Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement

 
 
Tuesday, 2nd December 2008

Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the The Scotsman site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

Edinburgh 32-12 Scarlets: Scintillating Edinburgh surprise Scarlets



Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 20 September 2008
EDINBURGH slaughtered the Magners League leaders with glorious running rugby to convincingly end the search for a first league win of the season at Murrayfield last night.
Andy Robinson, the Edinburgh coach, had urged supporters not to panic after defeats to Munster and Leinster and last night his faith was rewarded with four superb tries and the kind of entertainment that should bring supporters flooding back to Murra
yfield.

The Scarlets had won their opening three games and looked a more formidable side than previous seasons, but after a bright opening few minutes they struggled to get their hands on the ball and earned only glimpses of the home try-line. After Phil Godman opened the scoring with a penalty after 18 minutes, the stand-off stepping up when Chris Paterson was down injured, Edinburgh's pack began to uncover a platform and Mike Blair and Godman opened up the home attack. Hugo Southwell, Godman and Paterson were finding their range with a much-improved kicking game, penetrating deep into space and near touch in the visitors' half, and the team showed steely resolve in making the possession count.

Paterson pulled a penalty effort just wide of the posts in the 23rd minute, but with Allister Hogg and Ross Ford leading the forward charges, the hosts moved decisively onto the front foot with two tries in the space of three minutes. Great work by Mark Robertson, the left wing, forced a turnover from the Scarlets and though Nick De Luca knocked-on a quick tap-penalty, the Scarlets were penalised at the resultant scrum and Edinburgh launched a wave of attacks at the home line.

De Luca was at the apex of the first, but he was held on the try-line, and when the ball came wide left Geoff Cross and Allan Jacobsen were driven over, Jacobsen touching down Edinburgh's first try of the league campaign. Having waited more than 180 minutes for one try, a second arrived just over two minutes later after sublime running skills. Godman released Paterson and the full-back raced with conviction at space. He sucked in defenders and timed his pass superbly to Robertson who touched down near the posts.

He should have added a second on the stroke of half-time after Matt Mustchin had punctured a solid period of Scarlets pressure on the Edinburgh 22 with a long clearance kick downfield. Ross Ford, the Edinburgh hooker, stunned the Murrayfield crowd with his blistering pace over 60 metres, outstripping Gavin Thomas and chipping the ball over the try-line. It bounced towards Robertson, but the rangy wing lost it as he dived down to the ground and, much to his horror, referee Alan Lewis and his assistant David Changleng decided he had knocked on.

However, the Murrayfield crowd need not have worried as the home side started the second half from where they left off, the pack really taking the fight to a Scarlets pack in which All Black prop Kees Meeuws was outshone by Cross and Jacobsen, and David Lyons, the Wallaby No 8, was almost invisible. Godman was revelling in dictating play behind and after he had dropped a goal eight minutes in, Robertson scored his second and Edinburgh's third try of the night. It came from slick handling and ambitious attacking play, and terrific ball retention as the Scarlets repelled a series of bursts inside their 22. Eventually, the ball was moved left and Robertson jinked his way past Nathan Brew and into the corner. Paterson converted and for a team that had been struggling this season, against one unbeaten, there was something bizarre about the 25-0 scoreline.

The Scarlets were similarly stunned, Nigel Davies, their coach, having made four changes at and just after half-time – Regan King's return from injury particularly welcome for the coach – but he threw another two on with still nearly 30 minutes left as he sought desperately to find a way back into the game. They did, briefly, King creating the space for Morgan Stoddart, the Scarlets full-back, to score, but De Luca provided the perfect home response with a stunning individual try after Paterson had created the space for him.

De Luca was left fuming just after the hour-mark, however, when Godman looked to add the icing to a fine solo display, breaking despairing tackles inside the Edinburgh 22 and streaking downfield. He had three supporting runners and brought them into play well, but instead of giving it to the flying De Luca he opted for the less predictable pass wider, which ended with Turnbull guddling the ball on the ground. The Scarlets were then reduced to 14 men when Jones was forced off with an injury with all the subs used, but they finished the stronger with Martin Roberts grabbing a late consolation, while Scott Newlands was in the sin-bin, to give the final score a flattering look for the visitors.

Scorers: Edinburgh: Tries: Jacobsen, Robertson 2, De Luca; Pen: Godman; Drop-goal: Godman; Cons: Paterson 3. Scarlets: Tries: Stoddart, Roberts; Con: C Thomas.

Edinburgh: C Paterson; A Turnbull, H Southwell, N De Luca, M Robertson; P Godman, M Blair (capt); A Jacobsen, R Ford, G Cross, C Hamilton, B Gissing, M Mustchin, A Hogg, A MacDonald. Subs: J Hamilton for C Hamilton 56mins, G Kerr for Jacobsen, A Kelly for Ford, both 59, B Meyer for Blair 64, D Blair for Godman 65, J Thompson for Paterson, S Newlands for MacDonald, both 68.

Scarlets: M Stoddart; M Jones, R Higgitt, J Davies, N Brew; S Jones (capt), S Martens; I Thomas, K Owens, K Meeuws, V Cooper, S MacLeod, J Turnbull, D Lyons, G Thomas. Subs: N Thomas for Turnbull, M Roberts for Martens, both 40mins, M Rees for Owens, R King for Higgit, both 45, P John for Meeuws, C Thomas for Brew, both 53, L Reed for MacLeod 59.

