the march was led by a troupe of female drummers, lending proceedings a carnival atmosphere heightened by whistles, cheers and air horns.

For those who could not get into the 2,900 capacity venue, an overspill hall was organised where the speakers repeated their speeches. Inside the main hall, banners and posters that spelled out the protesters’ frustrations and demands were hung from the walls: “People First”, “No Cuts, Hands off Our Pensions,” “Fair Taxes, a Living Wage, Jobs, Services”.

For Linda Hunter, a Glasgow auxiliary nurse, the march was a opportunity to express her anger. “I don’t think it will have any effect, but we have to make our voice heard,” said Ms Hunter.

“We’re on low pay as it is, but they want us to pay more into our pensions, so I’m willing to participate in action that opposes this.”

She added: “It’s not just about us, it’s about the next generation to come and trying to protect them.”

Human rights lawyer Aamer Anwar was also among the protesters. He said: “I’ve been involved in marches for over 25 years, but what we’re seeing now is the first generation who have never been on strike and never been on a march.”

He said that this generation were now “being hit” for the first time and feared being “thrown on the scrap heap”.

Addressing the rally, Unite’s Pat Rafferty said public sector workers had been “forced into this corner” by the government.

“We’re not going to be mugged by millionaires and billionaires any more,” he told the gathering of demonstrators.

ABERDEEN

MORE than 3,000 pension protesters braved the bitter cold to attend a rally at the Castlegate in the historic heart of the Granite City.

The speeches were led by Lewis Macdonald, the Labour MSP for the North-east and transport spokesman, who praised the response to the strike call in the city, saying: “We support your action. What the government is doing to your pensions is just a symptom of what they are doing to the whole economy.

“It is time the government started to listen. And when you get thousands of people in the streets of Aberdeen and on streets up and down the country they have to listen.”

One of the biggest cheers of the rally went to Janet Adams, a GMB trade union official in Aberdeen, who said: “The Tories say we shouldn’t be on strike today. What a bloody cheek they’ve got.

“If they hadn’t put forward proposals to take money out of our wages to pay for the blunders made by the fat cats of big business and the banks there would be no need for us to take action today.

“The trade union movement will unite and fight any attempt to reduce our members’ rights to a decent pension.”

Tommy Campbell, the regional organiser of the Unite union, said the turnout on the picket lines throughout the area was a clear demonstration of the public sector’s opposition to the pension reforms.

However, he warned: “It is going to a long haul. We have to recognise that this government isn’t going to back down easily. But if we stick together we will win.

“I am asking you to return to your workplaces, go back to your communities, and start agitating, educating and organising because today is not the end – it’s only the beginning.”

Kate Ramsden, a Unison union member, said she had been astounded by the response in the North-east of Scotland. She said: “Public sector workers don’t take strike action lightly. It takes a lot for us to down tools.”

DUMFRIES

STRIKERS in Dumfries picketed local authority buildings, courts, hospitals and the town’s prison before many attended a rally at the Cairndale Hotel.

SHETLAND

In SHETLAND, about 70 union members braved rain and hail to form picket lines at Charlotte House, Hayfield House, Grantfield and at the Gilbert Bain Hospital.

WESTERN ISLES

ON LEWIS, about 250 strikers and supporters participated in a march through Stornoway.

With schools and nurseries also on strike, many parents took their children along as they waved banners and placards on the route from the Western Isles Council buildings into Perceval Square in the town centre where a rally followed. It was the largest public demonstration seen on Lewis for many years.

• Additional reporting by Frank Urquhart

Comments

There are 17 comments to this article

Order by:

Page 1 of 2

Tiny

Thursday, December 1, 2011 at 07:55 PM

16. It would only be irrelevant if private sector workers did not pay a large slice of the cost of public sector pensions. As many in the private sector have no pension to start with and very few have comparable pensions to those offered by the public sector then it is very relevant to private sector workers that they are not being asked for a penny more. Perhaps we should have a private sector referendum on the future options for public sector pensions with a range of options available. I know how I would be voting.

Carnival atmosphere mixes with sense of anger and grievance

Comments

Tiny

Broon Bairn

Phil C

Aristotle

Kinghob

Kinghob

Russell Mitchell

samcoldstream

Jason

Mercutio

Phil C

anti u k

anti u k

antiparasite

Cynicus in Exile

Your view

Top stories

News

Looking for...

Featured advertisers

Jobs

Search for a job

Motors

Search for a car

Property

Search for a house

Weather for Edinburgh

Home

Services & Offers

Send to a friend

Report

Weather for Edinburgh