Martin Hannan: A bitter taste to panda politics

By Martin Hannan
Published on Tuesday 10 January 2012 12:05

Apart from being a gift to headline writers, what exactly have our guest pandas brought to Edinburgh? Quite a lot, actually. The positive publicity surrounding their arrival at Edinburgh Zoo was quite extraordinary, and must have had tourism bosses thinking all their Christmases had come at once.

For once, tram was not the first word that people associated with Edinburgh, and Sunshine and Sweetie at least brought some light relief from an unremitting diet of bad news and rotten weather.

Yet Tian Tian and Yang Guang have not pleased everyone by coming to the zoo. From various quarters we have had what I can only call propapanda, which is aimed at making the presence of these two creatures in Scotland into a political issue.

As an SNP member it never ceases to amaze me how the Unionists and their lackeys in the press jump on any excuse to give Alex Salmond and his government a kicking, but the abuse handed out over the two giant pandas has been beyond the pale.

Reading some commentators, you would think the First Minister had personally bribed the Chinese Government to send us the pandas so our poor wee minds could be diverted from the delayed referendum issue. He was accused of hogging the limelight – bizarre, given that the First Minister was in China the day the pandas came here.

Satirical magazine Private Eye joined in recently, suggesting it was all a conspiracy linked to China’s decision to impose greater import controls on Norwegian salmon because the Nobel Peace Prize went to Chinese dissident Liu Xiaobo. Scottish salmon farmers will supposedly benefit, and China’s panda diplomacy will also ensure that the Scottish Government will go soft on China’s human rights record.

Except that, when he was in China, the First Minister did indeed raise the issue of human rights. So much for that theory... Last week we even had an animal rights mob enter the debate by slagging off the SNP Government for supposedly spending £43,000 on a welcome party for the pandas.

I don’t know if the Captive Animals Protection Society – if they were honest they would call themselves Prevention Society as they basically hate zoos – are tools of the Unionists, but their intervention was political and, if you play politics, you take the consequences.

Even now some diligent researchers are looking into CAPS and its charitable status. For instance, were those people in Scotland who donated to the charity told the society would issue damning and overtly political press releases against the SNP Government?

I’ll keep you informed as to what emerges from the research, but in the meantime any SNP member like myself should think twice about donating to this organisation. Don’t get me wrong, if CAPS and everyone else who hates the idea of Sunshine and Sweetie being here wants to get together and petition the Chinese Government to take them back home, then that is their perfect right to do so. But to attack this Scottish success story is just plain daft.

For a start, the actual amount donated to the Zoo Society’s welcoming was just £12,900 specifically for ceremonies that celebrated Scottish-Chinese friendship. The rest of the money went on the staff time and marketing budget to celebrate the pandas and the boost they are bringing to the vital relationship between this country and China.

As any sponsor will tell you, the amount you spend in actual sponsorship has to be doubled, tripled or more in marketing the fact that you have given the money. The Scottish Government legitimately made the grant and backed it up with a clever campaign to show that China and Scotland are becoming friendlier.

Of course, any organisation like CAPS which has both Peter Tatchell and art snob Brian Sewell among its patrons might make you think “strange bedfellows”.

Sewell once said he would like to see a plague reducing the population so we could abolish the North. Whether that meant north of Watford, Scotland or wherever, this crashing bore of a man did not say. But CAPS is welcome to him even if Mr Sewell’s involvement wasn’t trumpeted when they made their attack. Can’t think why.

No doubt, CAPS are well intentioned, but I will give animal rights bleeding hearts some credence the minute I see them queue up to campaign against human-on-child brutality first. And sadly, there’s plenty of that in Scotland as East Lothian’s new holder of the OBE, Anita Green, would tell you after her 12-year stint as vice-chair of the NSPCC.

I don’t think giant pandas will survive in the wild, and at this moment in time I can only hope the zoo breeding programme is the correct way to proceed in preventing extinction, though I am not 100 per cent sure that it is. However, I’m willing to take the word of animal experts that it will work, whereas CAPS, like all such campaign groups, seems certain in their views and unwilling to accept an alternative.

Meanwhile, those who would play politics with the pandas should be aware of this – the public love them and any attempt to use them to score political points will backfire. Indeed, there will be no sunshine for any sweeties trying such tricks.

Related Articles

• Express delivery for pair of VIPs (that’s Very Important Pandas)

  IT WILL be the moment that Edinburgh – and the rest of Scotland – has been eagerly awaiting for more than three years.

  12 Comments

• The Red flag flying in Scotland

  The arrival of two pandas in Scotland courtesy of the Chinese government is not the only sign of growing links between the two countries, writes Jane Bradley

  1 Comments

Comments

There are 1 comments to this article

Order by:

• Newest first
• |
• Oldest first

Page 1 of 1

• 1
• Show all

1

ratfish

Tuesday, January 10, 2012 at 05:34 PM

Mr. Hannan should realise that the Edinburgh Zoo giant pandas are very much a political issue with officials and politicians from both the Scottish and Westminster Governments having lobbied the Chinese Government to help Edinburgh Zoo make the $1 million a year lease agreement to bring the bears to Scotland. The SNP Government, which had previously refused to give money to Edinburgh Zoo to help with the leasing costs of the pandas, was very quick to try to hog the limelight by spending £12,900 of public money on the daft and very noisy arrival ceremony at Edinburgh Airport, another £23K on a series of dubious adverts in the Scottish press and running up a wages bill of £6,822.17 to facilitate these initiatives. Giant pandas are a giant propaganda tool of the Chinese Government. The cuddly image of the bears is far more acceptable than the reality of a country with a dismal record on conservation and pollution. It should also be noted that in all the years the giant panda captive breeding programme has been going only one animal has been returned to the wild and it was found dead within a year. There is genuine concern that, as has happened in numerous other zoos with giant pandas, when the novelty value wears off the cost of the pandas will prove too great a burden and compromise the ability of the zoo to care for the other animals in its care. Mr. Hannan suggests that some SNP researchers are hoping to take action against the charity Captive Animals Protection Society because their “intervention was political”. I’ve got news for the SNP - so long as they do not give money to a political party charities can get heavily involved in political issues and can even advise their supporters on which way to vote if helping a particular party into power would advance the aims and objectives of the charity. I know of at least one charity which previously encouraged its supporters to vote SNP but will not be doing so in future due to the abysmal record of the present Scottish Government on marine conservation issues. If Mr. Hannan checks his history he will see that some charities to help children actually sprung from Victorian animal welfare organisations. He suggests people should donate money to charities for children rather than animal charities. It is the job of Governments and not charities to ensure children are protected and nurtured.

• Report Unsuitable

Order by:

• Newest first
• |
• Oldest first

Page 1 of 1

• 1
• Show all

Logged in as:

Comment here. Start typing your comment here:

Post comment

Please adhere to our Community guidelines

Your view

Please sign in to be able to comment on this story.