Referee: A Lewis (Ireland). Attendance: 2655.



The full article contains 997 words and appears in The Scotsman newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 20 September 2008 1:15 AM
  • Source: The Scotsman
  • Location: Edinburgh
  • Related Topics: Edinburgh rugby
 
1

Venachar,

20/09/2008 01:47:50
More like it from Edinburgh!
Don't mention the missed kicks and the three missed try opportubities but that was a positive display by Edinburgh and from what I could see a reasonable crowd.

Unfortunately the next home crowd is at the Heineken Cup match with Leinster. For the people of Edinburgh, the Lothians and Fife, please get out and support Edinburgh Rugby they are a decent team.
2

Saltireblue,

Out Here! 20/09/2008 02:15:30
Didn't see the game and don't see much about Southwell in the above article. How did he do at centre?
3

Venachar,

20/09/2008 02:23:29
As far as I could see he did pretty well, but get along and see for yourself, it's better value than paying for Premier League soccer or sure.

Next home game is against Leinster ( best visiting fans imo) where up to 4 children go free with each adult ticket sold - mark 11th October in your diary, it could be fun.
4

Edinburgh Pete ,

20/09/2008 08:12:13
a much better performance totally outplaying the Scarlets up front with Godman back on form, Paterson stepping up and Southwell kicking excelletly from hand. 4 good tries, 3 others missed and despite couple of dodgy decisions by Mr Lewis, an excellent nights work.

5

Big Smoke,

20/09/2008 08:13:13
Good result, good to see they played a bit positive this game.

Whats Soccer? is that the American game that we Scottish folk call football?
6

Stoo,

20/09/2008 08:27:41
There was more than 2655 there.
7

JT,

20/09/2008 08:37:06
For once Alan Lewis had a fairly decent game, apart from the missed red card for the high tackle and the sin bin of Newlands bit of unbalance there. It was good to see a running game from Edinburgh, just to need to work on the mistakes especially the three nearest the try lines but after last weeks result anything was going to be an improvement. De Luca's try was the best and lets hope there are more to come.
8

W.Robertson,

20/09/2008 09:05:17
I think Edinburgh stepped up for this one. Robertson did very well and deserved his man of the match, however, I'm really not sure about Turnbull starting on the wing. I think we could do with Webster back. Southwell had a great game at 13 (considering it's not his position). Tackled and kicked brilliantly and I think he and De Luca worked well together.

Can imagine Andy Robinson's slightly happier with this weeks's performance. Hopefully they can keep it up.

9

Spoot,

Third rock pool on the left 20/09/2008 09:13:40
No, it isn't the try-line, it's the goal line - take a look at the laws of the game, Mr Ferguson. And while we're about it, let's also banish references to the sidelines (touch lines) and linesmen (touch judges).
10

Venachar,

20/09/2008 11:00:19
Thought there looked like more people in the stands than that crowd figure. Certainly a few positives to take from the match.
No yellow for the straight arm on Andy Turnbull yet a few minutes later Scott Newlands gets a yellow card for what? Persistant offending by the team from what I could see.
Was Mr Lewis asleep in the ref and coaches forum. He seems to make contrary decisions when at Murrayfield, Scotland v France, Edinburgh v Cardiff last year and last night some of his calls were downright weird, not just my opinion but the ref sitting behind me also.
11

Lederblix,

. 20/09/2008 12:27:14
didn't see the game but the reports suggest that Mossy got more action than when he's on the wing - how did he go?
12

Flinty,

EDINBURGH 20/09/2008 13:04:17
Mossy had the best game I can remember him having in a long time. He looks much better at full back than on the wing which seems to suit his style of running. He also had some great kicks to the touch lines.
13

J.A.,

22/09/2008 10:05:58
This is a good result for Edinburgh. I agree that the best position for Mossy is full back.
Not very big crowd was it? Perhaps this will be enough to stop “Venachar” from continuing his pathetic jibing at the poor Border crowds. Until we realise that this is not solely an Edinburgh or Glasgow problem but one which is affecting the whole country, we won’t begin to find a solution.
14

Jockbok,

22/09/2008 11:16:01
The 11th October sees two Edinburgh derbies (Muir v Heriots or Accies v Watsonians)being played on the same afternoon of the Edinburgh match. I cannot see how this will help the attendance at Murrayfield (or elsewhere). Perhaps some kind of innovation may be implemented. Muir to play the night before under their lights?
15

J.A.,

22/09/2008 15:36:23
#14
You’re bang on; clubs working in tandem with the SRU to stop a clash would help.
However, this will resolve the underlying problem of poor attendances.
Unfortunately, the SRU have jumped on and off the bus (pro rugby) far too often and we have now slipped too far behind other nations. Making up the ground we have lost is not going to be easy without a huge injection of cash into the right areas. Cash they don’t have!!

16

J.A.,

22/09/2008 15:38:59
What I what actually trying to say was.
"this will not resolve the underlying problem of poor attendances"

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.