Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement

 
 
Sunday, 23rd November 2008

Claim a Free Glayva Miniature

Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the The Scotsman site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

Will Sony's new device spell the end of the traditional book?



Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 02 September 2008
IT IS small enough to fit in a handbag or a large pocket – but contains the contents of around 160 books.
The race to convert book-lovers to electronic novels will intensify on Thursday with the launch of the £199 Sony Reader.

But writers are split on whether the gadget will ever challenge the traditional paperback as the favoured way to read a novel.

Roughly the size of an average paperback, it has 200 megabytes, enough to store 160 books of average length, and more capacity can be added in the form of memory cards. The device can also store and play back pictures and music files.

By connecting it to a home computer, owners will be able to download "ebooks" from the website of the bookshop chain Waterstone's, which will be selling the device.

The Reader uses display technology called electronic ink or "e-ink", meaning it uses power only when pages are turned. A single battery life should be enough for 1,680 page turns.

Each Reader will be sold with a CD containing 100 free books, including Dracula, Great Expectations, Pride And Prejudice and Romeo And Juliet.

Waterstone's has managed to beat Amazon – which has been selling its Kindle device in the United States for several months – to the British market.

Toby Bourne, category manager at Waterstone's, said: "We are very impressed with the Reader and think our customers will be too.

"We're working with publishers to develop the best range of ebooks – classics and new bestsellers."

However, writers were divided over the invention.

Toby Young, author of How To Lose Friends And Alienate People, said: "In the long run, electronic books will benefit writers, creating an easier way to enable first-time authors to get their work in front of the public. That will be a revolutionary change."

But Nick Hornby, whose books include Fever Pitch and About A Boy, was less convinced.

He wrote recently: "There is currently much consternation in the industry about the future of the conventional book, but my suspicion is that it will prove to be more tenacious than the CD.

"Readers of books like books, whereas music fans never had much affection for CDs."

Waterstone's said it had pre-orders for thousands of Readers, but admitted it was struggling to finalise pricing of ebooks.

A spokesman said: "We aim to make them cheaper than their physical counterparts, although people will have to pay VAT.

"We plan to have every new title available the day it launches, so you should be able to download everything you see in store."

Earlier this month, the CitiGroup financial services company predicted Amazon would sell 380,000 electronic books during 2008.

However, Amazon is notoriously reticent about publishing figures and some experts believe there could be as few as 50,000 electronic books in circulation.

Marc Lambert, chief executive officer of the Scottish Book Trust, said: "It's definitely a future; I don't know if it's the future.

"I think it's a good thing. It is still reading, it is just another platform, like the iPod, which has come into rapid use. It does take the tactile pleasure away of turning a book's pages, but at the same time it's making the book accessible on a different kind of platform.

"It can never replace the book as it was invented, because people will always enjoy the physical experience of reading a book, which you are going to miss on this."


The full article contains 585 words and appears in The Scotsman newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 02 September 2008 12:23 AM
  • Source: The Scotsman
  • Location: Edinburgh
 
1

Conan the Librarian™,

02/09/2008 00:33:06
I have some lovely leather bound books on my shelves at home.

Would I read them on the bus? Doubtful.

Use this wee piece of tech? Certainty.
2

subrosa,

02/09/2008 00:33:32
If the font on these was able to be increased, to avoid many of us using glasses, then it would be a best seller. Doubt that it can be though. Doesn't say anything in the blurb.
3

Charles Linskaill,

Edinburgh 02/09/2008 00:36:20

Darned Amazing! soon we wont need 'Brains' to be clever or stupid, we can have a fab electronic implant instead!

That said, Will anyone ever know what goes on in our Boy Wonders head,?

His 'bytes' have become scrambled, he says my DYW is 62, he means 26 and a few years!, he says I am 94, he means 49 + or - a few years!, he says too much, his recipes are getting ridiculous, and yet he still has the 'brain' to be Mr Mean and stash all his dosh under his mattress!

"BOOKS" Boy Wonder Loves! as he reiterated some time ago, and called me 'sad'

Question is,? Will the Great Boy Wonder Purchase this electronic marvel,?

NO! he likes the "Books" covered in 'cobwebs' that anti Jean left him, in her,...'Will' :)
4

Charles Linskaill,

Edinburgh 02/09/2008 00:40:14

BTW! all watch out for my "Book" to be published soon,..

