Analysis: ‘Scorecard not enough – we must improve system faster’
EARLIER this year, the preliminary results from PISA (a study that compares the performance of different countries’ school systems) were published.
They revealed that the world’s most effective schools are in Shanghai. They came out top in all the subjects tested: reading, maths and science.
There can be no argument about how fast schools in countries like China and India are improving. We know we cannot compete on price or scale of production. Now, it seems, we may struggle to compete in advanced skills, innovative thinking and creativity. Scotland has been warned.
There are, of course, many fine qualities in Scottish education. We have notably well-qualified teachers. Curriculum for Excellence offers a positive sense of direction. The same PISA study shows Scottish education again improving after some years of stagnation.
But, in comparison with others, how good are we really? And how can we improve faster? These are the questions that the independent Commission on School Reform is setting out to address.
The first task is to try to form a fair and objective view of Scotland’s performance. There is plenty of evidence available, but past discussion has tended to focus on political point-scoring and the allocation of blame. This is not good enough: future policy has to proceed from a reasoned assessment informed by genuine evidence.
Giving Scotland a scorecard is obviously not enough. However good Scotland’s education system currently is – and it is likely to emerge as a relatively high performer – there will surely be agreement that it has to improve.
Technical issues such as curriculum content, assessment and teaching methods will certainly figure prominently in the commission’s discussions, but there are other concerns. How well is the system managed and governed? Is it accountable to the right people? What can be done to raise learners’ ambitions and motivate those who are disadvantaged?
• Keir Bloomer is the chairman of the Commission on School Reform.
Email to a friend
Print this page- Alan Pattullo: Dignity, not sanctimony, is required at Parkhead
- 300 jobs at risk as Ryanair axes five Edinburgh routes
- Suzanne Pilley trial: I kissed her goodbye then never saw her again, says would-be lover
- Rangers administration: Craig Whyte’s promise to step aside and hand Rangers over to fans ‘ludicrous’
- David Cameron is playing into the SNP’s hands, says Michael Forsyth
- Scottish independence: Spectre of border controls raised by top Tory
- David Cameron is playing into the SNP’s hands, says Michael Forsyth
- Scottish independence: Alex Salmond hits back at Tory ‘Bourbons’ in battle over devo-max
- Scottish independence: Anti-Scottish jibes boost separation, Michael Gove warns Right
- Scottish independence: Let Scotland vote on independence in 19 months, says Michael Moore
Looking for...
Featured advertisers
Jobs
Search for a job
Motors
Search for a car
Property
Search for a house
Weather for Edinburgh
Thursday 23 February 2012
Today
Light rain
Temperature: 7 C to 14 C
Wind Speed: 26 mph
Wind direction: South west
Tomorrow
Sunny spells
Temperature: 5 C to 10 C
Wind Speed: 29 mph
Wind direction: West
Your view
Please sign in to be able to comment on this story.