Scholars failed

Share this article
2
Have your say

We write as scholars of Scottish history and/or of Scottish Catholic History, shocked at the unexpected announcement of the closure of the Scottish Catholic Archives for the foreseeable future. The fate of the archives has been a cause of concern for some time. For the last nine months the trustees of the Scottish Catholic Heritage, who are responsible for the archives, and the Bishops’ Conference have been urged repeatedly to provide some information about this. There has been no response.

We now learn, from an inadequate press release, that no more research in the archives is possible because there is a serious problem with mould. It is extraordinary that the trustees have allowed this to happen.

Presumably, this crisis is related to the decision in October to replace the archivist and his assistant with a part-time post, with the result that the building has been left unattended for days each week.

We, and everyone interested in Scottish Catholic history, deserve to be told how this has occurred, and what is being done to salvage the archives.

Immediate action is required if the mould is to be eradicated. We expect the trustees to take responsibility for this appalling situation, and for their persistent failure to communicate with scholars. The chair of the trustees, Archbishop Emeritus Mario Conti, should resign immediately as a matter of course.

(Prof) Dauvit Broun

Professor of Scottish 
History, University of Glasgow; former editor of the Innes 
Review; convenor of the 
Scottish History Society

(Prof) Ewen Cameron

Sir William Fraser 
Professor of Scottish History and Palaeography, University of Edinburgh

(Prof) Ian Campbell

Professor of Architectural History and Theory, University of Edinburgh; former member of the Scottish Catholic 
Heritage Commission

(Prof) Thomas Owen Clancy

Professor of Celtic, 
University of Glasgow; former editor of the Innes Review;
convenor of the Scottish Catholic Historical Association

(Dr) John Reuben 
Davies

Research Associate, 
University of Glasgow; current editor of the Innes Review

(Prof) TM Devine

Personal Senior Research Professor and Sir William 
Fraser Professor Emeritus of Scottish History and Palaeography, University of Edinburgh; former convenor of the 
Scottish Catholic Historical Association Gilbert Márkus, Research Associate, University of Glasgow; current reviews editor of the Innes Review

(Dr) Eila Williamson

Research Associate, 
University of Glasgow; former editor of the Innes Review

(Dr) Jenny Wormald

Emeritus Fellow of St Hilda’s College, Oxford, Honorary 
Fellow of the University of 
Edinburgh, and chair of the
Society for Scottish Medieval and Renaissance Studies

(Prof) Dauvit Broun

School of Humanities, 
University of Glasgow

Back to the top of the page