Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement

 
 
Sunday, 23rd November 2008

Claim a Free Glayva Miniature

Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the The Scotsman site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

'Misguided' Bank must act on rates, says Blanchflower



Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 29 August 2008
DAVID Blanchflower, the monetary policy committee "dove", warned yesterday that only a dramatic cut in interest rates could stave off the worst effects of a recession and predicted that unemployment could reach two million by Christmas.
Exposing the growing tensions within the MPC, Professor Blanchflower described fears expressed by fellow members that rate cuts would further stimulate inflation as "misguided".

Blanchflower, who has been the lone voice on the MPC calling for a reduction in borrowing costs, was scathing about the Bank of England's forecasts of flat growth, saying they were "wishful thinking".

Speaking ahead of next week's interest-rate-setting meeting, he hinted he would advocate a cut of at least a half a percentage point from the current 5 per cent rate.

Blanchflower revealed that he felt he was carrying the weight of the British people on his shoulders when he sought to convince the other eight members of the MPC of his case.

In an interview with the Reuters news agency, Blanchflower said: "To sit and worry about inflation expectations and what is going to happen to those, rather than worry about the fact that the economy is going to go into a recession seems to be misguided."

He added: "The way to get out of it is to act. Sitting by doing nothing is not going to get us out of this, and hoping that a knight in shining armour will come and lift us out of this is optimistic in the extreme."

Blanchflower warned that two million people could be unemployed by the end of the year, an increase of more than 300,000 on the current 1.67 million figure.

The MPC has voted to hold rates unchanged at 5 per cent for the past four months as inflation – currently at 4.4 per cent and set to peak above 5 per cent – soars.

Blanchflower said much of the debate about the rising cost of living was "very short-sighted". He said Britain could learn from the Federal Reserve and interest rates should be substantially lower than the current 5 per cent.

He added: "The question is what's going to happen in prices … 18 months down the road and the answer is inflation is going to plummet like a rock.

"I've obviously voted on quite a number of occasions now for small cuts but we need to act and we probably need to act in larger amounts than that. We need to get ahead of the game and it appears that we are now behind."


The full article contains 429 words and appears in The Scotsman newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 28 August 2008 8:45 PM
  • Source: The Scotsman
  • Location: Edinburgh
  • Related Topics: Interest rates
 
1

Highland Property Bubble,

Inverness 29/08/2008 01:00:41
The remit of the Bank of England is to control inflation.
As the current official figure for inflation surges towards 5%, the base rate should in fact be raised sharply in order to bring the debt-based economy back into line.
Those who are living in the real world and buying things such as food, clothes, fuel and perhaps heating their homes will know that the official figure of 4.4% is a complete mirage, but that's another discussion.
2

Charlie Ferrier,

Hamilton 29/08/2008 06:17:46
The interest rates need to go up and do so sharply - this will undoubtedly reduce inflation which is what the economy needs. It will also allow the currency to become stronger which is also a good thing allowing the better buying ability to offset the reduced cash availible in the economy. Overall it will be very beneficial
3

SouthernSkye,

29/08/2008 08:03:27
Agreed, interest rates up and try to squash the credit based system and move to a "pay as you earn" economy.
This would also encourage saving. This may impact the high-street gross turnover, especially in leisure, but we need to pull back from throwing cash around until the dust settles, debt is reduced and housing has reached a genuine plateau with interference.
The actual Cost of living is up by around 10%, houses down by more than 10%. The official 4.4% figure is a grossly twisted one.
4

SouthernSkye,

29/08/2008 08:04:22
sorry, that should have read
...housing reaches a genuine plateau without interference (from HMG/financial institutions)....
5

David Harrington,

Edinburgh 29/08/2008 12:39:47
#1 Raising interest rates will do little to do inflation as much of the cause is outside of domestic control, having more to do with world fuel and food prices. Your nom de plume suggests you are a one trick pony who should perhaps look at the bigger picture as nobody I know wants a recession in the UK.
6

easy money,

brazil 29/08/2008 13:31:51
no. 5 - absolutely right...
7

A Friend of Fernando Poo,

29/08/2008 13:43:47
The economy needs a recession. It's the continued desperate attempts to avoid one since 1998 that's got us into this mess in the first place.

Also the banks need more savings to supply the mortgage market. How do they get more savings? They increase the payoff to savers by raising interest rates.
8

edinburghiscommon,

29/08/2008 15:19:26
no 5. Maybe before trying to give lessons of economics to people you should probably understand it yourself?

