Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


Police called in as traders party for tram hole turns nasty

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 07 October 2008
TRAM workers have been accused of behaving like thugs after trying to break up a "birthday party" for a pothole thrown by fed-up traders.
Businesses on Leith Walk decided to mark the one-year anniversary of an unfilled crater on the busy street by throwing the street party.

Balloons and a homemade banner with the message "Happy Birthday Hole" were tied to barriers around the hole and traders even made a cake.

But the good-natured protest turned sour when tram contractors came along to pop the balloons and attempt to rip down the birthday banner.

When confronted by angry traders, a scuffle broke out and one of the shop owners was knocked over before the contractors backed off. The police were called but no charges have been brought against anyone involved.

Traders later returned to the pothole to attach more balloons to the barriers.

Tram chiefs have launched an investigation into the incident, which involved workers from construction firm Carillion.

Diane Taylor-Wallace, owner of the Snail Mail shop, said: "I'm still a bit shocked, it got nasty really quickly. I was in the shop chatting and I heard the noise of balloons popping and automatically thought some kids had got hold of them.

"So I went out with my best stern granny look but to my amazement I saw all these grown men bursting the balloons.

"We went over to try and stop them and I ended up getting knocked into the hole with one leg in the hole and one on the road.

"There was then all these arms all over me to try and force me out but I think the fact I got my phone out and started to phone the police made them back off."

Traders claim the hole outside Leith Cycle Co has been there for a year with very little sign of work on it in recent months.

Richard Dowsett, owner of Leith Cycle Co, said: "I have never seen anything like this in my life, it is the worst bit of public relations activity you can imagine. That hole has been there over 12 months – this is the most activity I think we've ever seen."

As well as work to move utility pipes, tram firm TIE is about to start work on building tracks at the foot of Leith Walk.

This work was meant to get under way on Monday but has been delayed until tomorrow after the utility works overran.

Keith Hales, of Leith Walk Barber's, said: "It was unbelievable, this was just a simple, peaceful protest and these heavies came in and were being very aggressive.

"This was just meant to be a light-hearted way of bringing attention to the sort of problem we've had here but these guys were just thugs."

A TIE spokesman said: "The safety of the public, our staff and our contractors is paramount in everything we do. TIE is launching a full investigation into the incident to find out from Carillion exactly what happened and the reasons behind the initial complaint.

"Once we have the full facts we will take the necessary action to make sure our work sites remain safe for all concerned."

New Mound traffic plans to be in place at weekend
TEMPORARY traffic management measures on The Mound are set to be made permanent by the weekend in the latest plans for the troubled junction put forward by tram firm TIE.

The move would see a lane for buses kept open westbound on Princes Street, as well as improvements to signals on George Street to improve traffic flow.

The plan is set to be given the go-ahead today by a new "peer review group" of the city's senior transport officials set up by council leader Jenny Dawe, and would be implemented by Sunday.

City leaders are also considering creating a number of temporary park-and-ride sites around the Capital in a bid to help ailing city centre shops.

Emergency action saw Princes Street reopened to buses westbound last week after diversion measures around The Mound junction failed.

The latest plan comes after days of deadlocked talks between traffic planners.

An emergency summit held by council chiefs yesterday agreed to create a new review group, involving top officials from the council, TIE, Lothian Buses and the police, which will scrutinise all traffic management plans and contingency plans before any future changes are given the green light.

Ms Dawe said: 'This is the biggest construction project Scotland has ever seen, and we apologise again for the delays last Wednesday. I can assure drivers and travellers that actions have been taken to ensure we do everything we can to stop this happening again."




Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 07 October 2008 2:36 PM
  • Source: Edinburgh Evening News
  • Location: Edinburgh
  • Related Topics: Edinburgh transport plans
 
1

Concerned of Leith,

07/10/2008 11:28:21
At least the traders were trying to see the funny side of the tram road works - it is a pity that the Carillion workers couldn't share their view.
2

Scotish Exile,

07/10/2008 11:37:04
name and shame them and then sack the lot of them, including their managers!
3

charliegreen,

edinburgh 07/10/2008 11:40:36
If they had time to burst balloons and shove people around, then surely they had time to fill the hole in. duh
4

The_Doctor,

07/10/2008 11:46:21
Well, at least TIE's workers on the ground are singing from the same hymnsheet as their bosses. It seems the workies are arrogant, narrow-minded morons with zero interest in good public relations....just like their bosses.
5

Optimus Prime,

Cybertron 07/10/2008 11:51:36
So let me get this right. An unofficial protest starts tying balloons/banners up and causing a disturbance and the workers are getting the blame for trying to take them down.

