Incinerator rule change is turning us into wasteland

Published on 03/10/2012 12:00

ANGRY residents have slammed the Scottish Government for turning East Lothian into “a wasteland” after councillors lifted a restriction on where waste treated at a proposed incinerator can come from.

East Lothian Council planning bosses yesterday voted 12 to two in favour of removing a condition under which only waste from Edinburgh, East Lothian, Midlothian and the Scottish Borders could be brought to recycling giant Viridor’s £200 million plant in Oxwellmains, near Dunbar, for incineration to produce energy.

The decision means waste from all over Scotland will come to the facility when Viridor finishes building it in 2016.

Viridor was granted permission in 2010 for the plant after a Scottish Government reporter reversed a council ban but imposed a condition limiting where waste is sourced.

Council bosses said the decision to lift the restriction was reached as government guidance had since changed, meaning waste generated in Scotland could be treated anywhere within national borders.

Residents living close to the site of the proposed plant today told of their fears over future levels of pollution and traffic, and said they felt “powerless” against the Scottish Government and Viridor.

Chris Bruce, member of the joint action group opposed to the plant and chair of East Lammermuir community council, said: “As you pass Dunbar, you see a cement works, a landfill site and a nuclear power station – and now we are going to have this incinerator.

“It’s one unsightly development justifying another unsightly development, and it’s as if our part of the world is being written off as a wasteland.

“There’ll be the bigger carbon footprint and higher pollution from the lorries coming all that way through East Lothian.”

Philip Banks, former chair of the joint action group, accused Viridor of being driven by profit and said: “They just want to set up a working plant to show off to cities like Edinburgh which, rather than developing their systems, will just ship all their waste to this plant.”

Viridor bosses welcomed the decision and said the new plant would help deliver the government’s zero waste strategy.

Colin Paterson, the company’s regional director in Scotland, said: “The decision by East Lothian Council to approve the policy alignment on waste reception reflects a common-sense approach which has long operated across Scotland.

A spokesman for East Lothian council said: “The planning committee was advised that it would be better to approve this change as if the council refused, a [government] reporter would just turn it down on appeal since national guidelines on waste have changed.”

Related Articles

• Plan to bring rubbish from across Scotland to Lothian plant

  BOSSES at a planned new Lothians incinerator are looking to bring in and burn waste from across Scotland if they can get the go-ahead.

  0 Comments

• Incinerator plan 'up in smoke'

  THE firm behind plans for a £140 million "super" incinerator in East Lothian has withdrawn its planning application for the controversial scheme.

• Will recycling target end up on scrapheap?

  AS MOUNTAINS of rubbish are emptied by the lorryload into a shed at one of the dozens of landfill sites across Scotland, the aim of recycling almost three-quarters of all we throw away seems a long way off.

• Dumped: Greens rejoice as council rejects plans for giant incinerator

  PLANS for a controversial giant incinerator have been refused permission by a local council.

• Green light for energy plant

  ENERGY firm Viridor has been given the go-ahead for its controversial £200 million energy-from-waste plant at Dunbar by Scottish ministers.