Our national collections need protection

Published on Friday 9 October 2009 21:39

I refer to Tiffany Jenkins' article (Opinion, 7 October) and the reply from culture minister Michael Russell (Letters, 8 October).

The National Museums of Scotland has serious concerns that, if enacted, the Public Services Reform (Scotland) Bill would effect a major change to our independent responsibilities in relation to our collections. I believe that is recognised by the minister, who has offered certain safeguards and assurances.

My trustees do not doubt the intentions of the government or the minister, but we are seeking to have these assurances defined in an enforceable form.

We have been advised, however, that collateral assurances given to parliamentary committees in debate or by letter do not constitute a binding obligation on other, future ministers or governments.

The draft bill already provides a specific and analogous protective clause, by way of exclusion, which will apply to Creative Scotland.

We are seeking similar specific statutory protection in relation to our collections, mindful also that we are constituted by primary legislation.

We remain in discussion with the minister on this matter and seek to achieve acceptable and binding safeguards.

SIR ANGUS GROSSART

National Museums of Scotland Chambers Street

Edinburgh