Another pathetic attempt by the Evening News to discredit this project.

The "protesters" should be charged with breach of the peace.
6

,

07/10/2008 11:53:26
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
7

Howard Moon,

07/10/2008 11:53:35
#5

The EEN supports the tram project. Hence no campaign to scrap it. Goodness only knows why. Plus I hardly think it could be called a disturbance - nothing's happened there for a year, what exactly are they 'disturbing'?

And through it all, our elected officials said precisely... nothing.
8

The_Doctor,

07/10/2008 11:56:16
#5

I think it's the shoving a woman into a big hole that should have been filled in months ago that the "workies" (a total misnomer, as they never seem to do any work) are being slammed for.
9

Statsman,

Edinburgh 07/10/2008 12:00:07
Tram fascists jackboot over peaceful protest.
10

Back pocket,

07/10/2008 12:00:50
What people don't realise is how hard it is to burst balloons whilst carrying a Greggs steak bake in one hand and a bottle of buckie in the other
11

Destroy the Planet,

07/10/2008 12:03:00
Ha ! Puny humans
12

Thomas the Tank,

Edinburgh 07/10/2008 12:07:40
I was in a shop in Elm Row on Saturday (having walked, before Jenny McA/Gorgie Tony crawls out from under his/her stone) when three yellow-jacketed morons from Carillion marched in and stated bawling that 'everybody who had cars outside had to move them because the police were on their way to tow them away'. Just a Pack of TIE Lies - the police have refused to touch Leith walk with a bargepole since this fiaso started, and no work was taking place anyway. Just another wee example of the utter contempt TIE/Carrillion have for the public.
13

Marathon,

07/10/2008 12:13:21
Is the local Gregg's selling slices of Tram Birthday cake?

14

Cod,

Leith 07/10/2008 12:16:52
The more protests the better. It's the new "Spot The Ball". Circle the exact centre of the workman and you get to win a shiny yellow jacket. TIE = Tons In Earnings.
15

Jingling Geordie,

Sunshine on Leith 07/10/2008 12:22:55

While driving down "The Walk" last week I caught one of these Carillion guys working, yep, working....when challenged he denied it.
I felt obliged to report this to TIE however their response was to ask if I could prove it.
Try it yourself......12 guys with yellow jackets, 4 walking, 4 talking, 3 looking and, if you're lucky, 1 working.
Little wonder this project is dragging on.
16

Cod,

Pans 07/10/2008 12:32:10
You won't find love in a hole.
17

The Barred O' Leith,

07/10/2008 12:32:59
''Did you shove the woman in the hole?''
''Naw, ah shuvved her in the face.''
18

BobW,

Leif 07/10/2008 12:37:03
Happy Birthday Hole!

We will all come round for a party on your second birthday.

Pity TIE cpuldn't afford a decent PR company.
19

The_Doctor,

07/10/2008 12:38:27
"Police were today called to Leith Walk, following a disturbance at a Hole. Senior sources said officers were looking into it"...

Yes, the old ones are the oldest.
20

Skip McClendon,

07/10/2008 12:45:10
Meanwhile, Courtney Love refused to comment.
21

Amenemhat,

07/10/2008 12:49:23
#15 Jingling Geordie

Have you seen the "cone boys" men wearing "orange" not green jackets, their job presumably is to pick up cones at junctions that get knocked over.

How do you apply for that job!
22

Tomsk,

07/10/2008 12:52:17
#6 Is it Optimus's birthday? Happy birthday Optimus!
23

Duncan in Edinburgh,

07/10/2008 12:54:03
What's the betting that there's another side to this story? What's the betting that the woman who was "shoved into the hole" actually barged into the workmen rather than being pushed herself?

I'd put good money on it myself.
24

JT,

07/10/2008 12:55:34
I guess the party goers were unlucky that someone was actually working on the trams as Ive not seen anyone working when going through town. I guess in the induction for this contract they had a humour bypass done! Time for TIE, the council and the contractors involved to apologise to the people of Edinburgh for stitching us up into having this tramline.
25

NotAgain...surely!!!!,

07/10/2008 12:55:50
For 2-3 months I watched on as the workers completely resurfaced North St David Street just off St Andrew Square. They spent hours of an afternoon carefully cutting slabs to fit into the pavement while at the same time putting up a new set of traffic lights.

For the last two weeks I have watched on with disbelief as they have now completely relifted the road and pavement and began work underground.