'THE AMAZING ADVENTURES OF CHARLES LINSKAILL'

Its Sure to-be a sellout! :)
5

Charles Linskaill,

Edinburgh 02/09/2008 00:43:01

"AMAZING" INDEED IF WE GET PREGNANT!
6

Conan the Librarian™,

02/09/2008 00:44:02
2
subrosa, I'm sure you can choose any size font you wish.
3
Charles, BW's favourite books are written by Garth Ennis, Neil Gaiman or Alan Moore.

Good stuff.
7

Charles Linskaill,

Edinburgh 02/09/2008 00:49:11

Conan ~6,

YES! We all know his favorite chocolate bar is,..


'Galaxy'
8

Charles Linskaill,

Edinburgh 02/09/2008 00:53:59

Boy Wonder thinks about,...'Spacemen'!

I think about 'Babies'!

What more can be said,? Two 'Loons' in their beds!
9

Charles Linskaill,

Edinburgh 02/09/2008 01:15:08

Pinball Wizard ~9,

You got that in one! :)
10

Conan the Librarian™,

02/09/2008 01:15:15
9
Welcome. Make yourself at home.
11

Conan the Librarian™,

02/09/2008 02:09:36
12
Vir sapit qui pauca loquitor ;-)

12

Charles Linskaill,

Edinburgh 02/09/2008 02:09:59

Pinball Wizard ~various,

'Ha Ha' very funny!

If our 'Babies' are like my DYW, the 'Bus Driver' and Lothian Buses will have no-chance, of refusing our army of "Babies" on their bus!

'Hell knows NO fury, like a womans warth'

And if DYW is correct, our babies will all be fighting females! :((
13

eric,

02/09/2008 07:28:00
Lets pray the bible goes 1st .
14

Boy Wonder,

02/09/2008 07:35:14
#2 Subrosa. Yes, the reader magnifies the page for you. This device is great. I have pre-ordered them for my entire family. Not that they'll replace our beloved book library entirely (not yet anyway) but they're great for taking a book out into the countryside on a good day (when we get one) for a good read!

#6. Actually not, Conan. Their comic output is one of my guilty pleasures ... Gaiman and Moore are hard to beat ... but I prefer Grant Morrison, Warren Ellis, Geoff Johns, Brad Meltzer, Roger Stern, John Byrne, Gail Simone, Joe Strazcynski, Greg Rucka, Mark Waid, Jim Shooter, Bill Willingham and a league of comic book writers and artists .. but I also like Feist, Eddings, Cooper, Asimov, Clarke, and a host of other novelists. My Reader will need a constant supply of batteries.

#9. Not Psychos ... only one PSYCHO and by that, you'll mean the Hootsmon's resident ranter-in-chief ... #3 who's off the meds again, Chuckles ... aren't you? We can tell you know ... we're used to you. Despite that ... good luck for this week, mate! We're all rooting for good news for you and the DYW. May all the forgotten gods of R'lyeh grant you old fogies new life!
15

Rulesbutnotrulers,

Federation, not separation 02/09/2008 07:36:28
Will this machine break if I drop it? My books don't.
16

Boy Wonder,

02/09/2008 07:39:22
Have you noticed how much the Reader looks like the PADD (personal access display device) from Star Trek?? The earliest 2151 version anyway.

How cool is that?? Tech imitating art from 4 decades ago! :D
17

The McKellarator,

02/09/2008 07:47:57
Hmmm since the Gutenburg archive is free to access from t'internet and I can download that on to my blackberry why should I bother?

I look forward to the 'i-wipe', the new digital bahooky cleaner.
18

Dr Mike,

Edinburgh 02/09/2008 07:58:29
Square eyes using computer VDU/laptop all day, now square eyes from reading books on a screen. I find my eyes get tired from all those rays! Another thing to recharge!!!!
19

Conan the Librarian™,

02/09/2008 08:06:22
20
I think Captain Kirk had something similar to get rid of stuborn Klingons.
20

Conan the Librarian™,

02/09/2008 08:06:57
Stubborn
21

Duncan in Edinburgh,

02/09/2008 08:11:52
#21 The idea behind the "e-ink" tech is that it is far easier on the eyes than a typical computer screen.

That said, e-book readers have been around for many years, and so has the e-ink technology, and they simply haven't taken off. I suspect it has a lot to do with weight and price. £200 is far too much for this sort of replacement tech. If the costs of materials can't be reduced, then perhaps a mobile phone model where the hardware cost is covered in a monthly subscription charge might be more successful.

