Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


Seven changes to Lions team but McGeechan still can't find place for a Scot

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 03 July 2009
BRITISH and Irish Lions head coach Ian McGeechan has made wholesale changes for tomorrow's final match of the series against world champions South Africa, but the absence once again of any Scots means that there will now be a desperately grim period of 12 years without a Scot starting a Test match for the Lions.
No Scots started any of the three Test matches on the Lions' last tour four years ago to New Zealand, with Gordon Bulloch making an appearance from the bench in the final match. The last time a Scot started a Test match for the Lions was when Tom Smi
th played in all three matches against Australia in 2001 – and even then, he was the sole Scottish representative in the Test teams. With the next Lions tour not until they travel to Australia in 2013, a dozen years will have passed since a Scot started a Test match in the famous red shirt.

This year, McGeechan picked only two Scottish players – Nathan Hines and Euan Murray – in his original squad of 37, and as feared, the Scots in the party were included as back-up rather than Test-match material, even though Hines and Murray were joined in the travelling squad by late call-ups Ross Ford and Mike Blair. Tomorrow's final Test is now relatively meaningless after South Africa clinched the series last week, but former Scotland coach McGeechan has gone no further than naming Ford on the bench, while Hines and Blair are left out entirely.

A wrist injury has sidelined Wales centre Jamie Roberts, so England's Riki Flutey forges a new midfield combination with Ireland's Tommy Bowe, who switches from the wing.

Ugo Monye, dropped after the first Test defeat, returns in the No14 shirt, with world player of the year Shane Williams starting instead of Luke Fitzgerald on the other wing.

England props Andrew Sheridan and Phil Vickery take over from injured pair Gethin Jenkins and Adam Jones, while back-row changes see starts for Wasps flanker Joe Worsley and Wales openside Martyn Williams.

The seven changes and one positional alteration mean just five players will have started all three Tests – Bowe, fly-half Stephen Jones, scrum-half Mike Phillips, skipper Paul O'Connell and No8 Jamie Heaslip.

The Lions must win at Ellis Park to avoid suffering a Test series whitewash for the first time in 118 years of fixtures between the sides.

Vickery returns for another confrontation with Springboks loosehead Tendai "The Beast" Mtawarira, who scrummaged the Englishman into oblivion in Durban a fortnight ago. "It is fair to say injuries have had an impact on the tour, as you would expect," said McGeechan. "We were unfortunate to lose Brian O'Driscoll, Jamie Roberts, Gethin Jenkins and Adam Jones through injury last Saturday.

"However, the players coming into the starting XV are all talented international players and are as keen as ever to turn the tables on the Springboks. Last Saturday, we were minutes away from winning, and that is a huge positive to take into the third Test."

McGeechan has opted for five forwards on the bench – hooker Ford, prop John Hayes, lock Alun-Wyn Jones, plus flankers Tom Croft and David Wallace, who drop out of the starting team. Scrum-half Harry Ellis and fly-half James Hook will provide back division cover.

Four players – Flutey, Sheridan, Worsley and Martyn Williams – all make their full Lions Test debuts.

McGeechan added: "We've tried to freshen it up – there have been some tight calls over the first two Tests. We gave the players a break earlier in the week, but we are back to it now and very keen to finish with a win."

Both McGeechan and Lions manager Gerald Davies, meanwhile, moved to ease any tension between the camps following a fraught third Test build-up.

Not only did Burger and Botha collect bans, but Springboks coach Peter de Villiers also suggested there had been no official congratulations from the Lions on South Africa's series win.

But McGeechan countered: "I certainly said 'well done' on the series. Twice, when we were both coming away from different media things (last Saturday], I shook his (De Villiers'] hand and said 'well done'.

"I think it has been a fantastic series. South Africa's finishing has been top-class, as has their defence. To have two games like that, and hopefully have a third, I think everyone will have got a lot from it."

Davies added: "Our relationship with the Springboks has been excellent throughout. We've had a wonderful arrangement with them. I've shaken hands with all the management and the (South Africa Rugby Union] president at every game I have witnessed. Once the whistle has blown, the game is over.

"If there was controversy arising out of the last game, I am saddened about that and disappointed about that because that incident (Burger making contact with the eye area of Fitzgerald], dare I say it, has no place in the game."





Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 03 July 2009 2:30 PM
  • Source: The Scotsman
  • Location: Edinburgh
  • Related Topics: British and Irish Lions
 
1

Fat one,

Edinburgh 03/07/2009 01:48:45
In my opinion a very poor selection. Not sure that Flutey has done too much to warrant a start, Hook, Darcy Fitzgerald and Earls are very unlucky not to make it into the 22. Monye and Williams have had their chances, Monye possible deserves another chance but at the expense of Fitzgerld, I don't think so! Fitzgerald and Earls also cover 15. Williams has done nothing on tour - he should not be in the 22. Forwards have a Wasps bias. Vickery is the only option at 3, like it or not. Worsley should be feeling very lucky especially with Wallace and Croft sitting on the bench. The backs selections will be our undoing!!!!
2

Uninterested Spectator,

03/07/2009 09:24:16
Does McGeechan actually pick the team?

If so how can Shane Williams be any where near the test squad let alone the first IV?

It seems to me that Edwards and Davis pick the team with input from Gatland, after all how can so many wasps players and welshmen possibly be on tour?

Also having Ross Ford as the token jock on the bench is rather daft. Last week the Lions rather had uncontested scrums than playing Ford so i doubt he will appear on saturday. As for Ellis, he is not great so Blair must be annoyed and i still don't understand how Hines doesn't get a start when the boks need to face a bit of aggression.
3

daffy_b,

03/07/2009 10:52:39
there has been far too much nepotisim in this entire selection debacle - from the original pool right down to each team.

FFS - why is S.Williams even on the tour - he has been gash!

If you're not Welsh or a Wasp - you don't have a chance.

Even the ENGLISH BROADASTING CORPORATION (aka BBC) acknowledges this with their headline yesterday of "2 ENGLISHMEN TO PLAY IN FINAL TEST".
4

BarntonBoy,

Here 03/07/2009 11:00:19
It's all a bit of a non event and an irrelevance now anyway. If their playing for pride then I am pretty confident that it will take another knock and as for the jock free selection then we will at least not have to share in the embarrassment.
5

Kenny Boy,

03/07/2009 12:11:25
Agree with all the comments re Williams. Fitzgerald has been very hard done by.
#2 Bringing Ford on would still have resulted in uncontested scrums as he is not a prop. He wouldn't have changed the situation.
6

F.D.L.,

Fitzgerald Darcy Blair Hines? what went wrong boys 03/07/2009 13:02:30
The Saffers will be laughing their collective kocksoff now: Target Vickery (again) and embarrass whats left of what used to be 1st class prop. Sheridan is too easy to wind up, he'll lose it big style and get sin binned for guddling about on the floor. Shaw will simply undo all his hard work by giving away penalties left right and centre. Collectively I'm afraid the 3rd Test may be a trouncing
7

AC19,

Edinburgh 03/07/2009 13:02:47
Very disappointed that Ellis is on the bench rather than Blair for this one.
8

RonSA,

03/07/2009 18:39:27
Watch theBokke backline this week. This is the real deal maybe with Habana at 11 mind you. Watch our Nokwe - he is faster than Habana. Pity Botha has been ruled out by the laughable Hinds - players will be very confused as to the clearing out laws.
Roll on tomorrow - I will be there at Ellis Park

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.