DCSIMG

Wordy wise

The difference between English and Scots pronunciation (Letters, 22 February) cost me the top place in an army trade exam nearly 60 years ago, and it still rankles.

Newly graduated and into 
national service at Aldershot, my squad was told in a simple test to write down a word meaning “to labour” that rhymed with “shirk”. I immediately ruled out “work” and spent a fruitless few minutes trying to identify another synonym that rhymed with “shirk”.

That was my undoing: the
answer was “work”. If you adopt a southern English accent you can can see how they got it.

I had my revenge many years later when taking part in an international conference in Germany along with an English colleague. Fortunately for us two, English was the language being used. But the continentals asked the English participant if he could please speak Scottish-English like Mr Broom as they found me much easier to understand!

Andrew Broom

Traquair Park West

Edinburgh

Avoch? Milngavie? Kilconquhar? Farquhar? Wemyss? How are these pronounced? Pronunciation is a regional, local, personal phenomenon. I have long since given up correcting people (teaching habits die hard!) 
although I do, on occasion, shout at the television.

How many “sentimmers” are in a “killometter”? I can recollect our local post mistress saying that she had been asked by the then-existing unit of the BBC for advice on the local pronunciation of “awkward” local names.

Her name was Miss Menzies (so pronounced). One of her postmen (no relation) was Tam Mingus (spelt Menzies)!

I now regard “propuh English” (Received Pronunciation) as a dialect, like Glaswegian or Lochgelly speak.

I recollect that in the preface to the textbook we used to teach Pitman’s Shorthand we were advised that certain words had to be “written as spelt, not as pronounced”! These included “iron” and “park”.

And then there was the poor foreign visitor to London who was having a hard time with his phrase-book English. When he saw a poster advertising a West End show thus “Cavalcade-pronounced success”, he gave up!

George Cooper

Westgate

Leslie

Regarding Harry D Watson letter (21 February) about 
dialects, I wasn’t being anti-
English. Most of the bad pronunciation comes from Scottish 
presenters!

David Mollison

Burnhouse Farm

Kirknewton

 
 
 

Back to the top of the page

 

X scottish independence image

Keep up-to-date with all the latest Referendum news