Hugh Reilly: Tall order for Larry to keep teachers sweet

Published on Tuesday 31 January 2012 00:00

HATS off to Larry Flanagan on becoming general secretary of the EIS. Like other progressive trade unions, as part of a drive to save unnecessary expenditure on stamps and envelopes, the EIS saw no need to trouble the rank and file in the decision to replace Ronnie Smith.

Instead, the new supreme leader of the country’s largest teaching organisation was appointed by a specially convened meeting of the EIS national council. As a confirmed socialist, Larry will stoically accept the doubling of his salary at a time when the teaching profession is enduring a wage freeze. Cut-price supply staff can be confident that Larry will continue to share their pain.

Somewhat graciously, he stated that Ronnie Smith “would be a hard act to follow”. Beyonce uttering that phrase on taking to the stage after Jedward would have been more believable, given the mass defections over what many EIS members perceived to be Smith’s abject betrayal of their pay and conditions.

I rather liked Smith, even if his demeanour eerily resembled that of John Le Mesurier’s Sergeant Wilson in Dad’s Army. Always soft-spoken and eloquent, he was a pioneer of the passive-aggressive approach to hostile questions posed by media friends of the anti-teaching brigade.

My one regret is that we never met. He once complained I had authored an erroneous comment regarding the voting procedure at an agm. I had written the piece in good faith, based on a hitherto reliable source. Unfortunately, when I investigated the complaint, it was evident that my mole had either been drunk or had wilfully misrepresented what had taken place. Embarrassed, I phoned Smith to apologise but was told he was “in the loft”. None of my subsequent calls were returned. Sorry, Ronnie.

From my limited encounters with Flanagan, I imagine he will be a more forthright defender of EIS members. When I sat on the Glasgow EIS committee, Larry always made positive contributions. Despite the odd heated discussion, I never once saw him lose his cool. I wasn’t present when, as an acting deputy headteacher at Hillhead High school, he was assaulted by a ned. After such a harrowing experience, being badgered by Gordon Brewer on Newsnight Scotland over possible industrial action will be a breeze.

His eight years as a Glasgow city councillor undoubtedly left its mark on him. His monotone delivery with a judicious sprinkling of trade-union-speak phrases such as “aspirations”, “brothers and sisters”, and “at this moment in time”, identified him as a potential Labour Party high-flier. Sadly, following a dispute related to implementation of the poll tax, he was suspended without limit of time. Later, when it became clear that having socialist principles harmed one’s progress in the Labour Party, Flanagan resigned from the organisation.

Flanagan takes the reins of a union horse with a firecracker tied to its tail and bangers with fizzing blue touchpaper up its nostrils. His first task will be bring disaffected groups such as ReclaimEIS back inside the tent and endeavour to initiate policies that will halt the haemorrhaging of members to rival unions.

His second priority is to convince teachers that the Curriculum for Excellence (CfE) possesses a semblance of integrity. As one of the key players supporting the innovative curriculum – he was the EIS representative on the management board overseeing the implementation of CfE – he will be aware that many classroom practitioners view him with deep suspicion.

The new head honcho faces many difficult challenges. Teachers, in common with other public sector workers, are disgruntled that their standard of living is being depressed through a double whammy of a salary cap and a proposed increase in pension contributions. Wholescale implementation of the controversial McCormac Report will send dominies over the edge and it is up to Flanagan to mobilise maximum resistance to changes that worsen teachers’ conditions of employment.

In the final analysis, a general secretary is only as powerful as his members. Last November, the impressive one day of action that closed almost every school in the country showed that the profession will not accept meekly any erosion of the hard-won working arrangements of the McCrone agreement in 2001.

Good luck, Larry.

Comments

There are 4 comments to this article

Order by:

• Newest first
• |
• Oldest first

Page 1 of 1

• 1
• Show all

4

mordor

Tuesday, January 31, 2012 at 06:00 PM

I would like to see our school teachers rather than simply be opposed to the Cormac report actually come up with something better. Seriously, we have secondary school teachers with high level degrees and I am sure they could knock their heads together, knuckle into the research, come up with something and then say to the Government "We think that is idea is far better" and not only does it have brains behind it but as an added plus, it has the experience of teaching in a school behind it too. Just a suggestion and I think that when it comes to schools we should have more inclusive adult debates rather than the screaming matches that one sometimes sees.

• Report Unsuitable

3

Taigh na Croiche

Tuesday, January 31, 2012 at 01:29 PM

The EIS has failed its members. No doubt though that Smith's pension will be a good one.

• Report Unsuitable

2

Ancient Wisdom

Tuesday, January 31, 2012 at 09:20 AM

As most retired teachers will tell you Ronnie Smith's regime was a disaster for pensioners because no attempt was made to keep existing pensions in line with newer ones. As a consequence teachers retiring today get far higher pensions than those who retired earlier, yet living costs are identical for both.You can bet Mr Smith has ensured better arrangements for himself,

• Report Unsuitable

1

Sawney Has-Been

Tuesday, January 31, 2012 at 05:06 AM

Speaking as one of the betrayed, I think the EIS is now at the stage the Labour Party was 5 years ago - disbelief that they have failed and disbelief that anyone can look elsewhere. It could be their biggest challenge as i don't think there are sufficient 'fighters' in their leadership class to rock the boat. Too many honours at stake.

• Report Unsuitable

Order by:

• Newest first
• |
• Oldest first

Page 1 of 1

• 1
• Show all

Logged in as:

Comment here. Start typing your comment here:

Post comment

Please adhere to our Community guidelines

Your view

Please sign in to be able to comment on this story.