Why did they bother to relay this in the first place?
26

Skip McClendon,

07/10/2008 12:56:20
#23

Of course you would...what this "good money" be around a Billion quid of taxpayers' cash, by any chance?
27

Skip McClendon,

07/10/2008 12:56:47
I mean WOULD this "good money", etc...
28

MishMoneypenny,

Edinburgh 07/10/2008 13:00:59
........ THE VIDEO IS NO LONGER AVAILABLE ..........

is the message I got on YouTube Boo, who removed it????
29

Skip McClendon,

07/10/2008 13:07:28
#28

Probably forced by a TIE employee complaining that the video mis-represented him. Showing him in the vicinity of tram "works" - clearly not an accurate representation of the average TIE workie's normal day...
30

Bob 2,

07/10/2008 13:09:41
15 Jingling Geordie,Sunshine on Leith 07/10/2008 12:22:55

While driving down "The Walk" last week I caught one of these Carillion guys working, yep, working....when challenged he denied it.
I felt obliged to report this to TIE however their response was to ask if I could prove it.
Try it yourself......12 guys with yellow jackets, 4 walking, 4 talking, 3 looking and, if you're lucky, 1 working.
Little wonder this project is dragging on.

Yip and its probably the same lot working at St Andrew Squayre, moving from job to job,
31

The Judge,

07/10/2008 13:11:24
As well as work to move utility pipes, tram firm TIE is about to start work on building tracks at the foot of Leith Walk.

This work was meant to get under way on Monday but has been delayed until tomorrow after the utility works overran.

How many delays is that now?

Have they found out what's under Princes St yet?

Cheer up only 2 years and 3 months to go till the big opening day.
32

Bob 2,

07/10/2008 13:13:21
12 Thomas the Tank,Edinburgh 07/10/2008 12:07:40
I was in a shop in Elm Row on Saturday ... when three yellow-jacketed morons from Carillion marched in and stated bawling that 'everybody who had cars outside had to move them because the police were on their way to tow them away'. Just a Pack of TIE Lies ..

....

Look dont you realise that you are Parked in their parking spot.
33

Tukhachevsky,

07/10/2008 13:15:04
Mon the trams!
34

Bob 2,

07/10/2008 13:18:17
An emergency summit held by council chiefs yesterday agreed to create a new review group, involving top officials from the council, TIE, Lothian Buses and the police, which will scrutinise all traffic management plans and contingency plans before any future changes are given the green light.

A bit late for this...Surely this should have been part of the TRO and forward planning of the whole peoject.

Temporary park and rides ...... who in their right mind would want to come into Edinburgh City Centre.

With all the Tram/Road works on just now, they'd have to be mad.

Colleagues at work took 30mins to get through Portobello on the Bus.

Breweries come to mind, and even if it was already organised, they'd still manage to make a TIE of it.!!!

Always look on the bright side of life
35

Bob 2,

07/10/2008 13:20:09
Cheer up only 2 years and 3 months to go till the big opening day.

yip and wait until they get their 1st Electricity Bill !!!!

mind you, half of Edinburgh will be blacked out once they hit the switch to turn on the tram power.!
36

Epicuras,

07/10/2008 13:23:26
all that will happen is carillion will despatch a few more brown envelopes to the folk who gave them the contract - hole thing's a disaster from start to finish :-)
37

THE BPRENTICE,

flying in my TIE fighter 07/10/2008 13:23:59
11 Destroy the Planet, nice one!!

u said:

"Ha ! Puny humans"

- I totally agree !!

AND ... they foolishly spend a great deal of their earth 'pounds' for their paid officials to attend a party for one of their many craters ... no wonder many say that the Earth Landing was a hoax ... surely this all can't be really happening.
38

,

07/10/2008 13:37:18
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
39

,

07/10/2008 13:38:09
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
40

roadstohell,

07/10/2008 13:38:21
Well, I can see the risks associated with members of the public attaching balloons & banners to a "work site". These sites are bound by Health & Safety legislation you know, TIE must ensure the safety of the public and it's contractors, and these dangerous items could have emperilled the life & limb of Carillon workers you know !!!!
These thoughtless and callous actions by the shop keepers could have had someones eye out !!!!
41

,

07/10/2008 13:41:01
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
42

cammy burns,

07/10/2008 13:43:04
#40 A work site is only a work site when there is work being done. For approx 364 days this has not been the case!!
43

Jingsitsme,

EDINBURGH 07/10/2008 13:50:37
Well now we know what tram workers really do and it's not work!

What a shambles and good on the birthday party for the one year old hole.

