Leader comment: Referendum could be only way to break paralsying grip of constitutional divide

Nicola Sturgeon was able to celebrate another national election victory but support for a second independence referendum did not receive a boost.
Nicola Sturgeon was able to celebrate another national election victory but support for a second independence referendum did not receive a boost.
Share this article
58
Have your say

We went into the local elections thinking that the fate of 
Glasgow would be the big story, as Labour faced the once unthinkable 
prospect of losing control of their heartland, a symbolic affirmation of the party’s demise in Scotland as the SNP swept them away.

We emerge, however, with that reality 
overshadowed by the surge of the 
Conservatives, who have doubled their tally of council seats and, most significantly, have positioned themselves as the main opposition to a second independence referendum.

The opinion polls indicated that this would happen, but no-one had predicted that the effect would extend into previous no-go areas for the Tories such as Ferguslie Park, 
Shettleston and Ravenscraig. These unlikely successes are confirmation that voting 
behaviour in Scotland is now dictated more than ever by the great constitutional divide.

This effect is a crying shame for local 
elections, and for the issues they are supposed to give the public’s verdict on. In their 
reaction to yesterday’s results, senior party figures made references to voters backing them because of their strength on local issues. These words ring hollow. Those voters who did mark their ballot paper with schools, roads, housing and the environment in mind were almost certainly in the minority.

So who actually “won” the election? The Tories have the most to celebrate, but the SNP are the face-value victors as the biggest party, with the most councillors by a long way. After ten years in government, by which time many administrations have reached their sell-by date, this is an impressive result for Nicola Sturgeon’s party. She can also point to the SNP becoming the largest party in 16 of Scotland’s 32 council areas – up from ten in 2012 – and joint largest in three others. In addition, her party now has the largest number of 
councillors in Scotland’s four largest cities.

However, the election leaves her with a lot to think about. Deeper analysis of the headline figures suggests that, when compared with the 2015 general election, the SNP vote has at best plateaued. The First Minister will also hear an alarm bell ringing in the east, where the SNP lost overall control of Dundee – a Yes city in the 2014 referendum – and Angus.

The opinion polls have suggested that there is no greater support for independence than there was in 2014 when Scotland voted for the status quo, and this latest barometer of 
opinion confirms that finding. If the SNP were hoping to attract more disaffected Labour 
voters, they might have found out yesterday that the well has run dry. Those Labour voters who have not defected to the Nationalists do not look likely to follow the others.

Scottish Labour deputy leader Alex Rowley responded to his party’s deeply disappointing results by stating that the outcome “only 
reaffirmed that if Scots want to stop the SNP, they have to vote Labour … on 8 June”. 
However, the evidence shows that Scots with that objective in mind are doing something entirely different, and backing the Tories.

And while the Jeremy Corbyn effect has 
contributed to Labour’s demise, the party’s Scottish leader, Kezia Dugdale, must take part of the blame for not taking a clear position on independence early enough, allowing Ruth Davidson to mop up the Unionist vote by 
positioning the Conservatives as the only 
party who can stop a second referendum.

Ms Davidson led a campaign which was 
unashamedly about stopping the SNP’s drive for a referendum rather than about local issues and she is certain to continue with this effective tactic in the run-up to the general election.

Because of the great divide effect we have witnessed this week, we can expect the 
general election to closely reflect these latest voting patterns – although with a different result because of the first-past-the-post 
system used at Westminster, which is likely to see the SNP emerge as clear winners in 
Scotland again.

And where local issues were muscled out this week, the same will apply to Brexit on 8 June. The general election was called by a prime minister seeking a mandate for 
negotiations with the European Union, but the ballot in Scotland will not be about that, and will instead be about a second independence referendum.

What we face is the prospect of every future election in Scotland – council, Scottish, 
Westminster – being defined by the 
constitutional question. It is difficult to see how this will change without putting the 
matter to bed with a second referendum – the very scenario that those who have switched to the Conservatives do not want to happen.