My advice would be to wait until a cheaper, lighter device emerges - possibly one with a roll-out or fold-out screen - shouldn't be too far away.
22

Getalifetoday,

Edinburgh 02/09/2008 08:39:41
There must be more for you chaps to do in the day? please visit www.needtogetoutmore.com
23

Montford's Jaicket,

Hanging around 02/09/2008 08:45:46
Not for me - I can't imagine anybody wanting to spend time looking at text on a screen all day, rather than open a book and read it. Next thing they'll try to put newspapers online!
What happens if you want to annotate your copy? When these books come out on film, will we be able to watch the DVD on our new I-book?
24

Toast,

02/09/2008 08:48:46
not convinced this will ever catch on,the young who like gadgets don't read/can't read and older readers don't like gadgets,I like books not gimmicks
25

Major (Retd) Michael Hamilton, KOSB,

Stichill, Kelso 02/09/2008 08:53:40
If you move into a smaller house e.g. on retirement, you may, as we did, find that you have insufficient space for all your favourite books. This device may be attractive in those circumstances. We are certainly getting one each. We are also giving one each to our son and daughter-in-law to take to China for their next three year spell there, not only for their use but also for our two grandchildren. Horses for courses - it will not suit everyone - but you don't have to buy it.
26

Jay Kay,

02/09/2008 09:00:18
Roddenberry was way ahead of his time. He portrayed this and other things that have come to past way back in the sixties. Good vision.
27

Forrest,

Livingston 02/09/2008 09:27:23
Which out of this reader and a book works better if you drop it in a bath?

Readers have been available on PDAs for years.
28

connaughtboy,

stonehaven 02/09/2008 09:38:47
No.
29

Mad Jock,

East Lothian 02/09/2008 10:00:34
I have ordered one of these machines, as it suits my purposes. I have a huge collection of books at home, and always travel to work with at least six books. We have a weight limit for our helicopter flights out to the rigs, and books eat into that considerably, plus it's a lot of weight to lug around airports anyway.
If I read a new book that I particularly like, I can always buy the real thing later, perhaps at a disacount some years down the line from Amazon and the like.
I agree that it's not for everyone. I wouldn't be seen dead with an iPod, but that doesn't mean to say that it isn't a good gadget.
This particular gadget will succeed of fail on the availability of books, from all sources and formats. If it attempts to remain proprietory, then I suspect that people will start to look elsewhere. I want to know that wherever I am in the world, I can download a new book, whether at work, home or some internet cafe in Outer Mongolia.
30

JoeMiddleton,

Edinburgh 02/09/2008 10:05:27
Yes, you will be able to change the size of the fonts, no it won't replace the traditional book. The Kindle has been out for a while but it hasn't really taken off so I doubt Sony's version will either.
31

Evan Owen,

Snowdonia 02/09/2008 10:26:06
Books are recyclable you can burn them to keep warm when you can't afford the gas, what do you do with this when the battery is flat and you can't afford the electrickery to recharge it?

People said the internet would kill off books, EB in particular. It hasn't.
32

Memyself&I,

02/09/2008 10:43:35
Will Sony's new device spell the end of the traditional book?

No.
33

Major (Retd) Michael Hamilton, KOSB,

Edinburgh 02/09/2008 10:54:43
Hi Mad Jock, Your post mentioning Outer Mongolia may seem far fetched. But my son and daughter-in-law have friends there whom they visit in the school holidays - and they will be taking their Sony BookThingie with them! Cheers matey, Michael.
34

Navvy,

02/09/2008 11:48:43
NO
like all electronics they will be susceptable to moisture, dropping, theft.
A damp book can be dried and one dropped in the river fished out and dried too
35

EK,

Edinburgh 02/09/2008 12:23:09
The printed word on paper has been around for 400 years. That habit won't die out in a lifetime. I prefer books as I am used to them and they are less strain on the eyes than the electronic versions. Also books are more tactile.
36

Mad Jock,

East Lothian 02/09/2008 12:55:58
The tape recorder, the gramophone, the 8 track, the cassette, the CD, the MP3 and the iPod have not managed to kill off the Orchestra or Rock Band. However, all of us have had our music supplied to us through at least one of these mediums over the years. At the end of the day, you can take your iPod with you anywhere, but you can't take an orchestra with you everywhere. The book will survive very well with or without the e-Book.
To all who moan about this new technology (it's not really THAT new), I say "Luddite".
37

Salvatori,

02/09/2008 13:19:39
No doubt this will suit some people's needs, but for me I wouldn't bother.