Probably the council will see that as sensible rather than order it to be filled in!
44

Citizen V,

07/10/2008 13:52:56
Ms Dawe said: 'This is the biggest construction project Scotland has ever seen...'

?!?!?

The biggest construction project Scotland has ever seen...

?!?!?

OMG! Words fail me.
45

,

07/10/2008 13:58:12
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
46

THE BPRENTICE,

07/10/2008 14:01:52
maybe the traders should make some cash out of this and tell tourists that Leith Walk is the oldest golf course still in existence? Instead of balloons - they should have held golf flags next to it.
47

Skip McClendon,

07/10/2008 14:03:19
#44

Yes, I got a chuckle out of Jenny's "biggest building project in the history of the world, EVER!" type quote as well.

Jeez-uz, Jenny...it's a blinkin' tramline...it's not the Pyramids!
48

Joe Smith.,

Moscow 07/10/2008 14:07:03

Where's PR guru Jenny McArthur today?

C'mon Jenny, entertain us with your random comments!
49

Citizen V,

Leith 07/10/2008 14:16:16
#47

It's not even the biggest tram system that Edinburgh has ever seen...

The management of this project is and will remain a joke.
50

Daft Old Git,

07/10/2008 14:22:20
#44#47
I think she means the biggest shambles. It is however a much bigger project than building the castle, the New Town, the Forth Bridges and the railways all put together
51

Casey Beer,

07/10/2008 14:31:57
A hole? Leith? A hole?

It'll still be a hole well after the workies have finished.
52

JulesF,

Kirkliston 07/10/2008 14:36:43
Wouldn't it be nice if Willie jumped into the hole just before they fill it ?
53

Jim W,

07/10/2008 15:23:35
It's all going perfectly to plan. The general public become more and more irate and frustrated by the traffic congestion which all along has been cleverly constructed by the council what with the white elephant tram system and the similarly cunning plan of digging up nearly every street in the city at the same time!

Planning!! The council couldn't plan a birthday party for a hole! :o)
54

Joe Smith.,

Moscow 07/10/2008 15:53:01

#47, 49

leave off Dawe. She's only 5 centimetres tall. It's not her fault the trams look big, distorted as they are through her Kenner Toys blister pack.
55

ikonoclast,

07/10/2008 16:19:37
Get used to behaviour like this from anyone in authority. In Gordon Brown's police state, anyone caught outside without their ID card will count themselves lucky only to be shoved into a hole.
56

Confucius,

07/10/2008 16:24:32
This city fully deserves its new World Wreckage status.
57

Peter - very disappointed/concerned,

Edinburgh 07/10/2008 16:28:00
What happended to the Video which earlier today accompanied this report?

Please don't tell me that it showed TIE/Carrillion in a bad light, gollygosh, I'd never have believed it of them, they are so up to the mark and on top of things and I don't think!!

Perhaps it just showed some of the workmen actually working?
58

Uma Toebone,

07/10/2008 16:30:14
Falling down a hole makes a nice change after tripping over loose paving slabs all day.
59

Edinburgh Mum,

Edinburgh 07/10/2008 16:36:12
Diane Taylor-Wallace, owner of the Snail Mail shop, said: "I'm still a bit shocked, it got nasty really quickly. I was in the shop chatting and I heard the noise of balloons popping and automatically thought some kids had got hold of them.

"So I went out with my best stern granny look but to my amazement I saw all these grown men bursting the balloons.

I love this woman, oh and happy birthday hole. I'll remember to send you a card next year. Then again maybe I will be stuck in traffic as the work/non work should be in Balgreen Road by then!!!
60

The Geniune Mario Antionette,

07/10/2008 16:38:10
it seems a hole of a mess they've got themselves dug into
61

The Geniune Mario Antionette,

07/10/2008 16:38:32
right said Fred..
62

Lala Land,

07/10/2008 16:46:45
Oh my God! What happened to Edinburgh? Did an asteroid hit the North Sea and cause a tsunami? Have Al Qaeda suicide bombers managed to drive a convoy of car bombs up Leith Walk and along Princes Street?

What? Trams caused this mayhem? Trams, those long train things that run on roads? You must mean vengeful alien trams shooting out death rays. No? Then who? TIE? Of course, TIE fighters armed with lasers. Must have been Darth Vader's idea. No? The council? You mean the peoples' elected representatives wanted this? And no one thought to stop them? The SNP did, but they were outvoted? And the citizens are just going to let this happen to their city? They're not manning the barricades, like they would in France? Jeez-o!

