THE MAN who murdered 16-year-old Elaine Doyle was today given a life sentence and ordered to serve a minimum of 21 years in jail.
John Docherty strangled the teenager and left her naked body in a lane less than 50 yards from her Greenock home on June 2, 1986
For almost 30 years, the question of who murdered teenager Elaine Doyle remained a mystery until a breakthrough came with advances in forensic science. It was discovered that Docherty’s DNA had been on Elaine’s body.
Docherty, 49, continues to insist that he did not kill Elaine and claims he is the victim of a miscarriage of justice.
At the High Court in Glasgow judge Lord Stewart told Docherty: “You were convicted of the murder, but you maintain your innocence.
“Elaine Doyle’s naked body was found in a lane just yards from her home. She was 16 and you were 21. The killing was a brutal one and has had a terrible effect on her family and given them years of uncertainty.
“Given that you continue to maintain your innocence, there is no explanation for this crime.”
Defence QC Donald Findlay said: “Mr Docherty is adamant he is the victim of a miscarriage of justice. He did not kill Elaine Doyle and he intends to fight it until he proves he has been the victim of a miscarriage of justice. One day improvements in scientific techniques may enable a wrong to be righted.”
In the decades following the teenager’s death, police interviewed thousands of people though they made little progress in the inquiry.
But advances in forensic science and DNA technology finally helped snare her killer John Docherty, a man who had never previously been on the police radar in connection with the murder.
On the night she died, Elaine went to the Celtic Club in Laird Street, Greenock, then to a nearby hamburger stall before leaving her friends around midnight.
She was last seen walking towards her home in Ardgowan Street.
A passer-by saw her alone but with a man walking closely behind her.
The following morning her body was discovered. She had been strangled with a ligature. It was thought the crime was sexually motivated.
At the time of her murder, DNA was not part of a police inquiry - although forensics looked for hairs and fibres which were lifted by tape from areas of the body.
Despite carrying out 2,377 house-to-house inquiries, no real suspects emerged and the investigation was eventually scaled down as police ran out of lines of inquiry.
Almost 20 years later in 2005, a full forensic review of the case was carried out and the tapings taken from Elaine’s body, which had remained sealed for nearly 20 years, were examined.
They found a full male DNA profile on a taping taken from her back, and another profile for the same man mixed with Elaine’s DNA on a taping from her face.
The investigation was stepped up again but the difficulty was establishing who the man was as his DNA was not on the police database.
Docherty’s name came up, He had been at the Celtic club that night but was never questioned by police,
He provided a DNA sample voluntarily on May 12, 2012. It was a one in a billion match.
Further inquiries established that Docherty, a bus driver with Inverclyde Council, did not know Elaine and there was no explanation for why his DNA might have been on her body.
Docherty, who served in the Army for six years, has a young daughter and a long-term partner.
He showed no emotion as he was led away to start his sentence.