Reading speed as well documented is slower when viewing content in a monitor or browser setting (I for one prefer to download a document from the web rather than viewing it in situ in a browser due to this fact) and all the scrolling up and down with a device like this will prove annoying.
38

Nessie 309,

Oak Park,IL USA 02/09/2008 15:38:57
Hi Folks...
I bought my wife this last Christmas (2007)- she is an avid reader... She just loves it - You can also load pics (which, due to the screen) show as black and grey... and you can load music too...-It has a headset connection...

The Reader is very easy on the eyes and nothing like using a pc monitor... The downside is that you need to acquire books through the p.c. and they only come from Sony's e-library - but they have thousands and all the latest offerings... the price varies but it's about 7-10 GBP each...

They also e-mail you weekly of new releases and best sellers to preview...

The free books are mostly classics that the majority of us have read before or find too "heavy" going.

When I bought it I paid about the same price you are getting offered it for.

You can have it inscribed - you charge it up just like a cell phone so don't need to buy batteries regularly

Great for taking on holiday -or in her case back and forward on the train to work.

I doubt if it will kill the hard copy industry - but it will save a load of trees...
Regards
Bill (originally from Ayrshire)
39

motherload,

mountains 02/09/2008 16:08:27
. ..was having a good read, dropped my 'book' in the river, jumped in after, was saved by a tree fallen naturally in the middle, pulled myself out, built a fire to dry out my soaked jeans from drift wood, walked back to the road, hitch-hiked to nearest town, had refreshing bowl of soup at the bistro, climbed the stairs to my comfortable apartment, ordered new books online to replace electronic marvel, went to local library full of historic paper, had coffee, read free book checked out for two weeks, enjoyed end of summer down by the river, strolled for shells, found piece of electronic garbage, threw it away... busy day. wrote about it on scotsman... entertained a few...or not
40

Joanna,

Cambs, England 02/09/2008 16:51:10
I think this is a good idea if you're going on hols or in something like the armed services and have to be light on packing.

However, I understand that the e-books are the same prices as 'normal' books, so that would be a consideration for me. I buy most of my books second-hand, its amazing how quickly you can find the latest bestseller in a charity shop or secondhand booksellers. I also use my local library a lot, so the only advantage I can see, in my case is maybe being able to get hold of out of print titles via this system. As it is I think I'll just stick with the hard copies and the occasional excitement of finding a first edition in a used bookshop.
41

Balan,

San Diego 02/09/2008 17:53:16
I have one for over a year and recently upgraded to their latest model. The size of the text can be adjusted to three different levels. It is the best way to take books on a plane or vacation. With up to 16 GB of memory, if you want you can take the Library of Congress in your pocket.

I recommend it highly.
42

Whiskymac17,

Kinghorn, Fife. 02/09/2008 17:57:45
I don't think the readers will replace paper books, but they will compliment them. I lecture in my local college and often carry several sets of notes plus a fiction book for relaxation. With a Reader I'll be able to carry them all in one light-weight device.
I've tried reading eBooks on my PC monitor and my laptop and it's not a pleasant experience, I've also used a PDA and found the screen too small for comfortable reading. The Sony reader does not have a back-lit screen making it easy on the eyes. Neither are you restricted to books sold by Sony or Waterstones, it will display PDF and MS Word documents. I already have a collection of books and material that I can use, so I am waiting with excitement for delivery of my shiny new reader any day now, and I'm not a young 'geek', I'm 63 and intend to get many years of use out of my reader.
43

Whiskymac17,

Kinghorn 02/09/2008 18:09:12
An interesting point that I neglected to mention. In USA the libraries are starting to offer eBooks on loan. These can be downloaded through the internet and are readable for a fixed period of time, after which they expire and self-destruct. I think this suggests that there is a demand for eBooks and a future for the eReaders.
44

Conan the Librarian™,

02/09/2008 19:27:00
Here's a free library specialising in SF and Fantasy.

http://www.baen.com/library/defaultTitles.htm
45

energizer,

edinburgh 02/09/2008 20:28:48
The answer to the question in the headline is 'no'. Next?
46

Fairfax,

04/09/2008 13:00:24
Conan (47): "Here's a free library specialising in SF and Fantasy."

Hi Conan; thanks for the link.

I'm tempted by the Sony Reader, particularly when on holiday say, but the price is too high at £199. For comparison, the Asus mini-notebook, is now selling for just under £300:

http://www.pcpro.co.uk/reviews/206229/asus-eee-pc-901.html

Still, perhaps the £199 will drop rapidly.
47

Dan'l,

Nova Scotia 07/09/2008 02:21:12
So, what's new? I've been reading ebooks on my palm pilot for 4 years and have close to a thousand titles in my library .....
The only thing new is Sony is finally catching up with the world

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.