Hospital staff too busy to wash hands says NHS chief

Published on Thursday 28 May 2009 09:42

A SENIOR Lothian health official has suggested some hospital staff are simply too busy to wash their hands.

NHS Lothian Health Board vice-chairman Eddie Egan was speaking as it emerged that in certain departments, almost a quarter of staff are failing to wash their hands regularly.

The simple hygiene measure is seen as a key tool in the fight against superbugs.

New figures show that while some Lothian departments hit 98 per cent "compliance" with handwashing, others were as low as 77 per cent. At the same time, board members were told, cases of the potentially fatal C.difficile bug have gone up in the last month.

And while medical director Dr Charles Swainson suggested tougher action against staff who did not follow the guidelines, Mr Egan hit back, blaming over-worked staff and even poor sink facilities.

"If people are not following policy I have no problem with personal conversations.

"But sometimes the nature of the work means people are rushing about because thousands of people are coming through the doors and facilities are not up to scratch.

"That's why we are hitting 77 per cent in some parts and 98 per cent in others."

Dr Swainson is known to be furious that failure of such a simple and old-fashioned procedure could undo other good work which has taken place to tackle superbugs.

He is also aware of the damage bad statistics can do, after it emerged in 2006 that Lothian was the worst health board in Scotland for C.diff deaths, when 40 people lost their lives.

He told the meeting: "The good manners on this subject which has been in place is now coming to an end, and I'm losing patience with some areas of this."

Health Secretary Nicola Sturgeon has demanded a "zero tolerance" approach towards handwashing compliance, though Dr Swainson said at the meeting: "I don't think we've fully worked out what zero tolerance means, but if you work for the NHS you are expected to follow our procedures, and this one particularly, to the letter."

Handwashing compliance is monitored randomly by surveillance teams, who compile results from various departments across a range of time frames.

Board members were told that in April there were 87 cases of C.diff, up from 72 in March and 59 February – which was the lowest number in five years.

Despite the rise, bosses said it was still lower than the Scottish average, and that the health board is well on target to meet Scottish government targets when they come into play in 2011.