Margo backs proposal to let doctors help patients die

Published on Thursday 5 January 2012 12:06

INDEPENDENT Lothians MSP Margo MacDonald today welcomed a UK report proposing that doctors should be allowed to help terminally ill patients to die, providing they have less than a year to live due to severe illness or injury.

The independent Commission on Assisted Dying, chaired by Labour peer Lord Falconer, said the measures would replace the “inadequate and incoherent” laws surrounding loved ones helping patients to end their lives, which can lead to prosecution.

Some senior MSPs north of the Border have expressed concerns over the findings, saying such policy decisions should be left to medical professionals.

But the proposals were backed by Ms MacDonald, who put forward a bill on assisted dying to the Scottish Parliament two years ago. That bill was voted down overwhelmingly, but Ms MacDonald, who suffers from Parkinson’s disease, is planning to bring back fresh proposals in the near future.

She said Lord Falconer’s report was a chance to revisit the issue. She said: “He and I have gone about our objectives in different ways but I am certainly willing to learn from anything unexpected that he uncovers in his investigation and I know that he has been interested in both of our bills in Scotland.

“I think my second attempt reflects what we learned from the debate and the evidence giving during the first bills progress in Holyrood.

“As a result I think this second bill will be an improvement and meets some of the practical concerns expressed to us by various groups.

“In the process of pursuing patient autonomy and the rights of the patient to determine when to end a life that has become intolerable to him or her as a result of their irreversible condition, I think our proposal may be slightly ahead of Lord Falconer’s work so far.”

Today’s report from the commission said a number of high profile cases involving the Dignitas clinic in Switzerland meant a law change was necessary. But it added stringent safeguards must be in place to protect those who might not have the mental capacity to make such a choice, or who might be clinical depressed.

Conservative MSP Alex Johnstone said: “My primary concern is that we should trust the medical profession rather than going down this route, which has been tried unsuccessfully in other countries.”

Related Articles

• Margo facing up to her toughest battle

  THE scene is the epitome of suburbia. An elderly woman with the merest hint of a blue rinse stands at the kitchen table and rolls out a clear plastic bag which the casual viewer might assume is designed to hold a chicken or turkey but is, in fact, for the human head.

  0 Comments

• Should carers be free to help loved ones die?

  SHE seemed unnaturally articulate for so early in the day, and for someone who has been in failing health for years. But in interviews yesterday morning, prior to a two-day hearing at the High Court in London, Debbie Purdy presented a compelling case for a change in the law on the so-called right to die.

  0 Comments

• MacDonald to push ahead with her bid to make assisted suicide legal

  AN MSP launched a consultation on plans to make assisted suicide legal yesterday, saying helping someone to die could be "the last caring act" a doctor carries out for their patient.

  0 Comments

• When pain becomes a matter of life and death

  MARGO MacDonald's bill to legalise assisted suicide is due to come before the Scottish Parliament this month, but opinion on the subject is still sharply polarised, writes Eddie Barnes

  0 Comments

• Catholic Church vows to block Margo MacDonald's end-of-life bill

  THE Catholic Church last night vowed to challenge in court any move to legalise assisted suicide, after veteran MSP Margo MacDonald launched her right-to-die bill. The Church has questioned the legality of the proposed law that could introduce suicide clinics to Scotland and see those as young as 16 given the right to decide to have their lives ended.

  0 Comments

Comments

There are 3 comments to this article

Order by:

• Newest first
• |
• Oldest first

Page 1 of 1

• 1
• Show all

3

A Voice of Reason

Friday, January 6, 2012 at 10:06 AM

So sensible to see this being examined again. It's about time we had this available. Last time I looked we were a free society so as long as there are the right safeguards its the individuals right to choose. Thank goodness for independent minded MSP's iike Margo to support this.

• Report Unsuitable

2

Paulpool

Thursday, January 5, 2012 at 08:57 PM

If i am that ill...no one and i mean no one including the religious nuts has a right to but in..that includes the goverment to...stay the hell out of my business,you are already to involved as it is...give me the shot and off to sleep i go...the planet does not need another sick and dying human wasting resourses...

• Report Unsuitable

1

SlyFifer

Thursday, January 5, 2012 at 01:08 PM

The right to choose the style of one's end given safegaurds is written into the proposals drafted by the Scottish Democratic Alliance in their submission on the Constitution for Scotland submitted to the Constitutional Commission, in 2010. Has Margo made similar submissions or is she a lone voice ?

• Report Unsuitable

Order by:

• Newest first
• |
• Oldest first

Page 1 of 1

• 1
• Show all

Logged in as:

Comment here. Start typing your comment here:

Post comment

Please adhere to our Community guidelines

Your view

Please sign in to be able to comment on this story.