Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement

 
 
Wednesday, 3rd December 2008

Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the Edinburgh Evening News site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

MacDonald claims most Scots support assisted suicide law



Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 22 July 2008
MARGO MacDONALD today claimed a majority of Scots would back a change in the law so people with terminal illnesses could choose to die.
She said she had received a "hugely positive" response to her television documentary last week on assisted suicide.

And she said she was convinced most people did not believe it should be a crime to carry out an "act of mercy" at the request of someone who wanted to end their life.

The Independent Lothians MSP, who suffers from Parkinson's Disease, has said she wants the reassurance of knowing she can end her own life if she decides the condition has become intolerable.

In the documentary, she declared her support for legalising not only assisted suicide but also euthanasia, where doctors would be allowed to help patients die.

A Bill on the right to die was introduced by Lib Dem MSP Jeremy Purvis during the last session of the Scottish Parliament, but it failed to secure enough backing.

Ms MacDonald said if Mr Purvis was not planning to make a fresh attempt with his proposed legislation she would consider introducing her own Bill.

She said whether it received majority support from MSPs would depend on the details of what it proposed. But she said the majority of letters and e-mails she had received since going public on the issue backed her comments.

She said: "Every indication I have is there is majority support for the principle.

"Jeremy Purvis introduced a Bill in the last parliament and I don't know whether he intends to introduce another one. If he does and I agree with it, I have the choice either of total support or support with amendments.

"If he is going a different way, I would consider bringing in a Bill.

"I am absolutely convinced of the level of support for the principle among the general public.

"The parliament might run behind the development of public opinion, which is not unusual in cases where individual morality meets public policy."

She said she wanted a full discussion on the issue. "There is a great deal still to be debated.

"In the Netherlands, they have legalised physician-assisted dying. Should that be extended to family members or friends?

"There are a lot of issues I'm not sure of because I haven't gone into them. People have to think about it."

Ms MacDonald acknowledged there would be strong opposition to the move from certain quarters, including the Catholic Church.

She interviewed Cardinal Keith O'Brien in her film.

"Keith O'Brien outlined the teaching of the church," she said. "I think his points are utterly valid and people will make up their own minds, but people who don't subscribe to this teaching must also be allowed to exercise their morality and conscience.

"I had the good fortune to go to Holland and talk to people for this film. I had the privilege of seeing what the reality was.

"The programme was a contribution to the debate. The debate is just starting. For some people it will not be concluded in time to allow them to die at the time of their choice. But we have to start somewhere."


The full article contains 535 words and appears in Edinburgh Evening News newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 22 July 2008 12:34 PM
  • Source: Edinburgh Evening News
  • Location: Edinburgh
  • Related Topics: Euthanasia
 
1

Prin the Dissolving Donkey,

22/07/2008 12:31:19
No, I'm sorry, this isn't very funny at all.
2

Linmal,

Livingston 22/07/2008 12:39:23
I have a great deal of respect for Margo MacDonald, but I have to disagree with her here. I sympathise entirely with her plight and that of so many others who have debilitating and often painful illnesses but life is a gift and it is not ours to take. There are so many ways of making things more comfortable for people and whilst I do not condone either euthanasia or suicide, assisted or otherwise, neither do I condone artificially and needlessly prolonging life. There is the Hospice movement. We are blessed in Edinburgh by having both Marie Curie and St Columbas, both places of peace and calm. My own father died in St Columbas and I cannot praise enough the care of the staff and volunteers. He died with dignity and without pain and I am glad to have had the time we did with him.

This is a debate which will rumble on and on but all in all I would say that the law as it stands should remain. Otherwise where would it end? There are many people who are otherwise healthy but suffer from Alzheimers, etc, who would make the decision there?

I wish you well, Margo, I feel it is so sad that you are having to suffer this debilitating illness, but you have so many things to look forward to with a loving family surrounding you.

God bless.
3

Linmal,

Livingston 22/07/2008 12:47:15
Just as a postscript, my mother had a stroke when I was 16. At the time she begged for us to let her die. My mother went on to live for another five and a half years during which time she had several lovely holidays with my father, was able to be present at my wedding and then was able to hold her first grandchild in her arms. If we had been able to assist her suicide at that time would we have done it? Just think of what she and we, as her family, would have missed. Things do sometimes improve and whilst my mother was not as able-bodied as she had previously been, she did manage to get about to a degree and these were years that I am so glad I did not miss.
4

Destroy the Planet,

22/07/2008 12:54:11
I have too disagree as well, i find the principal of assisted euthanasia as an unethical, degrading aspect of society. My parents also went through St Columbas and although the increased levels of morphine can be in some ways looked as expediating the death, they died with dignity and without pain at the moment in time they were meant to leave this mortal coil.
5

Dragonlord,

22/07/2008 12:55:18
2# Bet you change your mind if you get this disease. You ask who will make the descision for Altzheimers ect. It is for those of sound mind to make their own choice. It is also their own lives to do with as they will, and if they make a will whilst of sound mind, then what's to stop someone doing what they requested and ending their life in a dignified manner? Obviously the patient would disguss this with the relative, or person they would wish to help them and get their consent. No-one is expecting someone to commit murder but simply carry out their wishes and end their life when they are no longer able to do so themselves.
6

Mercutio,

FALKIRK 22/07/2008 12:57:11
Whilst I admire Ms McDonald and hope her campaign is given due consideration she fall into the politicians trap of claiming "mostScots" would back her proposals. "Most Scots" would probably support Capital Punishment!

 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.