Nurse! Please re-fasten my straitjacket. I want to stay where I am.
63

Confucius,

07/10/2008 17:09:07
To ensure they are a "success", expect the council to make it condition of employment that all workers, contractors (and anyone else they can coerce) must use the trams.
64

calum,

07/10/2008 17:10:17
#48 - Jenny is the office alter ego of Gorgie Tony. She/he obviously hasn't access to the computer today or they're away for a counselling session for their paranoic schizophrenia.
Anyway, some of the supporters of the tram project were saying the other day on here how the tram must be popular because there had been no protests ....... well, here is the start in the above story.
65

jdships,

07/10/2008 17:10:49
5 Optimus Prime,
"Another pathetic attempt by the Evening News to discredit this project."

You need to get more methinks !!
TIE ot its contractor's don't need anyone to discredit this project as they are doing a pretty good job themselves !!
As I say get out travel on a bus and have look round - you will be amazed !!
66

Who's Killing Of leith,

07/10/2008 17:28:05
video can be seen at the following:
http://uk.youtube.com/watch?v=yb0AbBJBVgM
67

Ned_Kelly,

07/10/2008 17:39:22
No. 68
Not exactly Rollerball was it, mate! You should see a Carlton v Richmond footie game. That can get nasty.
68

Lord Dyson,

The Far Side 07/10/2008 17:49:17
I suspect these rather officious operatives believe they are the Police - there are certainly more of them about. I had a run in with one recently on Princes St whilst photgraphing the Gothic Rocket:

"Can I help", he said.

"No thank you, good sir but thank you for enquiring" sayeth I, "I have been taking photographs for some years."

"You can't take photographs."

"But Sir, I am a visitor to this fair and congested city."

"It is against the law."

"Ahem...My good man, it most certainly is not."

"You have to ask permission."

"But Sir Walter Scott is Dead!"

I departed at this point as I could see his fellow hole diggers preparing the concrete for my visit to Lochend Pond!
69

Phatniq,

the moon 07/10/2008 18:01:38
#38 You are correct, but could you try to climb out of your own rectum?

Happy b'day hole...not your's Foo.
70

ikonoclast,

07/10/2008 18:04:09
72, a site visit would involve councillors in two disagreeable activities:

a) they might meet members of the public, some of whom could express an opinion on their trashing this once great city in order to build a glorified train set

b) more importantly, lifting their snouts from the publicly-funded trough
71

GMann,

Leith 07/10/2008 18:05:13
#51 Casey Beer I guess if Leith is a hole you are just passing through ;) - Yeah the oldies are the best.
72

,

07/10/2008 19:02:44
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
73

tumshie heid,

07/10/2008 19:56:52
The layabouts responsible were probably aggrieved that they might have had to do some work if the traders brought this hole to the publics attention.
I hope there will be more protests and eventually this crazy scheme will be abandoned much to the relief of most of Scotland.
74

Douglas,

Bathgate 07/10/2008 20:37:57
#17 A true gem :o).
75

Josef Göbbels,

07/10/2008 21:33:48
Mein Führer, I am having a wundershön idea for our new Vergeltungswaffen: das Trammensonderkommandozug!

Just imagine! Hundreds of yellow jacketed shock troops pouring out of these unstoppable machines to dig anti-car holes in the ground and push pedestrians into them also.

That will teach those skirt-wearing untermenschen!
76

MasterXX,

07/10/2008 22:30:55
Any cake left?
77

nancydrew,

08/10/2008 00:01:42
this is a cute little story - better bedtime reading than the aunty annie/niece carla brawl!
78

THE BPRENTICE,

08/10/2008 00:13:26
Holy Mole-eee - did sales of polos on Leith Walk increase today?
79

Jingsitsme,

EDINBURGH 08/10/2008 07:52:35
all this keeps publicity away from the project itself being called to account - a complete failure from start to ???? IS it really started!

Council day will come eventually.......in the polling booth
80

Old Cartha Boy,

08/10/2008 08:48:18
Went past the hole this morning - never seen such activity by workies and machinery - coincidence, surely.....
81

Fidelio,

Edinburgh 08/10/2008 09:38:49
What is all the fuss about?
Leith has been a hole for years and no one has been that bothered about it until now.
82

Jamesbuchanan66,

08/10/2008 09:47:23
What were the balloon poppers thinking!?! They could have got free cake!

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 

Today's Vote

Should TIE be spending time Twittering and using social networking sites?
Yes, many people communicate this way now
No, it’s just another form of spin
No, it should focus on getting the work done on time


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.