If interest rates are raised, the value of the pound will increase against other currencies therefore making our imports (food) much cheaper. Also no other EU countries had energy prices rises like ours (if any at all), simply because they store gas for the winter whereas the UK buys its own gas back at 3 times the price...plus nothing can be done to save the property market expect leaving it crash completely.
9

Highland Saint,

Black Isle 29/08/2008 16:05:25
#5 Good comment
#8 clearly you are in a unique position to make such statements 'nothing can be done to save the property market' so lets just leave it then. Thank goodness your not on the policy group!
10

The Strategist,

29/08/2008 18:49:28
The issue is one of trust in the banking system.

If interest rates were reduced could we trust the banks not to revert to their bad old ways and start re-inflating the credit bubble, driving house prices back up and so on and so forth?

My own view is that we shouldn't trust them further than we could throw them.
11

Active Sassenach,

Luton, England 29/08/2008 21:34:32
David Blanchflower assumes the economy will respond to a cut in interest rates by expanding or, at least, not going into recession.

If the cost of money were the only factor inhibiting business from investment, he might be right. The main factor inhibiting business is that we no longer have any business. It has all emigrated to China. It is not like olden times, when we were just out of Bretton Woods. Then we had a Bank of England "Corset". We were only just defining M0 as a test of narrow money alongside our favoured measures of broad money and bank deposits in M2 and M3. Then we had MTFS. Not only do we not now have a government with a medium term financial strategy, we have a Chancellor of the Exchequer who doesn't even know what day of the week it is.

Those were the days when we manufactured and traded. We could cut interest rates and invest. Then the consequent weakening of the currency further boosted exports so the Government could print a few quid for tax cuts and hold an election before the downstream inflation from increased import costs forced them to raise rates again. Then we were at the mercy of other countries who got their own back by doing the same. Now they all have the EURO - we do not. So they now have 13 times the leverage on getting their own back.

Mr Blanchflower, please resign from the MPC. Your memory has lost its short-term capacity and is reverting to long-term embedded memory that it mistakes for the short-term. We no longer make things to sell. LIBOR is so far ahead of base that we are in uncharted banking liquidity puddles. It is not clear that base any longer has any relevance to financial markets or the economy.

In the short term a cut in interest rates might lead a few self-deluded people to think they can spend more. Mr Blanchflower, you know perfectly well how high a dead cat bounces and that cutting interest rates now will just lead to a W shaped recovery and not a V shaped one. Please resign from the MPC before it is
12

Active Sassenach,

Luton, England 29/08/2008 21:37:57
Please resign from the MPC before it is....

too late.

Sorry, I missed a bit out.
13

Highland Property Bubble,

Inverness 29/08/2008 22:42:17
#5 Mr Harrington. With respect to your posting.
The sole remit of the Bank of England is to keep inflation at a respectable level. The Bank was not given its’ powers in order to bolster a grossly over-inflated property market.
With regards to your accusation that I want a recession in the UK, let me assure you that I am the last person who would wish for such an outcome. The reality is however that we have built an economy based on over-inflated property values which have been driven by unsustainable debt.
If the re-alignment of this country’s economic base through higher interest rates should lead to recession then so be it.
14

Evan Owen,

Snowdonia 30/08/2008 08:33:18
It worries me that this man is on the MPC!
15

Alan B,

31/08/2008 17:20:39
#Highland Property Bubble

"As the current official figure for inflation surges towards 5%, the base rate should in fact be raised sharply in order to bring the debt-based economy back into line."

The problem with your analyse is interest rates changes tend to effect the inflation rate 2yrs down the line.

As such because inflation is higher now than target does not necessarily mean interest rates should be raised again.

Inflation is generally where the economy grows faster than the production side of the economy. If we are slowing down, as we are then inflation will tend to fall.

There are many more issues. For instance domestic inflation in service sector has been higher and the official inflation rate kept lower by cheap import of clothes and consumer goods from China etc.

One yrs food price inflation will fall out the figures next yr. So it is the general inflation rate that is important.

Brown should really have put in place policies to control house price inflation. But that is a different matter.
16

Alan B,

31/08/2008 17:23:02
#edinburghiscommon

"If interest rates are raised, the value of the pound will increase against other currencies "

Not necessarily and probably only in the extreme short term.

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 

Features

Featured Advertising



Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.