Playing into SNP's hands

Published on Wednesday 30 April 2008 20:57

The splendid array of talent that makes up the Calman Commission on the constitution (your report, 29 April) must really be on a hiding to nothing. It is difficult to see how the SNP can possibly lose politically when its findings are eventually published.

If Calman recommends a transfer of powers from Holyrood to Westminster, it will be treated with derision. If it recommends the status quo should prevail, it will be accused of a lack of imagination. If it recommends a limited increase in powers for the Scottish Parliament, this will be attributed to unionist influence on the commission. If it recommends a major increase in powers, this will play right into Alex Salmond's hands.

The lack of business and academic expertise on the body is significant, as is the lack of personnel sympathetic to independence. So, too, is Sir Kenneth's remark that public reports are not always welcomed, or acted upon, by governments.

The timing of the report's publication in relation to the next Westminster election could be crucial. Publication of the Kilbrandon report in 1973 helped prompt a wave of sympathy for the nationalist cause. Whatever Calman recommends is likely to help the SNP towards its aim of 20 seats in the UK parliament, and a chance to advance its aims by holding the balance of power there.

BOB TAYLOR

Shiel Court

Glenrothes, Fife